Steaks, seafood & other American offerings in an old-school place with unique decor & a full bar. Based on 736 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
25 Sunnyside Dr, Martinsville, IN 46151
Phone: (765) 342-4398
Website: https://bynumssteakhouse.net/
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
5–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 5–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 5–9 PM |
| Thursday | 5–9 PM |
| Friday | 5–10 PM |
| Saturday | 5–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Emily Stone
Wow! This was a wonderful meal! The restaurant was clean. We enjoyed the different decor in each seating section. The service was very good and our food was wonderful. We took home slices of the turtle cheesecake and enjoyed that the next couple of days, very good! It’s a little pricey, but this will be our special occasion restaurant!!
… more
Chris Lee
Great place to have a steak. It is tucked away just off I 69. The staff were all very good and the steaks were cooked perfect to order. Everything was reasonably priced. The restaurant was clean. Each entree came with three sides that inckuded a salad and their soup of the day. Bread is brought out early and was very good.
… more
John Landgrave
Overall a decent dining experience. I gave 4 stars rather than 5 because the soup that comes with the meal is watered down beef broth with a roll floating in it, the salads are small and the prices for the steaks are more than prime steakhouses like Morton’s or Ruth’s Chris but not near the quality. I’ve learned now to stay clear of restaurants that don’t take American Express.
… more
Salvadore Bertolone
Quaint steakhouse. Best potato I’ve ever had and the 16 oz. pork chops is the greatest value prop I’ve ever seen in a restaurant. Will stop everytime I come through this part of IN.
… more
xSUGARBEARx 808
Love this place, whether with the family or just the wife. Great atmosphere, great food great service. There have been time the beef broth onion soup have been cold. But great cuts of meat. Sadly I haven’t seen a drink list unless having to ask the waitress. But will always come back.
… more
Catherine Hannel
We usually sit in the bar area. The atmosphere, food and customer service are top notch. Christy and Lola are both amazing and interactive with all customers. I usually get the New York strip and my husband gets the double chops, but never had anything didn’t like. Would highly recommend.
… more
Mike Price
Tried this for the first time. Had dinner for two on a Sunday evening, around 6 pm, the wait to be seated was about 15 min, Service was good, mixed drinks were on point, and the food was great. (Probably the best King Crabs in Indy area)
… more
Barbara Painter
This restaurant deserves less than “one star”. We wanted to dine here since we had not been here in several years. It used to be so nice but now it is musty, run down and outdated. There was 5 in our group and we were crammed in a booth and we were the only ones in the room so it was not a busy night. Three in our group were celebrating birthdays so this was a disappointing experience. The tasteless French onion soup was beef broth with no onions, a small clump of cheese on the bottom and a small lump of bread on top. The side salad was from a store-bought bag, the bread was stale and the baked potato was very small. The steak was just okay. My son ordered a medium rare prime rib which was served rare and cold. He sent it back to be cooked medium and again it was rare. He sent it back again and it was served gray. He took one bite and it was tasteless and tough. Certainly not edible and not worth $50. The manager was not friendly, did not acknowledge the birthday celebrations, and she did not want to hear our comments. This was the worst experience! Do not waste your time or money coming here. Bynums at the Indy location has good service and great food. Also Texas Roadhouse and Longhorn are much better than here and both have good food and reasonable prices!
… more
Danielle Ferguson
If I could give higher than a 5 I would. I have always loved the food but customer service is just amazing. Bynums is my go to restaurant. The food (especially the onion soup)and the amazing people keep me coming back.
… more
Christina Nail
The food is so good! It is our go to restaurant for family get togethers! It is always great food and good service. The atmosphere is quiet for a enjoyable dinner. We have always had very good waitress as well. The filets and ribeye are great. As well as the French onion soup. Also a good variety of seafood and drinks. I recommend highly. It has always been a family favorite
… more
… View more