Based on 91 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $$
Address:
1201 W Broadway, Monmouth, IL 61462
Phone: (309) 760-8316
Website: https://www.buffalo67.com/
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Hala
We were so excited to try this place. Other than some stuff that irritated me, food was ok, with good portions.
… more
Stacia Mattan
Our family of 4 dined in. All of our entrees were delicious. We shared one appetizer – Spinach Artichoke Dip- and we all agreed it was super yummy. I had maple bourbon salmon (excellent flavor and well cooked), my husband had catfish and it was very good. My son had teriyaki wings and my daughter had a chicken quesadilla. Both kids ate their food and said it was very good. I was disappointed in my “premium side” of roasted Parmesan vegetables which were clearly a frozen bag of veggies with cold Parmesan sprinkled on top. I had one glass of wine and everyone else had a soft drink. Our bill was $93. The waitress was very sweet and did a great job. All in a all a good experience and nice addition to Monmouth.
… more
Tyler Swedeen
Service very slow. Our food was less than mediocre for the price. Appetizer was cold and a sloppy mess. NY strip was way overcooked and the toppings were burnt to a literal black crisp and potatoes very dry. The beer was room temperature. Dont usually complain but the experience here was pretty bad. Wont be coming back.
… more
billie malesker
The cheeseburgers were great! Good sized portions. I loved the little extra touch the side salad had. Don’t order a spicy Bloody Mary unless you’re sure you want spicy! Lol
… more
Bobbi Birk-LaBarge
This place came highly recommended. We were spending the weekend in Monmouth from out of state and wanted a great place to eat. Unfortunately, this was not the place. When reading their menu it describes how their items are cooked and you imagine what their dishes might look like based on the description. Two of us ordered their homemade chicken tender dinner. When my tender meal came out the breading appeared burnt and was extremely dry. The same was done with my onion tanglers. I looked at the other meal at the table and the breading was a little lighter than mine. This was nothing as described on their menu. I cooked in a kitchen in several different establishments over the years and I know my way around a kitchen. We said something immediately to the waiter and he requested the kitchen make me new tenders. The kitchen staff argued and basically said that’s how they have to be to be cooked at 165° so they chose NOT to make me new tenders. Apparently the cook/chef is not inclined to know that’s what happens to breading on anything when the heat is too high or the oil is old. Another female employee tried to get staff to make me another order but was unsuccessful so she asked if I wanted something else. After hearing the cook refuse to remake my order, I was hesitant at ordering anything else so I asked if she could just remove the charge from my bill. She was a wonderful lady and full of apologies but she wasn’t the one that needed to apologize as she had no control over the way the food comes out of the kitchen and no control over the cook(s) stubbornness.
… more
Nick Jurgle
I was not impressed. Food was barely warm. Tortilla chips were stale, and who puts romaine lettuce on nachos? For reference, my wife had the beef nachos, and for the price, we could have had better at taco bell. I had the buffalo ranch fries. They weren’t all that bad, but they were barely warm. Those two items were $26. We only had water to drink, and it had a funny taste. Unless something changes or it was an off night, I would not recommend this place. Prices are too high for food of this quality.
… more
Richard Bleyaert
Would give 0 stars if possible. Service was not good, slow, lackidazical, as if didnt care. Management is horrible and obviously have 0 Customer service skills. Brought all food out individually and the last person’s food came out almost 20 minutes after because they forgot to cook it. We had to ask for information instead of them talking to us to explain the situation, communication could have avoided the issues. Then they tried to only give 15% off, seriously, that added insult to injury. This place started out as a descent place to have dinner and drinks, have been here 3 times prior with no issues and it is sad that we will never go again.
… more
Stacy Bieri
The food was delicious, setting was modern eclectic and the staff was friendly!
… more
Luanne Thurston
Best meals we’ve had in a long time! Highly recommended!
… more
Dysfunctional Veteran 83
Came here on a Saturday night. I found this place while looking for a good local spot. Wow, I had the Thai chili wings and the coconut shrimp. The food was delicious and the service Jamie provided was top notch and friendly. This place is excellent, I hope to visit here soon and often.
… more
… View more