Based on 121 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
110 Old York Rd, New Cumberland, PA 17070
Phone: (717) 774-4600
Hours
| Wednesday | 9:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 9:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 9:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 9:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 9 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 9:30 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Chris Legend
I love this place, but i swear they are really cheap on sauce, i am so angry when my wife orders pizza from here and i have literally specs of pizza sauce. I dont want extra sauce i just want some sauce all over my pizza…
… more
Jared Rumer
I’ve ordered from this location several times previously and the food has always been ok. This evening I ordered 4 slices of pepperoni pizza and 10 hot wings
… more
Kalyn Cole
I started going here during the pandemic to help out a local business. I really like their pizza slices because the sauce doesn’t overpower the rest of the pizza. I also get their strombolis and they’re a good size for one or two people, not too much. Fyi English is not their first language, so be patient with them. But they are always very thankful and gracious when I get something from them. Give them a try.
… more
Marc Wills
Always good food when we go there for lunch. A good selection as well. Prices are on par with othe places. A bit disappointing there is no fountain soda anymore but at the same time who needs the extra sugar of a refilled soda 🙂
… more
leo
Food is good but the delivery system is broken. Only shows maybe half of the menu items, and if you call and try to just order on the phone you get yelled at
… more
zairylee de jesus
Amazing pizza!! Wow!! ordered the bacon cheeseburger pizza and it’s really authentic and very Italian. Super delicious! Very clean. Worth the extra couple dollars because you can tell they use fresh ingredients. Don’t think I’ll find a better spot, this is pretty hard to beat. I’ve eaten pizza in many places and this place has definitely beat all of them.
… more
Brandi Altigieri
We’ve ordered delivery from Brothers almost every Friday night for the past 5 years. The food is fresh and very good. They have the best pizza in the area. Their grilled chicken sub is great (sometimes I ask them to add bacon) as is their meatball and cheeseburger subs. Their chicken fingers are amazing. Their salads are fresh. We’ve tried almost everything from their menu (haven’t tried the dinners). Sometimes they’re brusque when taking orders but I know they get crazy busy and honestly, I don’t really care. The food is good, the price is reasonable and my kids get excited when they see the pizza man’s red jeep pull up to the house. Owner is great with my boys! Highly recommend them!
… more
Ty Ditch
Didn’t have to wait long for my pizza and it was vary good like always
… more
Zachary Garner
By far best pizza anywhere near use, fresh amazing food. Love everything I get here. And the bread and crust on everything is awesome.
… more
Tim Starr
Good pizza and salads, but we’ve had too many bad experiences with the people that we will not be going back. It’s a shame that they’re so rude because we haven’t found a good pizza place in New Cumberland yet. The funny thing is that they seem to get mad at you for trying to use their coupons and the pricing on their own menu. They’ve tried to overcharge my wife on their lunch deals a few times, then act all bothered and upset when you point out the lower price on the menu. I ordered a two topping pizza and they tried to charge me extra because those two toppings were ham and pineapple. Maybe there’s an extra fee for the “Hawaiian” naming rights. When I finally convinced them that it was just a two topping pizza they said that pineapple costs more (doesn’t say that on the menu) and then complained about the expired coupon I was using. Sure, it had expired over a year ago, but they gave it to me only a few weeks before… So if you want decent food and someone to make you feel like the bad guy and give you a hard time about it, eat here.
… more
… View more