Calogero’s is a fine dining Italian restaurant located in Garden City, New York since 2002. Our top priority is bringing our customers the best authentic Italian food while providing excellent service. To go along with our full service dining room, Calogero’s has a full service bar, patio, deck, pizzeria with outdoor seating and a private dining room for events and corporate meetings.
Traditional Italian dishes served in a sleek, contemporary dining room with a romantic atmosphere. Based on 324 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
919 Franklin Ave, Garden City, NY 11530
Phone: (516) 294-2922
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 4–11 PM |
| Sunday | 3–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: calogerosgardencity.comopentable.com
Reviews
Dennis M.
Thought they all did a spectacular job. Our waiters explanation of all the dishes was important to us. Our waiter knew the menu and spoke off of it with great enthusiasm. This is a very important thing to keep people coming back. It was my wife’s birthday (who is a great cook) and I love to grill as well. My Wife ordered the seafood with spaghetti and I finished it . We thought it was well prepared. Prices were fine food was great and the service spectacular. Packed for a Thursday night. Make reservations.
… more
Jan Hrivnak
Staying in a nearby hotel, and evening being since and warm, made me feel like I wanted to walk a bit to find something healthy, delicious but also not overpriced to eat. Google reviews is what I normally use and Calogero’s caught my eye as they had pretty high score already and were open until 10pm. It was already past 8:15pm so I decided to give it a try. Nice people, very friendly, good food and quick service made me feel they deserve 5 stars. If you are looking for an extraordinary experience, this is not the place but it hits all points when it comes to good food in a cozy atmosphere.
… more
Anne Marie Pitre
Had lunch here with the ladies this past week…usual spot for us. We all got the same (another usual for us) – chicken panini. Delicious lunch with grilled chicken, roasted red pepper, arugula, fresh mozzarella, and pesto. Ordered mine with the restaurant fries which are homemade chips. So filling, I had plenty of leftovers! Service was very attentive. We will be back in the fall to lunch outdoors!
… more
Jim H
The food was delicious. The staff was incredibly friendly. They found out that my daughter is graduating from college and sent her dessert with congratulations written on the plate. They didn’t have to do that but we all loved that they did. Very thoughtful. Go and enjoy.
… more
LaShawn Grajales
Food was delicious, we took our son to lunch to celebrate his graduation from elementary school. The kids loved the pizza!
… more
Cristina Da Cruz
I must say I was extremely happy with the food and service that was provided at my daughter’s baby sprinkle. It was a last minute event as she lives out of state. They were all accommodating with the menu, décor and even opened the restaurant earlier so that all the decorators were able to take their time and make it look beautiful. I am so happy I was able to hold the event here and would recommend it to anyone looking to have a party.
… more
Gregg Miller
I have been to Calogero’s about four times. I thoroughly enjoy the service and atmosphere. I find the food to be above average, but stop short of giving a higher rating. The wines are very good.
… more
Doreen Borchers
Dined on a Saturday night. Reservation for 5:30. Good time. Not crowded and plenty of parking. Handicap accessible. Restaurant did get busy towards 6 and parking was definitely not as easy. The restaurant is very nice. Good atmosphere. Very attentive. Food was very very good. The shrimp bisque soup with spinach was excellent. Veal marsala was terrific with plenty of marsala flavor. The veal with spinach prosciutto and fontana was also very good. Served with tasty string beans and potatoes. Marsala came with mashed potatoes . It worked. Doesn’t need to be pasta. The disappointment was no pear tart for dessert..had warm chocolate cake which was good. I would recommend Calogero’s.
… more
Michael Scricca
Went for a drink… Why is it so hard for bartenders to make a margaritas lately. The drink wasn’t very good may but at least it was expensive. $46 for 2 drinks a neat bourbon and a sub-par margarita.
… more
Kevin Sniffen
A quiet oasis on this row of busy restaurants. Fine food and very attentive service. My wife and I wanted a place to unwind on a Friday night and be able to talk without shouting. I dont live in the immediate area, but would definitely go again.
… more
… View more