Brothers Bar and Grill Menu – Muncie, IN

Type : Bar & grill

Location : Muncie, IN

Outpost of a Midwestern sports-bar chain serving casual American eats in a party atmosphere. Based on 745 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Brothers Bar and Grill 47303

Address:
1601 W University Ave, Muncie, IN 47303

Phone: (765) 287-8297

Website:

Hours

Sunday 11 AM–2 AM
Monday

(Labor Day)
11 AM–3 AM

Holiday hours
Tuesday 11 AM–2:30 AM
Wednesday 11 AM–2 AM
Thursday 11 AM–2:30 AM
Friday 11 AM–2:30 AM
Saturday 11 AM–2:30 AM

Menu

Starters & Shareables
Wisconsin World Famous Cheese Curds
From the cheese curd capital of the world to your mouth! Large curds of cheese, hand-dipped in our own Wisconsin beer batter and fried until golden brown. Served with your choice of dipping sauces.
$10.99
Boneless Wings
Half-pound of tender, boneless chicken wings, individually cut and hand-breaded right here, tossed in your choice of Brothers sauces.
$11.99
Bone-In Wings
Traditional wings tossed in your choice of Brothers sauces.
$13.99
Chicken Cheese Nachos
Freshly fried tortilla chips layered with our own queso sauce, cheddar, and pepper jack cheese, grilled shredded chicken, refried beans, pico de gallo, jalapeños, and sour cream.
$12.49
Chili Cheese Nachos
Freshly fried tortilla chips layered with our own queso sauce, cheddar and pepper jack cheese, Lisa’s chili, pico de gallo, shredded lettuce, jalapeños, and sour cream.
$10.99
Gator Balls
Gator by name only! Chicken breast wedges wrapped in bacon, stuffed with pepper jack cheese and jalapeño. Served with peppercorn ranch. Caution, these Gator Balls come out hot!
$12.99
Brothers Breaded Pickles
Unlike some places that get these shipped in a bag, our pickle slices are tossed in Brothers breading right here and served with peppercorn ranch dressing.
$8.99
Soft Pretzel Sticks
Warm pretzel sticks served with our horseradish-mustard sauce and a side of our tasty, cheesy queso for dipping.
$8.99
Brothers Appetizer Sampler
Brothers “Variety Pack” of appetizers includes Wisconsin cheese curds, chicken tender strips, breaded pickles, chicken cheese nachos, and choice of three sauces.
$17.99
Chicken Tender Strips
All white meat chicken fresh-cut and handbreaded to order, fried golden brown with a side of peppercorn ranch.
$10.29
Grilled Shredded Chicken Quesadilla
Large flour tortilla, melted cheddar and pepper jack cheese with shredded all-white meat chicken. Served with pico and sour cream.
$10.99
Firecracker Fries
An addiction prediction. Basket of fries tossed in a light garlic sauce with a trifecta of pepper; cracked black, crushed red and white pepper, then dusted seasoning. Served with peppercorn ranch.
$8.99
Cheesehead Fries
Pile of golden french fries layered with queso sauce, cheddar and pepper jack cheese, bacon and green onions. Served with peppercorn ranch.
$9.99
Deep Fried Oreo Cookies
State-fair delicious without the stick! Battered and fried Oreo Double Stuf® cookies with a drizzle of caramel and chocolate with a sprinkle of powdered sugar.
$6.99
Fresh Fried Tortilla Chips & Salsa $5.99
Fresh Fried Tortilla Chips & Queso $6.99
Basket Of French Fries $6.99
Salad & Chili
Thai Orange Chicken Salad
Mixed greens with fresh cucumber, orange and tomato all under sweet-and-spicy, hand-breaded boneless chicken.
$12.50
Granny Smith Apple Pecan
Mixed greens tossed in maple vinaigrette and garnished with granny smith apples, dried cranberries, toasted pecans, balsamic glaze, and bleu cheese crumbles.
$10.25
Chop Chop Salad
Mixed greens with bacon, tomato, bleu cheese crumbles, red onion, croutons and chopped egg topped with your choice of dressing.
$9.25
Socko-Taco Salad Veggie
Everything you want in a taco salad. Mixed greens, radish, cucumber, roasted corn, black bean, cheese and pico topped with chipotle ranch dressing. Served in a dip-fried flour tortilla shell.
$9.25
Lisa’s Chili
Crock of chili layered with cheddar and pepper jack cheese and baked. Served with sour cream and green onion. With oyster crackers.
$6.99
Wraps & Happy Food
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Hand-breaded and fried chicken breast tossed in our own buffalo sauce, served with provolone cheese, shredded lettuce, diced tomato, and bleu cheese crumbles in a tomato-basil flour tortilla wrap.
$11.49
Cod Almighty
Cod fillet hand-dipped in our own Wisconsin beer batter, fried until golden brown, topped with shredded lettuce and served with tartar sauce.
$11.49
Queso Chicken Wrap
Grilled chicken, our famous queso sauce, with a blend of cheese, lettuce, fried corn tortilla chips, red onion and diced tomato in a tomato-basil flour tortilla wrap.
$11.49
The Ultimate BLT
Toasted marble rye bread loaded with bacon, lettuce, tomato, melted cheddar cheese, mayo and topped with a fried egg.
$11.49
Southwestern Wrap
Grilled chicken and chipotle ranch dressing with black beans, charred corn, lettuce, diced tomato, blend of cheese and crispy tortilla strips wrapped in a tomato-basil flour tortilla.
$11.49
French Dip
Thinly sliced ribeye steak on a French-style hoagie. Topped with melted provolone and served with a side of au jus for dipping.
$12.99
Chicken Ranch Wrap
Grilled chicken, shredded lettuce, diced tomato, chopped bacon, blend of cheese and peppercorn ranch in a tomato-basil flour tortilla wrap.
$11.49
Steak & Swiss Wrap
Thin cut steak with swiss cheese, thousand island, pico de gallo, and letttuce in a tomato-basil flour tortilla wrap.
$11.49
Chicken Between The Bread
Brothers Classic Chicken Sandwich
Back to basics. Marinated chicken breast, hand-battered, fried with mayo and pickle on a toasted bun.
$10.99
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Hand-breaded and fried chicken breast tossed in buffalo sauce, topped with provolone and bleu cheese crumbles served on a toasted bun.
$11.99
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Grilled marinated chicken breast served on buttered flour bun with lettuce, tomato, onion and sliced dill pickle.
$10.99
Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich
Breaded and fried chicken breast covered in Brothers Nashville inspired golden BBQ sauce and topped with pepper jack cheese. Served on a toasted bun with creole mayo.
$11.99
BBQ Chipotle Chicken Sandwich
Grilled, shredded all-white meat chicken in a smoky chipotle barbeque sauce with cheese, onion tanglers, on a bun.
$10.99
Burgers
Smokehouse Burger
Hand-patty topped with bacon and covered with sweet BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese and tumbleweed onions. Served with shredded lettuce and tomato on a toasted bun with bacon mayo.
$12.49
The Over-Achiever
As if way-more than a half pound of hand patty beef was enough to satisfy you. We also include bacon, two slices of cheese, grilled onions and top it off with a large fried egg.
$13.49
Wisconsin Cheese Curd Burger
Hand-battered, beer battered, melt-in-your-mouth Wisconsin cheddar curds on top of our beef patty and bacon. With sweet chili aioli on a buttered flour bun. It even sports its own cheesehead hat.
$11.99
Impossible Burger
Meatless, impossible plant-based patty, in classic burger form, with lettuce, tomato, pickle, red onion on a toasted bun.
$13.49
Brothers Good-N-Ugly Stacked Patty Melt
Can something this ugly be loved by so many? Yep. Our seasoned three-blend beef, hand-pressed between slices of grilled marble rye bread with swiss, yellow grilled onion and thousand island. If you’re a true-to-form patty melt fan, you won’t be disappointed!
$11.49
Brothers Classic Bacon Cheeseburger
Hand-patty with American cheese and bacon served on a toasted bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, and sliced dill pickle.
$11.25
Classic Cheeseburger Without Bacon
Hand-patty with American cheese served on a toasted bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, and sliced dill pickle.
$9.99
Quesadilla Burger
Our seasoned quesadilla burger has queso sauce and a whole lot of midwestern love that’s wrapped comfortably inside a flour tortilla like a snuggly weighted blanket. With a blend of cheese, tomato, pickle, lettuce, and onion.
$11.49
Favorites
Beer Battered Cod Fish Fry
Half-pound of cod fillets dipped in our own Wisconsin beer batter, fried until golden brown, and served on a bed of french fries and tartar sauce.
$13.49
Buffalo Chicken Mac ‘N Cheese
Two american favorites in a bowl. Mac ‘n cheese (five cheeses) topped with boneless buffalo wings served with a warm breadstick.
$15.99
Chicken Fried Chicken ‘N Gravy
Extra large tenders of all white meat chicken twice breaded and fried for that fried-chicken-crunch made-from-scratch gravy on the side and french fries.
$12.99
Five Cheese Mac ‘N Cheese
Our mac ‘n cheese is the real deal. Five cheeses of the American classic comfort food served with a warm bread stick.
$11.75
Street Tacos
Chicken Tinga Street Tacos
Two shredded chicken tinga tacos, pico de gallo, avocado aioli, lettuce, and queso fresco. Includes two fresh, house-made salsas (roasted red and roasted green). Served with refried beans and spanish rice.
$10.75
Baja Fish Street Tacos
Two beer battered cod fillet tacos, pico de gallo, avocado aioli, queso fresco, and lettuce. Includes our two fresh, house-made salsas (roasted red and roasted green). Served with refried beans and spanish rice.
$12.25
Cajun Sriracha Fish Tacos
Two cod tacos, pico de gallo, sriracha aioli, queso fresco, lettuce, and cajun spices. Includes our two fresh, house-made salsas (roasted red and roasted green). Served with refried beans and spanish rice.
$12.25
Grilled Fish Tacos
Two grilled cod tacos, pico de gallo, avocado aioli, queso fresco and lettuce. Includes our two fresh, house-made salsas (roasted red and roasted green). Served with refried beans and spanish rice.
$12.25
Kids Menu
Kid’s Cheeseburger
Includes French Fries
$6.49
Kid’s Chicken Tenders
Includes French Fries
$6.49
Kid’s Mini Corn Dogs
Includes French Fries
$6.49
Kid’s Mac & Cheese $6.29
Kid’s Grilled Cheese
Includes French Fries
$6.29
Kid’s Cheese Quesadilla
Includes French Fries
$6.29
Red Bull To Go
Red Bull Energy $5.00
Red Bull Energy Sugar Free $5.00
Red Bull Yellow Edition (Tropical) $5.00
Red Bull Red Edition (Watermelon) $5.00
Beverages
Coke ® $2.99
Diet Coke ® $2.99
Coke Zero ® $2.99
Sprite ® $2.99
Minute Maid Lemonade ® $2.99
Sides & Additions
Avocado Aioli $0.50
BBQ Sauce $0.50
Blue Cheese Dressing $0.50
Fat Free Italian Dressing $0.50
Honey Mustard Dressing $0.50
Marinara Sauce $0.50
Queso Sauce $1.50
Salsa Rojo (Red) $0.75
Salsa Verde (Green) $0.75
Sour Cream $0.50
Ranch Dressing $0.50
Tartar Sauce $0.50

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Ashley D
I just recently moved back to the area after being away for a couple of years and you can tell that management has changed for the better. Staff is friendly and very helpful. On a couple of occasions I had been sitting by myself in the evening and employees working the door would walk around and ask if I was okay every so often which as a female this made me feel safe. They are always on it with cleaning up dirty dishes and refilling drinks as needed. I have yet to leave the establishment dissatisfied.

… more

Mark Jackson
Located in the heart of BSU campus. We stopped for a beer and they had a decent selection available. Was around lunch time/early evening when we stopped. We did end up getting an appetizer sampler platter. Food was good and fresh. Bartender was cool. The place wasn’t very busy but it was also July so most students were probably back home for summer break.

… more

Lauren Burns
So we are regulars here on Tuesdays for burger night and sometimes the service is great, sometimes it’s terrible. We have had the same server, Ingrid, three times and it has been terrible every time. All of the tables around us has been sat, served, and then replaced with new people by the time we got our food. Had to go up to the bar to order drinks because she never came around to even take our order. It wasn’t even busy when we came. We love coming here but the service could be better.

… more

Jerry Bowling
I took my wife and daughter out for an early dinner. This location is on Ball State campus so I could potentially be busy at some points but we went on a Friday around 5pm. It wasn’t busy at all and got seated right away. The server was new but did a great job and gave us good service. My wife and I are plant based so we tried thier impossible burger which was very good, along with the apps. Beer selection was good along with thier cocktails. Overall I would recommend.

… more

Ally Bright
Had a great time for dinner here for my friends birthday! Their $2 burgers are a great deal and the drinks, too! The server we had was super nice and pretty and I wish I remembered her name! We had so much fun and thank you to the host for getting us a booth! It was comfy and we all enjoyed the food and I can’t wait to go back and drink now that I’m 21!!

… more

J Gray
There’s a great variety of food and we got great service at the Muncie location.

… more

Lindsey Bonfiglio
This fine dining establishment has a dress code. The place with profanities carved into the bar needs you to wear formal attire. So don’t forget to bring a blazer when you stop by to your local college vomit-in-the-stall bar.

… more

Dutch Assassin
This is the second time I have come to this restaurant/bar. The first time we sat for over 30 minutes and never even got a menu, much less anyone providing the service they are paid to give. So we walked out. I sit here right now for over 30 minutes and have not got my appetizer even. Took 15 minutes to even get our drinks. And there are MAYBE 4 tables of customers in the whole place! We should ha e walked out again this time as well!! I am VERY disappointed. And I WILL NOT return for a third try. They seriously need to get their act together. It’s sad.

… more

Tiffany Partaker
The cheese curds are the only thing worth having on the menu, but just a warning, they will clog your arteries. Service here is inexperienced at best. I would say unless you’re going for the sport and drink during a crowded night, skip it.

… more

Eric Sean
I have not gone to Brother’s, but live right next to it. It is not safe in the evenings. Please do not go there alone or after dark. There have been multiple shootings, and bar tenders have been accused of spiking drinks.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions