Casual pizza joint supplying pies & stromboli since 1953, plus sandwiches, burgers & a kids’ menu. Based on 445 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
405 E Kirkwood Ave #4036, Bloomington, IN 47408
Phone: (812) 332-2111
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Amy Potthast
The pizza is delicious. My husband loves the crust (“thin, perfectly crisp”) and the staff is sooo kind and friendly that my too-young son wants to work there some day.
… more
David Senter
Definitely glad that I decided to give it a second chance. Food and service were great. My son and I enjoyed it.
… more
Gina Wilcox
We had a pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms, a mozzarella salad, and an order of onion rings. All of the food was excellent and really exceeded our expectations! My husband said it was the best pepperoni and mushroom pizza he’s ever had and the best onion rings ever. The salad was huge and loaded with shredded mozzarella. Our food came quickly, and the service was outstanding. It was fun watching the cook cutting up the pizzas and strombolis. It was clearly not his first day on the job–an “expert marksman” with the pizza cutter. We devoured the salad and the rest of the onion rings, so there’s only one in the picture. Lol! I highly recommend!
… more
Jayden Jj
Best pizza ever , can never fail here , staff friendly
… more
Brad Hoggatt
Classic Hoosier pizza place. Nothing fancy, just good food and service. We ordered a Hot Ham & Cheese sub and a Stromboli online for carryout. The process was smooth and the food was great. The staff were friendly.
… more
Terri Laughlin
Wonderful pizza and HuGE salad with more cheese than I have ever seen on a salad The bread sticks were awesome as well.
… more
Bradford Morrison
Excellent pizza crust and topping. Plenty of meat and cheese ..a tad more sauce would have been ok.
… more
Troy Maynard
Delightful pizza and sandwiches at this venerable Kirkwood landmark. The family and I enjoy their simple, thin crust pizza with sparing sauce, light cheese, and delicious toppings. Sandwiches are served on big fluffy bread with plenty of tasty pickles. Prices are reasonable, service is fast, and the staff are always super friendly.
… more
Mary Kortea
Ate here for the first time today. After all the hype I really wanted to love cafe pizzeria but….I picked up my order and got home and my pizza was stuck to the box so every piece I tried to pick up tore in half, it was a little on the colder side as well. To me it tasted no different from Avers or Pizza X. I had a Stromboli which wasn’t too bad. It definitely didn’t have the classic strom taste. It’s a sweet kind of taste but it was full of toppings so that was a plus. I have yet to find a strom that taste’s like Monroe County Pizza’s. I think theirs were the best in Bloomington. We also ordered some of the garlic cheese bread and the edge of the box was closed down on the bread so most of the cheese came off when the box was opened. The taste was ok. Was not a fan of the dipping cheese. For a very small personal pepperoni pizza stuck to the box,a strom, and an order of cheese bread stuck to the box was $29. To me not really worth the money.
… more
Will R
I was passing through town, and I had *the best* pizza here I’ve had in years! I wish I had a similar pizza joint in my hometown!
… more
… View more