Bully’s Restaurant & Pub Menu – Columbia, PA

Type : American restaurant

Location : Columbia, PA

Completely restored railroad hotel built in 1903. Operating as a full-service Inn & Restaurant. Described by many as one of the best-kept secrets in Lancaster & York. The Inn has 11 well appointed rooms with private baths. Great for weddings, long-term business stays & Get-a-way weekend specials. The Restaurant & Pub boast a hand-carved oak bar & tin ceilings. Areas best selection of micro, craft & import beers cratering to the true beer connoisseur. Fine wines & spirits with one of the best Back bars around, including an excellent selection of Single Malt Scotch & Bourbon. Our American-style cuisine dubbed, “Upscale Casual” comfort food with a twist which includes a wide variety of light fare, soup, distinctive entrees and fine desserts.

Based on 322 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Bully's Restaurant & Pub 17512

Address:
647 Union St, Columbia, PA 17512

Phone: (717) 684-2854

Website:

Hours

Wednesday 4–9 PM
Thursday 4–9 PM
Friday 4–10 PM
Saturday 4–10 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday Closed
Tuesday 4–9 PM

Menu

Starters
Crab Dip
Special crab mixture topped with jack cheddar cheese, served with toasted bread
$12.00
Seasonal Flatbread
Description available from your server
BBQ Ribs
Half rack of ribs smothered in our smoky BBQ sauce
$11.00
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Scallops wrapped in smokehouse bacon, served with a honey citrus pepper sauce
$12.00
Pub Fries
Hand cut fries topped with applewood smoked bacon, jack cheddar cheese and scallions
$10.00
Brie Puff Pastry, Fruit & Nuts
Mild baked brie cheese wrapped in a flaky puff pastry
$12.00
Lamb Sliders
Sweet & spicy roasted jalapeno relish, Weissa Kase cheese with a mango habanero aioli on three Brioche buns
$12.00
Chicken Strips
Breaded tenderloins with smoky BBQ sauce
$10.00
Steamed Mussels
New Zealand Green Lip, white wine, garlic, herb butter, crushed red pepper, parmesan cheese & grilled focaccia
$14.00
Jumbo Wings
Mild, Medium, Hot, Or BBQ (1 doz)
$10.00
Side Salads
House Salad
Spring mix greens, plum tomatoes, julienne carrots, & croutons
$5.00
House Caesar
Romaine tossed with Caesar dressing croutons, & shaved parmesan cheese
$6.00
Seasonal Salad
Description available from your server
$9.00
Dinner Salads
Caesar Salads
Romaine tossed with Caesar dressing croutons, & shaved parmesan cheese
$15.00
Grilled Chicken Or Steak Salad
Mixed greens, julienne carrots, plum tomatoes, croutons, and jack cheddar cheese. Hand cut fries or cole slaw
$15.00
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Breaded tenders tossed in Buffalo sauce, mixed greens, julienne carrots, plum tomatoes, croutons, and jack cheddar cheese. Hand cut fries or cole slaw; (Mild, Medium or Hot)
$15.00
Hot From The Kettle
Bully’s Creamy Crab Soup $6.00
Soup Du Jour $4.00
Bully’s Bison Chili
Local farm raised American bison. Served in a crock with melted jack & cheddar cheeses and toasted bread
$8.00
Land Features
Pork Osso Bucco
Oven roasted for hours, 22oz premium hand seasoned pork shank infused with pork demi-glaze
$29.00
Grilled Lamb
A “Must Try” Two grilled premium reserve lamb chops with a balsamic honey glaze with a touch of Grand Marnier liqueur
$26.00
Rough Rider Ribs
A customer favorite! Tender, falling off the bone rack of baby back ribs, smothered in our own smoky barbecue sauce
$21.00
Roasted Duck Confit
Time-honored French tradition, two seasoned roasted leg of duck that are as tender and juicy as one can hope with a mild teriyaki orange ginger sauce
$26.00
Roasted Chicken
Lightly dusted with seasoned panko, seared in duck fat, with a fire roasted plum tomato sauce and roasted fingerling potatoes
$23.00
Butcher Block Selection
Cut Of The Day
Special cuts change often, your server will be glad to explain the cut of the day
Sirloin Bistro Steak
Aged 10oz. center cut coulotte with a wild mushroom crumbled bleu cheese sauce
$28.00
Kona Tenderloin Steak
8oz. beef tenderloin rubbed with fresh ground Kona coffee, cocoa, & cinnamon, finished with a stout beer demi-glaze
$23.00
Surf-N-Turf
Add Crab Cake $8
Ocean Features
Fresh Catch
Our selection changes often, your server will be glad to explain the catch of the day
Broiled Crab Cake
House specialty crab cake made with a special blend of crab meat and side of citrus aioli
$25.00
Stuffed Portabella Mushroom
Marinated portabella mushroom with a crab imperial dill soufflé, served over rice with a lobster saffron sauce
$23.00
Chilean Sea Bass
Pan seared then finished in the oven, with sautéed onions and wild mushrooms in a light Frangelico butter sauce
$29.00
Grilled Salmon
Atlantic salmon grilled with honey teriyaki glaze & mango peach salsa
$24.00
Pasta Features
Spicy Seafood Mac & Cheese
Amish garden pepper jack, asiago, shaved parmesan, crumbled pancetta, jumbo shrimp, scallions, & trottole pasta with toasted panko bread crumbs
$18.00
Lobster Ravioli
Lobster stuffed ravioli, roasted red peppers, roasted corn & lobster cream sauce over rice
$27.00
Vegetarian’s Stack
Jumbo handmade spinach stuffed Florentine raviolis and breaded egg plant cutlets stacked on a bed of rice, with an organic dried tomato and garlic pesto
$21.00
Lite Fare
Fish ‘N Chips
Beer battered cod & jumbo seasoned potato chip wedges, malt vinegar, cole slaw and choice of tartar or cocktail sauce
$16.00
Crab Cake Sandwich
Our special blend of crab meat on a toasted brioche bun with lettuce, tomatoes and choice of tartar or cocktail sauce
$14.00
San Fran Chicken Toasty
Seasoned chicken breast, bacon, grilled tomato, & southwest chipotle pesto, on a toasted brioche bun with choice of cheese
$13.00
Bangers & Mash
Traditional old world dish of fresh pork & apple sausage, garlic mashed potatoes, and a caramelized onion gravy demi-glaze
$16.00
Tenderloin Tips & Toast
“Local Harvest” tips, red onions, wild mushrooms, over wild rice in a stout beer sauce
$19.00
Portabella Mushroom
Hickory-smoked portabella mushroom topped with crab imperial, tomatoes and Weissa Kase cheese, served open-faced on toasted sourdough bread
$16.00
Steak Burgers
Texas Burger
Smothered with our famous BBQ sauce, red onions and Woodsmoked Cheddar cheese
$12.00
Teddy’s Mushroom Burger
Smothered with sautéed mushrooms with choice of cheese
$12.00
Beat Down Bacon Burger
House special bacon jam, with choice of cheese
$12.00
Spanish-American Spicy Burger
Buffalo wing sauce, jalapeño peppers, red onions and Garden Pepper cheese
$12.00
Salad Burger’s
For the customer who still craves a great tasting burger without the bun, try any of our burgers served on a salad
$12.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

A. Nelson
HIDDEN GEM OF COLUMBIA, PA . Went here for dinner last night and was blown away. It is very unassuming from the outside but the food is incredible, especially for the price. We got a number of items, all incredible in their own ways. Each dish is the most elevated version is could be. The potato wedges, the bao buns, the bacon burger, the steak with blue cheese sauce and one of the pizzas. I will absolutely be coming back here and selfishly hope not many people find out about this place. Service was great as well.

… more

Saoirse Sheldon
The only thing I am mad about is that I couldn’t eat everything! I had the lamb sliders and they were superb. Hands down the Siracha Watermelon Sorbet is perfection. Now don’t get me wrong the strawberry goat cheese was definitely worthy of “lick the bowl clean” status and I now believe that Holiday dinner should have spiced cranberry and red wine ice cream to go with your pie of choice.

… more

Brett Skipper
Stopped in based on a recommendation from a local and were not disappointed. Great ambience with lots of tin work and am old school wooden bar. Decent beer selection and the food was excellent. We would certainly return.

… more

Walter Sobchak
They place had a really nice tavern feel, and the staff was awesome. The food was lacking. We got the mushroom burger. Medium rare, with fries. It’s seemed like there was no seasoning at all. A little salt, pepper, garlic and onion goes a long way. Burgers were cooked to what we ordered.

… more

Doreen Jemison
This restaurant was my in-laws’ selection for a birthday dinner. We had not been there for over 20 years and were pleasantly surprised. The staff was incredibly attentive and flexible. They helped us navigate as my parents could not ambulate easily. The food was delicious and fresh. And prices for dinner and drinks were reasonable. We would highly recommend the ribs and the fish tacos. GF selections were also easily noted.

… more

mayumi myers-zastowny
The setting is quite lovely. Tin ceilings and all. My husband started with the crab soup very tasty and creamy. We both shared a plate of pub fries. Cheesy Hot and filling.

… more

Jill P
A surprise gem. We thought we were going to a pub, but it’s so much more. The cozy charm, excellent international beer selection (no pushing run of the mill IPAs) and excellently prepared food make this well worth a stop.

… more

Summers
They have great food! The bangers & mash are banging!

… more

Chris Brown
We were looking for somewhere off the beaten path and found it. The atmosphere and decor was very comforting and the food was great. The bison chili was unique and full of flavors. The stuffed (crabmeat) portobello was huge sitting on top of garlic mashed potatoes and covered with a cream corn sauce, that with a glass of red wine and it was perfect! Check out the bar when your there, they don’t make them like that anymore, beautiful!!

… more

David Rude
This place is a gem. Easy to get to and good quality service. The wait staff was attentive and helpful. The food was good. The atmosphere is laid back and more mellow. You can actually hear the conversation you are having with friends. Many places are just too loud for conversation. The big thing thing here is their beer selection. If your a beer connoisseur this is place for you. The options they have are rare finds or you can’t find them anymore: except here. The have about 15 or so on draft and huge bottle selection from the best and hard to find, and vintage selection that’s no longer made. They have something for everyone and every taste. If you love beer go here!!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions