Brooklyn Diner USA Menu – New York, NY

Type : Diner

Location : New York, NY

Set near Carnegie Hall, this nostalgic high-end diner offers both classic & creative dishes. Based on 3 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Brooklyn Diner USA 10019

Address:
212 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019

Phone: (212) 977-1957

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 8 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 8 AM–9 PM
Thursday 8 AM–9 PM
Friday 8 AM–10 PM
Saturday 8 AM–10 PM
Sunday 8 AM–9 PM
Monday 8 AM–9 PM

Menu

Appetizers
Our Famous Chicken Soup With Plenty Of Egg Noodles
thick-sliced challah bread
$12.50
Our Famous Matzo Ball Soup With Plenty Of Chicken $13.50
Quinoa Salad
avocado, cucumber, radish, currants, orange
$9.75
Avocado, Arugula, Romaine Lettuce & Oranges $10.25
Hummus Plate
cucumbers, heirloom carrots, pita
$10.50
Buffalo Chicken Wings $14.50
Guacamole & Tortilla Chips $10.50
Pastrami Egg Roll $14.50
Entree Salads
The Perfect Plate
quinoa salad, little gem salad, hummus, marinated feta cheese
$19.50
The Perfect Plate With Half Avocado
quinoa salad, little gem salad, hummus, marinated feta cheese
$23.45
The Perfect Plate With Chicken Paillard
quinoa salad, little gem salad, hummus, marinated feta cheese
$27.45
The Perfect Plate With Blackened Salmon
quinoa salad, little gem salad, hummus, marinated feta cheese
$28.25
The Perfect Plate With Crab Cake
quinoa salad, little gem salad, hummus, marinated feta cheese
$30.25
Brooklyn Chicken Salad
napa cabbage, red cabbage, snow peas, edamame, cucumber, seaweed, pickled ginger, oranges, marcona almonds, water chestnuts, crispy wontons, cilantro
$23.75
Mexican Burrito Bowl
chicken, avocado, peppers, onions, cheddar cheese, black beans, saffron rice, crema, pico de gallo, tortilla chips
$19.95
Burgers
Hamburger
tomato, lettuce, pickle
$18.95
Cheeseburger
tillamook cheddar, tomato, lettuce, pickle
$19.95
Bacon Cheeseburger Deluxe
tillamook cheddar, tomato, lettuce, pickle
$20.95
French Burger
french fried onions, caramelized onion, cognac sauce, mayo
$23.95
Chicken Burger
lettuce, tomato, pickle
$19.95
Buffalo Chicken Burger
crumbled blue cheese, buffalo hot sauce, pickle
$19.95
Veggie Burger
crumbled blue cheese, buffalo hot sauce, pickle
$19.95
Crab Cake Burger With Slab Burger
lettuce, tomato, tartar sauce
$24.95
Mac N’ Cheese
Pastrami Mac N’ Cheese $22.95
Frankfurter Mac N’ Cheese $22.95
Entrees
House Specialty Chicken Pot Pie
puff pastry crust, baked daily in limited quantities (please excuse us if we sell out)
$23.95
St. Louis Spare Ribs
french fries, cole slaw
$26.95
Pan Seared Teriyaki Salmon
oyster mushrooms, sauteed spinach, wontons
$25.95
Miso Glazed Cod
sauteed spinach
$24.95
Rigatoni Pasta Alla Vodka
with breadcrumbs
$21.95
Eggpplant Parmigiana $20.50
Chicken Pepperoni Parmigiana $24.95
Meatloaf Pepperoni Parmigiana $24.95
Pollo Cubano
grilled chicken & spanish rice, caramelized onions, pico de gallo. cilantro sauce
$21.95
Chicken Burrito
guacamole, cheddar cheese, black beans, saffron rice, crema, pico de gallo, flour tortilla
$19.95
Mexican Burrito Bowl
chicken, avocado, peppers, onions, cheddar cheese, black beans, saffron rice, crema, pico de gallo, tortilla chips
$19.95
Steak Frites
flat iron steak, french fries
$25.95
Breakfast All Day
Eggs Any Style
crispy corn polenta, choice of challah bread or everything bagel
$15.95
Eggs Any Style With Berkshire Slab Bacon
crispy corn polenta, choice of challah bread or everything bagel
$20.95
Eggs Any Style With Housemade Italian Sausage
crispy corn polenta, choice of challah bread or everything bagel
$20.95
Eggs Any Style With Nova Smoked Salmon
crispy corn polenta, choice of challah bread or everything bagel
$21.95
The Omelette
bacon, tillamook cheddar cheese, fines herbes, crispy corn polenta & choice of challah bread or everything bagel
$18.95
Pastrami Hash With Fried Eggs $23.95
Avocado Toast With Fried Eggs & Feta Cheese
add salmon 5.95, add pastrami hash 4.95
$18.95
Fresh Strawberry Waffles
whipped cream, maple syrup
$19.95
Nutella Chocolate Hazelnut Waffles
fresh banana, hazelnuts crumbles, whipped cream, maple syrup
$19.95
Cakes & Cookies
The Strawberry Blonde Cheesecake
strawberries, valrhona fudge
$12.95
Allen Grubman’s Chocolate Blackout Cake
triple-layered valrhona chocolate cake & chocolate ganache frosting
$12.75
Traditional Rugelach
chocolate, raspberry, apple-pineapple
$10.00
Six-Inch Chocolate Chip Cookie $6.95
Best Milkshakes in Town
Vanilla Milkshake $12.00
Chocolate Fudge Milkshake $12.00
Oreo Cookie & Vanilla Milkshake $12.00
The Original Egg Cream
Chocolate Or Vanilla $7.95

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: opentable.com

Reviews

Ellen Huang
Classic diner vibe with typical diner fare. I really liked their strawberry milkshake! Burger and fries were decent, but nothing special. Food was on the pricey side for diner food, although given the restaurant’s prime location, maybe this should not be surprising.

… more

H H
It’s a rather busy restaurant during weekends. We had to wait a while without reservations. The decor is old school type, there are a few healthier option compared to other traditional diner. However, it’s quite pricey in my opinion.

… more

Martin Leonard
Weather was good so sat in the outside area. Service very good and attentive. Had the French Toast and a Bagel with Salmon. Good but not too special to justify the pricing of both items.

… more

abitofjess
UPDATE:

… more

Alicia Trimmiño Jaramillo
When entering the diner you go back in time and you feel like in a classical diner. The waiters are very nice and they make sure that everything is okay! Recommendation if you are getting the hot dog you’ll have to share it because it’s REALLY BIG but the flavor is good!

… more

Maria Barrera
The location is unbeatable. It could be, easily, a tourist trap, but it is not. Greal food, made with care, excellent and attentive service. Good portions. No pressure to leave the table. In lovely Spring days such as today, there is the option to dine in the adjacent outdoor plaza. A joy to behold. Highly recommended!

… more

Peter Falco
Good place with decent portions. Arrived at 11:30 and were seated right away. The staff are courteous and give you time with the menu if you need it. The soup entrees are good portions, but there was a chicken bone in my matzo ball soup. The fries we got as a side were fine, though most were fragmented pieces and therefore a little too crispy.

… more

Daniella Kirby
This place is amazing. The staff are hilarious and give fantastic service. Bartender also makes a great whiskey sour.

… more

Shaun Bothamley
Great diner near central Park. Was seated straight away inside, they do have a nice outdoor area too. Service was quick and polite. Food came quick and tasted good.

… more

Elie Zaghrini
Passed by this diner on my first day in the US, and although quite crowded, I just loved its vibe, its window seats, its beer, and its menu! The prices are reasonable, seeing location and portion size.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions