Welcome to Butler Inn of Pewaukee one of Pewaukee’s oldest and finest supper clubs. Our restaurant combines classic elegance with a relaxed atmosphere.
Come to our family-owned steakhouse to savor our top-notch hand-cut steaks, delightful seafood, and a variety of other delicious options. Our experienced and dedicated staff will make sure you have a wonderful evening.
Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a returning friend, join us for a memorable dining experience. We’re excited to welcome you soon!
Old-school supper club with a relaxed vibe offering steak, seafood & wine plus weekly live music. Based on 704 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
742 Glacier Rd, Pewaukee, WI 53072
Phone: (262) 691-0840
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday |
4–8 PM |
| Friday |
4–9 PM |
| Saturday |
4–9 PM |
| Sunday |
Closed |
| Monday |
4–8 PM |
| Tuesday |
4–8 PM |
| Wednesday |
4–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Haley Schmitt
Butler Inn has a little bit of everything! Wonderful service, very prompt, friendly and knowledgable. Our group had a little bit of everything from scallops to ribs, to ahi tuna, and of course the star the 5 star filet. The 5 star filet has a delicious garlic butter on top, and when paired with the lobster it is a must have dish. Finished the night with a chocolate martini, and ice cream drinks which the staff hand muddles, they are thick creamy and delicious. Butler Inn had multiple drink and dinner specials, and is a must stop restaurant. Also not pictured the flaming cheese, which is a great experience.
… more
Shelly Larson
First time eating here and the food was AMAZING! Can’t wait to go back!
… more
Dan Roufus
We had an amazing time tonight. Drinks were great, fun and delicious. The food was fantastic, the Chefs know their craft and execute it perfectly. The staff was so warm and welcoming. This is a must stop for a classic Supper Club. Thank you
… more
Corrine Pillsbury
Reservation 6:15. 3 people. I had gotten a drink from bar waiting for others. Got to table shortly after. Did not have a waitress/server to offer drinks to others until close to 6:40. Food order taken not received until 7:15. Two fish frys. One steak, an hour after our reservation. Never served bread basket had to ask for it. Did get haystack onion ring order right away. Very Very noisy. Sometimes hard to carry on a conversation with others.
… more
Peter K.
Five star filet and ribs were good. Fried lobster tail, also good Service was excellent.
… more
Jule Warnecke
We went to the Butler inn last night yo celebrate the sale of our home. We have dined there before and enjoyed it immensely. The waitress was attentive, friendly and efficient. The busboy was also very attentive. I had the lobster and steak special for $50, we also ordered before and after dinner
… more
James Tarabori
Haven’t been there for years after 2 disappointing experiences. A friend said to try it again. WOW! better ribeye than Palmers…..thicker so easier to cook medium rare and not served in a pool of hot grease like Palmers does. Only disappointment was my wife’s Old Fashioned….a little low on the Bullet bourbon and not muddled. Also the service was almost too good….entre came too fast. Her ribs and shrimp were very good as well.
… more
Amanda Schlueter
They raised their prices quite a bit which is fine but they also took away from portion size as well their side salads are just the cheapest lettuce now but they charge more. I don’t mind if somewhere needs to raise their prices due to inflation but don’t take away the quality and portion size of the food if you’re raising the price!
… more
Fred K
Awesome food and great service. Very reasonable pricing. Typical Wisconsin supper club atmosphere.
… more
Barbara Hime
We had a wonderful experience, food and drinks were great and the best service anywhere by far. Our server Leah was absolutely amazing. Highly recommend.
… more
… View more
