Brooklyn Pizza located on Route 9W in Newburgh NY serving the Hudson Valley the best Pizza and Subs with a Brooklyn taste.
If you are craving for the tastiest pizza in town, stop by or use your favorite app for delivery.
A Family Owned Pizzeria Restaurant
Eat in, Take Out, Order Online
Use your favorite app for delivery
Based on 152 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
5273 Rte 9W, Newburgh, NY 12550
Phone: (845) 568-3311
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tiffany Parker
AMAZING!! I order from here weekly and the food is fantastic. Great pizza, Great Sauce, Great pepperoni rolls, perfectly made cold subs, and above all Great Customer Services!! They are so kind, so pleasant, super polite, and generous. I couldn’t be happier with the gentleman who run this place, their service, and their food. Well done! (Also posted on yelp)
… more
Sue Ann Berte’
Ordered an Italian combo sub and a small pizza. 1. The pizza crust was burned. 2. For the sandwich, I think, I’d have been better off with QuikChek. I got a single layer each of ham, salami, provolone and pepperoni. With GIANT pieces of iceberg lettuce, and tomatoes. (If I wanted a salad, I would have ordered one!) I barely had any oil and vinegar. I understand that they’re under new management, same name. But the food quality is completely downhill! Time to find a new pizzaria.
… more
Amanda Leia Brubaker
I’ll start off by saying their staff was super friendly. I got a chicken Italian sub and garlic knots there. The knots felt old and dry rather than chewy and moist. The sub itself was also dry between the bread and the breaded chicken. If the owner reads this I’d recommend adding cheese to that sandwich as the default and either more mayo or some sort of oil and vinegar.
… more
Jeff Adelman
This place is under new management and honestly I think they should change the name, just my opinion. At least put a large sign outside under new management. The place had been mediocre at best for a while. The new owners are nice and have excellent quality food & service. Good luck!
… more
Geno Monroe
Stopped in for the 1st time and was pleasantly surprised. The owner is super-friendly. I got a wrap, salad, and a Pepperoni slice. ALL were delish! I ate the whole slice, including the crust.
… more
Brian Scully
Stopped in on a hunch. I was not disappointed! Ordered a couple plain slices and they were excellent! Thin, perfectly cooked, nice sauce and just the right amount of cheese. I will be back for sure
… more
Isa Torres
The only decent food listing we found on our road-trip so decided to stop and eat here. We were pleasantly surprised. Very good pizza, my 6yo loved it.
… more
Joe Leo
I don’t usually write reviews but the bungled order and surliness of the driver inspired me. The order was delivered incomplete. The Doordash driver (they don’t have their own delivery apparently) left the food on the step without knocking and called as he was driving away. I told him the order was incomplete and he hung up on me. I called Slice, who contacted the restaurant was that he forgot the item and I should drive there and pick it up. I PAID for delivery for a reason. They also charged me for extra dressing, petty, which they also left off. Will not be ordering again and suggest you don’t either.
… more
Randy Collazo
Me and my Wife are New Yorkers by birth but now reside in PA. We miss NY pizza! We were in town for my Daughters wedding and leaving to go back home when we thought…hey we haven’t had our pizza. We found Brooklyn Pizza and tried it. Garlic knots…dam good, and we got a large pizza to eat in the way. Thank you guys for giving us our great memory of the pizza that we miss. Would go back!
… more
Katlin Mackey
I want to start by first saying this is a small locally owned business that just like everyone else during Covid I’m sure went through struggles that effected the business. I find some of the previous reviews to be completely unsympathetic to the littlest of complaints. Everyone runs to post an ugly review when “unhappy” to have a voice but I promise you for every one bad review Danny the owner has dozens of great reviews from customers and people who support his hard work and good food. I have zero complaints about the food from Brooklyn Pizza and certainly enjoy my favorite and exclusive “Buffalo Knots.” They are addicting! The Owner Danny comes from a Pizzeria bloodline and continues to work extremely hard at preserving the old school way and family sauce. He treats everyone like family and goes above and beyond for the community. He’s the guy who would give you the shirt off your back and for that he 100% has my business for not only that but great, honest, local delicious pizza! A must go, especially for those Buffalo knows, if you haven’t tried them you’re missing out I promise!!
… more
… View more