Based on 225 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
20722 Timberlake Rd, Lynchburg, VA 24502
Phone: (434) 266-1114
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lia Boras
I enjoyed my pepperoni pizza over my lunch period (around 2pm). It tasted fresh, and the food was really good. Also, the server was kind and considerate.
… more
Alan Faircloth
I’m done with this place. Double the take-out time if placing a take-out order. The last 3 out of 3 visits have resulted in excessive wait times AFTER placing an order. After calling on the phone to place a pizza order, the order isn’t even close to being ready upon arrival. On 8/11/23, I called at 5:30 to place an order for a single, small pizza. The lady on the phone said it would be 40 minutes. I thought that was rather lengthy considering it was just a small pizza. I agreed and responded to the restaurant 40 minutes later. When we arrived, they hadn’t even put our pizza in the oven yet! We had to stand around for another 20 minutes to get our food! I understand that places get busy at times and things can happen but this has become a regular pattern for them. This is at least the third time this has happened in the past 6 months. I only go because my wife loves their pizza. Even she said we were done after out last encounter. Great pizza but HORRIBLE time management with no consideration to the customer. Not going back.
… more
Jeremy Keesee
Brothers has been in my family’s restaurant rotation for a few years now. Always quality, family run so there’s that special touch you can’t reproduce from a corporate HQ.
… more
Juanita Cook
If you have not checked this little place out. They are a small place but the pizza is the best I have had and they make it with love. And the staff are so friendly. My first time in and I will be back. Glad they made the lost representing Virginia that I found on the Living in Lynchburg page on Facebook. I have driven by it so many times when I was checking out the church next door and really never paid attention to the little place tucked in. Don’t miss out my friends. I can’t wait to go back again.
… more
ForeverHappy Amy Shrum
Wow! Got the margarita calzone & husband got a “small” pepperoni & banana pepper pizza. The calzone was very good & it was huge. Definitely could feed two and the small pizza was about 11” round. The ingredients were so fresh and the meals were above expectations to say the least! Very impressed!
… more
April Gardner
This is my favorite pizza place hands down. The staff is always friendly. They have excellent Alfredo dishes and salads as well.
… more
Michael Brown
Delicious! Great staff. The food is always delicious.
… more
Jennifer C
Pizza was great which is the reason for the generous rating. It took over an hour to get it when the lady said 20 minutes. The staff seem unorganized. My suggestion would be to order take out but give them plenty of time.
… more
Mary Saburn
Ok, after seeing the posts on Facebook about Brothers Pizza I told my husband I wanted to go try it for dinner tonight. It did not disappoint! We each got a house salad ($3.95). My husband had the Italian dressing and I tried the blue cheese dressing. Nice salads and the dressings were tasty. We shared their large pizza which is 16 inches ($14.95). We did a half and half as I wanted to try the house special, minus the green pepper, and he only wanted pepperoni and mushrooms. The pizza was delicious! I loved the flavor of the sauce and it has plenty of toppings. Most of the pepperoni was under the yumny cheese but it was on there. I’m not a big fan of pizza crust but I really liked theirs and ate my crust! We brought half home to enjoy later. We both drank Pepsi ($2). They weren’t busy except for a few other customers and a few take out orders as well. You all need to check it out! Our waiter was very nice and friendly and efficient. I definitely look forward to going back and trying other menu items besides having more pizza! We also got a punch card to use. Sweet! I’ve included a copy of their menu.
… more
Cham P
After read Lynchburg ledger paper published nov 2018 i thought i want to check out the truth behind, i was surprised they were vote as a BEST PIZZA RESTAURANT IN VIRGINIA looks to me it is hoax and paper article mislead public and purpously give publicity to this place, picture says time magazine BUT in other note in your table says “TIME MONEY MAGAZINE” this really misleading and it’s up to you guys to Google the rest
… more
… View more