Brotherhood of Thieves Menu

In 2021 the Brotherhood and the entire property was given new life. The Brotherhood was recreated to be the best it ever was and three more concepts were added – a beer garden patio, the Notch Whiskey Bar and Cisco Kitchen & Bar. Brotherhood of Thieves is open year -round on Nantucket Island.

Family-friendly pick featuring hearty eats, craft beers, a patio & a cozy fireplace. Based on 540 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ No takeout

Brotherhood of Thieves 02554

Address:
23 Broad St, Nantucket, MA 02554

Phone: (774) 325-5812

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Monday (Labor Day)	11:30 AM–12 AM Hours might differ
Tuesday	11:30 AM–12 AM
Wednesday	11:30 AM–12 AM
Thursday	11:30 AM–12 AM
Friday	11:30 AM–12 AM
Saturday	11:30 AM–12 AM
Sunday	11:30 AM–12 AM

2020 All Day Dinning Menu
Spicy Fried Shrimp & Calamari Point Judith calamari, banana peppers, Meyer Lemon aioli	$14.00
Arty’s Sliders Two jumbo lump crab cakes, southern aioli, fried onion straws served on a king Hawaiian roll	$14.00
Clam Digger’s Stuffed Cherrystones Onions, peppers, chorizo, pickled jalapeno	$9.00
Scallops & Bacon Maple mustard sauce	$13.00
Broho Nachos Fresh fried chips, Monterey jack cheese, house-made corn citrus salsa, pickled jalapenos, sourcream, and fresh avocado	$16.00
Autumn Bruschetta Roasted butternut squash, roasted tomatoes, roasted onions, served atop whipped goat cheese on a grilled baguette. Garnished with pumpkin seeds and pumpkin seed oil.	$11.00
Gochujang Fried Wings Brown sugar, Gochujang glaze, crushed peanuts, cilantro lime aioli	$11.00
Gochujang Cauliflower Brown sugar, Gochujang glaze, crushed peanuts, cilantro lime aioli	$9.00
Island Quahog Chowder	$8.00
Lobster Bisque With Pastry A classic for over 35 years	$13.00
Kettle Soup Of The Day	$7.00
Classic Caesar Salad Housemade dressing, croutons, freshly grated Pecorino Romano	$12.00
House Salad Our own mix of greens, pickled onions, radish, celery, tomatoes, English cucumber, crispy chickpeas, sprouts, Za’atar sherry vinaigrette	$11.00
Mediterranean Bowl Arugula, marinated tomatoes, red onion, cucumber, Kalamata olives, hummus, feta cheese, crispy chickpeas, and pita toast points	$15.00
Tuna Poke Bowl Tamari tossed tuna, sushi rice, pickled vegetables, avocado, sprouts, wasabi pea, and Wakame salad.	$22.00
Spinach And Honeycrisp Apple Salad Spinach, sundried cranberries, spicy pecans, fried panko crusted goat cheese, pickled onions, Za’tar sherry vinaigrette	$15.00
Burger Your Way 100% New England grass fed beef, lettuce, tomato, onion, half sour pickle, creamy coleslaw, curly fries	$14.00
The Arty Caramelized onion, Boursin cheese, red wine demi glace	$15.00
Tuna Burger Fresh ground yellowfin tuna, seasoned and seared with pickled vegetable, wasabi ginger aioli	$17.00
Islander Classic burger topped with roasted peppers, onion, thinly sliced grilled linguica, pepper jack cheese, roasted garlic aioli	$16.00
Veggie Burger Plant based pattie, avocado, sprouts, pickled onion, kimchi aioli	$15.00
Cisco Burger Classic burger topped with housemade Cisco beer BBQ smoked brisket, pickled jalapenos, Vermont cheddar	$16.00
Grilled Prosciutto Cotto And Three Cheeses Sourdough bread, Italian smoked ham, Gruyere, Vermont cheddar & Boursin	$15.00
Black Bird House smoked turkey, Vermont cheddar, coleslaw, kimchi aioli on pumpernickel	$16.00
Dayboat Fried Cod Buttered brioche roll, cheddar cheese, dill tartar sauce, shredded lettuce	$16.00
Crispy Chicken Sandwich Boneless chicken thigh, pepper jack cheese, pickled onions, shredded lettuce, jalapeno corn sauce, buttered Brioche	$15.00
Club Of The ‘Hood Smoked turkey, Italian smoked ham, Duke’s mayo, apple smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, toasted sourdough bread	$16.00
Lobster Salad Roll Classic lobster salad, grilled New England brioche roll, curly fries, cole slaw, half sour pickle	$24.00
Street Style Tacos Three white corn tortillas, shredded lettuce, salsa fresca, fresh avocado, pickled jalapenos, lime cilantro cream. with blackened chicken	$16.00
Fried Green Tomato BLTA Duke’s mayo, pickled onions, avocado, applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, toasted sourdough	$15.00
Smokehouse Grilled sourdough, house smoked brisket, cilantro lime slaw, Vermont cheddar, kimchi aioli	$16.00
Junkyard Dog Grilled Hebrew National dog, wrapped in bacon, pickled jalapenos, cheddar cheese sauce on butter grilled. New England bun	$14.00
Fish & Chips Fresh Dayboat cod, dill tartar sauce, creamy coleslaw	$20.00
Seafood Of The Day What ever is freshest and how the chef feels like cooking.	$28.00
Steak Frites Worcestershire glazed steak, mushroom, caramelized onion demi-glace, curly fries, served with a side salad of arugula with parmesan cheese.	$26.00
Rotisserie Chicken Vegetable Pot Pie Oven-roasted chicken, mushrooms, peas,carrots, pearl onions baked to order, served with a house salad.	$23.00
Dessert Menu
Blondie Of Thieves Chocolate chip cookie baked to order served in a cast iron pan, topped with “Ice Cream Machine” Vanilla, chocolate sauce, and whip cream — Serves two	$14.00
Fresh Honeycrisp Apple And Cranberry Crisp Fresh Honeycrisp apples and cranberries, crisp with cinnamon and pecans topped with “Ice Cream Machine” Vanilla and a dollop of whip cream	$10.00
Root Beer Float “Ice Cream Machine” Coconut, topped with Patron XO	$10.00
Chocolate Mousse Housemade with a dollop of whip cream	$10.00
Chocolate Lava Cake “Gluten Free” Bittersweet chocolate, hot chocolate center, whip cream and house made chocolate sauce.	$10.00
Kids Menu
Frappe Chocolate or Strawberry	$10.00
Cup Of Chowder	$6.00
Fresh Fried Tortilla Chips Queso and Salsa	$6.00
Macaroni & Cheese – Cheeto’s Crust	$12.00
Fried Chicken Tenders With curly fries and ranch dipping sauce	$13.00
Fish & Chips With cole salsa and curly fries	$13.00
Kid Broho Burger With curly fries	$12.00
Pasta & Butter With garlic bread	$10.00
2 Uncrustable PB&J With curly fries	$8.00
Choco Taco	$7.00
Vanilla Ice Cream With chocolate sauce	$7.00
Chocolate Mousse	$10.00
Shop
The Brotherhood Gift Cards Gift cards are sold in multiples of $50 with a limit of $500
Kids Logo Brotherhood Tee Shirt Athletic Blue	$30.00
The Brotherhood Logo Tee Shirt Made from tri-blend material-Poly/combed cotton/rayon. Super soft, very washable. This price includes shipping	$36.00
The Brotherhood Trucker Hat Four colors: Red with white mesh, white with white mesh, dark gray with gray mesh or light grey with white mesh. This price includes shipping	$25.00
The Brotherhood Copper Mug This price includes shipping	$30.00
The Brotherhood Yellow Rain Poncho	$5.00
Broho Pint Glass 16 oz Glass. This price includes shipping
Sample Pre-Set Private Party Menus
Deluxe Passed Hors D’oeuvres Thai Coconut Beef Skewers with Roasted Peanut SauceShrimp Cocktail with Cocktail SauceCrab Cakes with Lemon Tartar SauceMini Asparagus and Brie PaniniBroho Beef Sliders Cheddar Caramelized OnionsVegetable Spring Rolls with Sweet Chili Dipping SauceBacon wrapped ScallopsBeef WellingtonsChicken WellingtonsChoose from 5 of the above, priced per person	$24.00
Premium Passed Hors D’oeuvres Mandarin Moho Shrimp with Roasted Pineapple SalsaLobster Bisque Soup SipsWasabi Seared Tuna with Picked Cucumber and Ginger On A Sesame CrispPistachio Crusted Lamb LollipopsMini Foie Gras BLTLobster and Mascarpone Arancini with Fire Roasted Tomato SauceSteak Frites (Rare Tenderloin on Garlic Crostini with Tarragon Aioli Crispy PotatoesMini Lobster Salad RollsChoose from 3 Deluxe and 3 Premium, priced per person	$32.00
Deluxe Stationary Appetizers And Snacks Brotherhood WingsBroho Chips and DipCrudite platterFinger Sandwich PlattersBroho Curly FriesChoose 3 from the above, priced per person	$20.00
Premium Stationary Appetizers And Snacks Artisan MeatCheese PlatterSmoked SalmonFried CalamariChoose 2 from the above, priced per person	$20.00
Raw Bar Wellfleet Oysters, Littleneck Clams on the half shellWith Champagne Mignonette, Cocktail Sauce and Lemon WedgesPriced per person	$18.00
Option 1 Choice of Island Quahog Chowder or Brotherhood Mixed Green Salad with Sherry VinaigretteChoice of Broiled Cod, Lobster Sauce with Horseradish Mash and Season vegetables or Herb Roasted Half Chicken with Mash Potatoes and a Warm Asparagus SaladCookie and Brownie Platter
Option 2 Choice of Brotherhood Caesar Salad or Quahog Clam ChowderChoice of Free Range Chicken Breast, Potato Gnocchi and a Truffle Pan Jus; Seared Scallops with Parmesan Risotto, Crispy Pancetta, and a Lemon Buerre Blanc; or Grilled N.Y. Strip Steak with Candied Shallot Red Wine Reduction, Roasted Root Vegetable Mash, and Seasonal VegetablesChocolate Mousse with Raspberry Sauce
Option 3 Choice of Lobster Bisque or Brotherhood Caesar SaladChoice of Pepper Crusted Beef Medallions with Savory Potato Gratin, Brandy Pepper Corn Sauce, and Seasonal Vegetables; Lobster Carbonara, with Pancetta, Spring Peas, and a Mascarpone Cream Sauce; or Rosemary Roasted Lamb Rack, Celery Root Mash, Season Vegetables, Romesco SauceCreme Brule
Soups Lobster Bisque French OnionQuahog Clam ChowderSeasonal Potage
First Course Crab Cakes with Chipotle saucePlatted Shrimp CocktailBrotherhood Caesar SaladMixed Green Salad with Sherry VinaigretteMixed green Salad with Fuji Apples Candied Pecans Vanilla Bean VinaigretteBaby Kale Salad with Toasted Pine Nuts Roasted Tomatoes, and a Myers lemon Vinaigrette Crispy, Pancetta and Shaved PecorinoRoasted Beet Salad with Fried Goat Cheese and Spiced Pecans
Entree Item Braised Beef Short Rib with Candied Shallot Red Wine Reduction, Savory Potato Gratin, and Seasonal VegetablesGrilled Ribeye with Roasted Fingerlings, Seasonal Vegetables, Horseradish Demi-GlaceJumbo Stuffed Shrimp with Saffron Risotto and a Spicy Tomato BrothLobster Mac and CheeseHerb Crusted Lamb Loin, Smashed Red Potatoes, Season Vegetables, and a Rosemary JusFree Range Chicken Breast, Garlic Mash Potatoes, Roasted Mushroom, and Seasonal VegetablesPan Roasted Pork Tenderloin, Roasted Mushroom, Garlic Mash Potatoes, Balsamic Cream Sauce
Desserts Cheese Cake with Fresh BerriesSeasonal Fruit Crisp with Vanilla bean Ice CreamMilk Chocolate Pots De Creme
Luncheon Option 1 Tomato Bisque with a Goat Cheese Crouton or Clam ChowderChicken Caesar Salad or Roasted Turkey ClubCookie and Brownie Platter
Luncheon Option 2 Clam Chowder or Seasonal Vegetarian SoupBrotherhood Chicken Cobb Salad, Asian Seared Ahi Tuna Salad or Grilled Chicken Club on FocacciaCookies and Brownie Platter
Sample Luncheon Buffet Clam ChowderTomato BisqueBrotherhood House Salad with Sherry VinaigretteCaesar Salad StationWith Grilled Chicken or Grilled VegetablesAssorted Sandwiches-(Turkey, Ham, Smoked Corned Beef)Curley Fries or Pasta Primavera SaladCookies and Brownies
2020 Drink Menu
Prosecco, Angelini Italy
Brut Rose, Bailly Lapierre Bourgogne
Brut, Domain Carneros Carneros. Bottle only	$50.00
Brut Reserve, Pol Roger Epernay. Bottle only	$70.00
Brut, Veuve Cliquot Reims. Bottle only	$98.00
Rose, Hess Shirttail California
Rose, Commanderie Peyrassol France
Pinot Gris, Domaine Agrape Alsace. Bottle only	$43.00
Pinot Grigio, Eos California
Pinot Grigio, Santa Margeritta Alto Adige. Bottle Only	$54.00
Sauvignon Blanc, Eos California
Sauvignon Blanc, Mohua New Zealand
Chardonnay, Eos California
Chardonnay, Rodney Strong Sonoma
Chardonnay, Stags Leap Napa Valley
Pinot Noir, Eos California
Pinot Noir, A Z Wineworks Oregon
Pinot Noir, Cherry Pie Carneros. Bottle only	$82.00
Merlot, Eos California
Merlot, Steele Lake County. Bottle only	$50.00
Malbec Alta Vista Mendoza
Zinfandel, Ballard Lane
Cabernet Sauvignon, Eos North Coast
Cabernet Sauvignon, Josh North Coast
Cabernet Sauvignon, Simi Sonoma
Truly 5% ABV	$8.00
Twisted Tea 5% ABV	$8.00
Twisted Tea Half And Half 5% ABV	$8.00
Fishers Island Lemonade 9% ABV	$10.00
Sangria 4.2% ABV	$8.00
Triple 8 4.4% ABV	$8.00
Downeast Cider 5.1% ABV	$8.00
Bud 5% ABV	$6.00
Bud Light 4.2% ABV	$6.00
Mich Ultra 4.2% ABV	$6.00
Miller High Life 4.2% Abv	$6.00
Miller Lite 4.2% Abv	$6.00
Red Bridge “GF” 3.2% ABV	$7.00
Modelo 4.6% ABV	$7.00
Heineken “Zero” 0.0% ABV	$7.00
Heineken 5% ABV	$7.00
Whales Tale 5.8% Abv.	$8.00
Peak IPA 7.1% ABV	$8.00
Juicy Haze 7.5% ABV	$10.00
Sam Adams Lager 4% ABV	$6.00
Guiness Irish Stout 4.2% ABV. Served inside only	$8.00
Stella Artois 5.2% ABV. Served inside only	$8.00
Cisco Brewers Gripah-Grapefruit 5.5% ABV	$8.00
Cisco Brewers Shark Tracker 4.8% ABV	$8.00
Lagunitas IPA 5.7% ABV. Served inside only	$8.00
Allagash Brewing Co White Ale 5.0% ABV. Served inside only	$8.00
Cisco Seasonal Served inside only	$8.00
Ts Mai Tai Flor de Cana rum, orgeat syrup, Curacao, lime & pineapple, scratch sour mix and floater of Myers	$10.00
Gosling Dark & Stormy	$9.00
Navy Grog Gold, dark & white rum, lime & grapefruit juice, honey, soda water, mint and lime garnish	$10.00
Moscow Mule Triple 8 Vodka, Goslings Ginger Beer & lime	$10.00
Whiskey Sour Brotherhoods own 4 Roses single barrel bourbon, scratch sour mix, lemon Juice & bitters	$10.00
Maine Root Soda Fair trade and sweetened by organically grown cane sugar, made in Portland Maine!	$6.00
San Pellegrino/Aqua	$10.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: resy.com

Reviews

Amy Stradling

Absolutely amazing! We loved the clam chowder, a little different than the average chowder. It’s my favorite clam chowder ever. And the fish sandwich!! Now that is a great fish sandwich! Went for lunch at a slowish time and service was excellent! Nicely decorated inside

… more

Jen Rogers

Great dinner spot on Nantucket! We went for an earlier dinner before catching our ferry back and the place wasn’t very busy. Veggie burger and fish and chips were both very much enjoyed! Service was pretty prompt as well.

… more

Jayson Tomasulo

Came for dinner without a reservation a few weeks ago and it took a couple of hours to get a table. The bartender was friendly and engaging and the drinks were solid. The oysters were excellent and my chicken Marsala was very good as well. The waitress at our table was a bit on the slow side, but overall, it was worth the trip and the food has greatly improved in the past couple of years.

… more

Stacey McKenzie

Always is a different adventure. The newly renovated place is cute. Giving a modern vibe upstairs and a cold dark basement.

… more

Karen Sweeney

Always a good spot for great food options . The prices are usually decent too. We had a party of 6 and it went fairly well except the outside seating that we wanted wasn’t getting enough shade from the umbrella but the staff was very accommodating to try , and when it didn’t we easily moved seat inside . Fast and efficient service. Friendly servers and bussers.

… more

Ryan Cotton

The staff are welcoming and helpful. The Chowder is excellent and the short rib sandwich also tastes great! Large assortment of drinks from the bar. Very chill and cool atmosphere.

… more

Ava Lanning

THE BEST French Onion Soup I have ever had.

… more

Peter Stieglmayr

GET THE LOBSTER ROLL W BROWN BUTTER SAUCE…IT WILL CHANGE YOUR LIFE!!! Service was great. Had also the fish & chips battered which was well made! Highly Recommend.

… more

Jake Domanski

Nice tavern style restaurant. Got the fish and chips, it was alright, a little bland. Not the worst but not the best i’ve had. Service was good though

… more

Dan Ferrara

I picked this spot because of the funny name. Expecting average American bar food but what I was treated to was one of the juiciest and most delicious fried chicken cutlets I’ve ever had. Food, drinks and service were all excellent.

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Brotherhood of Thieves Menu – Nantucket, MA

Hours

Menu

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions