Based on 232 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
200 Mathistown Rd #1, Little Egg Harbor Township, NJ 08087
Phone: (609) 294-1851
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:15 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:15 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:15 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10:15 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10:15 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9:15 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Cara Mia Warfle
As a business owner, I hate to leave this review because I know the importance of a high rating. With that said, I do my best to keep my clients happy. Last night we ordered a pizza from Brothers Pizza. We were starving lol. Unfortunately, we were greatly disappointed. The onions were old, (we are onion people and could tell by the disgusting taste) and I’m assuming, not the usual used on pizza? They were diced and oily, I’m also assuming that they ran out of cheese and forgot how to cut the pizza, …. This was unedible. Yes, it was burned also, like seriously burned where the crust crumbled and was BLACK. . We tried calling them several times but they wouldn’t answer the phone. If they had answered, and made it right, I would not have left this review.
… more
Denise DeFrehn
I was extremely disappointed on my order of Shrimp Scampi that I had delivered to my home. It was $18 and it consisted of 5 or 6 small shrimp in Scampi sauce but no linguine or really any type of regular pasta. It had a few tiny pieces of some kind of pasta. I have had sandwiches delivered before and desserts and they were good. However, I really felt cheated at this horrible expensive entree
… more
Elizabeth Wilson
Ordered a simple calzone with meatballs with a side of mozzarella sticks and a soda. The mozzarella sticks and soda was on point why wouldn’t they be? However, the calzone…… the calzone was tremendously undercooked, it also had an over load of ham on it which I didn’t ask for! In all the main course was absolutely disgusting and I’ll never order from there again!
… more
Maggie Morgan
Saw a local recommend this place and they deliver, so we tried it. Ordered via Slice app with ease. Took 1h20m to deliver 1 cheese pizza and an egg roll. It was terrible. The cheese was more caramelized rather than melted and had no taste. The only thing you could taste was the herbs in the sauce. Will never order again.
… more
Kate Martin
Really RUDE people— and I’m NOT that kind of customer. I shared my experience with a lot of people at my community center and was told, the pizzeria is under different owners who are NOT recommended. I guess I know why… after all…pizza’s pretty much Pizza (if the place knows their business). The rest is all about customer service. That’s where THIS place falls flat on their faces. I can’t accept ‘RUDENESS,’ especially when the reason is because THEY screwed up and expect to take their mess out on me. I’m sure glad there are SO many other pizzerias to choose from, all within less than a few blocks from THiS place. And that’s where I’ll be going!!
… more
Susan Reddan
Came down from NY and was happily surprised! EXCELLENT pizza and overall experience! Will 100% be back next time I’m in the area.
… more
Rare Pig
Owners are great and so is the food definitely coming back love the plain pizza
… more
Theresa Kennedy
We used to love Brothers pizza. The new owner is a real piece of work. We ordered delivery and waited an hour. When driver arrived he forgot 1/2 of our order and had to go back and get it. 25 mins later (it’s 1.5miles from my house) he comes back with cold wings and sausage. I called the restaurant and asked to speak to the manager. He refused to tell me his name and then proceeded to argue with me that no mistake was made. That we had gotten the food we ordered and that no food will be hot after 75 mins. So, Mr. Owner Man, glad you keep on top of taking care of your customers, you know, intentionally forgetting half their order, then delivering it cold and yelling at them when your staff clearly made the mistake. I pray someone doesn’t get ill from your irresponsible food storage and delivery.
… more
Jenny Rivera
I only ate here once and won’t again. They seemed very busy but their customer base is seniors and may explain the popularity from locals. They only offer water and soda. I have eaten at many places as we all have in our lives and have never heard of only water/acidic soda as a beverage option. They do not even offer tea. The pizza was disgustingly oily. I wish I had taken a picture of it. My wrap was not satisfying at all. I would not recommend this place for any kind of eatery.
… more
George Koslow
Great service food is great my wife and our grandkids love this place
… more
… View more