Based on 495 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1107 3rd St SW #3, Winter Haven, FL 33880
Phone: (863) 229-7404
Website: https://www.brothersnystylepizzafl.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ricci Konczyk
The best pizza so far that my husband and I have had since moving from Philly to Winter Haven 6 years ago. Obviously we’re used to really great pizza in Philly and were constantly disappointed till this, and they even have his beloved little anchovies (yuck). My criticism is that they charge so much for a pie that the food cost is probably $3.00. Tonight I went in to order because when I called it said the number was disconnected, not true, when I tried in the store it worked fine. I placed my order but before I paid the girl informed me it would take at least a half an hour because they only had one guy back there making pizzas. I did notice the big sign in the window advertising that they needed a pizza chef. I cancelled my order and left. This was NOT their fault. It’s going on all over the U.S.A. We’ve lost so much of the workforce lately, no one seems to want to work anymore. I’ll go back…hopefully they hire soon.
… more
Ashley Geraghty
As someone who is from NY/NJ this pizza is super disappointing. It’s overpriced and super small for a “Large” the pizza was flavorless – there was basically no sauce at all. The garlic parm wings were awful – it was basically wings with oil and the mozzarella sticks tasted like the type you buy in the Publix frozen section. I’m sorry but for $45 i expected way more.
… more
April Mannion
Best pizza in Winter Haven. Great New York style with fresh ingredients.
… more
Cristal Salazar
First time at this location and I am more then impressed. Asked for lite sauce and the pizza came out perfect the taste is amazing the crispness of the pizza is just rite. Very good pizza.
… more
Sheldon Baird
I this is first and last time I will eat here food was good but cost me $30.00 for large pepperoni and 2 drinks I was going to order wings also then the bill was up to $60.00 like this isn’t Taj Mahal I’m eating at. I don’t mind paying for good food but Pizza and 2 sodas ? Then to top it off I was charged $2.00 for ordering my food lmao like really pizza was $20.00 so tax and drinks $10.00 oh the ding bat told us 50 minute wait time that was not the case 20 minutes that was fine .
… more
Jorge Irizarry
Definitely the best pizza around. Classic cheese and also white pizza. Fresh.tasty, authentic.
… more
Phylena McCall
We found our place for pasta! Baked Ziti and that is a side of spaghetti . We didn’t feel up to making it ourselves so whooo-hooo! We tried the jumbo wings with honey/honey sauce on our 1st order . Our 2nd try on the wings the crispy are now the favorite still with the honey-honey.
… more
Jay Saltzman
Foods good but don’t order online. Got at store at the end of the time that is supposed to be ready and they said it won’t be ready for another 15 minutes. That tells me that it wasn’t even started. You’re better off calling in.
… more
tim elliott
Best pizza in the county! (Sorry Floridino’s). Friendly server gave us the whole story – retired owners(30 years) of Northern pizza restaurant get bored and open up pizza restaurant. Other Italian food, calzone’s etc; my wife had a Eggplant wedge (think folded over pizza dough) which she thought was terrific and she’s really picky about eggplant. We’ll definitely be back (and hopefully they’re working on a beer license) and bring friends with us. Now in 2022 tried the wings along with the pizza. Pizza still terrific, and now add wings to the list. Wings were Garlic Hot and Spicy, and they sure were! Best garlic wings I’ve ever had!
… more
Don And Audrey Gibson
Zero stars! Yesterday we placed our dinner order on line. It didn’t appear to go through. Got an email that said they would send a confirmation IF they took the order. They DID charge my bank card for the order. So I called them. They said 35-40 min. When I arrived to pick up my order they knew NOTHING of my order. They claim they never got it from their computer.
… more
… View more