Based on 454 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
N8802 Co Rd A, Beaver Dam, WI 53916
Phone: (920) 885-9984
Website: https://www.cantafiosbuckhornsteakhouse.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4:30–9 PM |
| Friday | 4:30–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4:30–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
loredana sima
To the non locals, this is a hidden away gem. We stopped there on our way home to Chicago, on a Saturday afternoon. Didn’t have reservations and I’m not sure if that’s how they work but the wait was only 20 min and well worth it. The atmosphere was fantastic. Quiet, friendly and cozy. They make you feel like you’re family. Everyone is super friendly. The service was outstanding. We ordered the sirloin stake for two. How does one describe perfection? We have finally come across a place that literally serves the perfect stake. Between bites, my friend and I looked at each other and said “it’s only a two hours drive, we’re coming back”
… more
David Gabelbauer
Short staffed for the night but everyone stepped up and did a fantastic job. Constantly checking on customers, making sure they have enough drinks and sometimes being chatty. My girlfriend had the snow crab and I had the porterhouse. Both were very well prepared and delicious. I’m definitely coming here again.
… more
Jenn Much
Hands down the BEST eatery in Beaver Dam! The service was simply outstanding. Very warm, welcoming and friendly and you never had an empty drink on your table. Even more, the food was phenomenal. The Buckhorn Tradition – a deep fried onion with chipotle sauce, was huge! The steak was perfectly cooked and hit the spot, too. Altogether, everything was fresh and hot. One of my favorite aspects, however, was the beautiful homage to the owners fallen veteran son. Bringing his story into their restaurant provided a touching aspect to my visit. Kudos to the owners for providing free meals to veterans, too. The owners, along with the staff, truly put their heart and soul into this steakhouse. It is immaculately clean and provides a wonderful atmosphere for a dinner out. My husband and I would happily make the drive from Appleton to return. Highly, highly recommend – it’s worth the stop!
… more
Richard Schneider
Good experience overall. There is a lot of supper clubs in the southern half of Wisconsin and this one has good food, relatively quiet atmosphere, at least on the Saturday night we were there. Is it the knock your socks off, over-the-top stellar supper club of supper clubs? No. But it is a reliable choice of places to go out to eat that won’t disappoint.
… more
S Burg
Stopped in on our way home from a nearby outing a few months ago. We entered the bar area and saw no hostess. No eye contact from the bartender. We were left standing there wondering if we were to check in somewhere else. Waitresses and possible hostess walked by us several times without acknowledgement. It got to be almost 20 minutes and was so uncomfortable. We were finally seated with no menu or water and it was an additional 10 minutes before someone yelled over to us whether anyone had taken our order. Our waitress was pleasant enough. The food was mediocre. We generally experience friendly service in small towns but on this visit, they seemed to only cater to locals. Probably won’t be back.
… more
Tracey Hensen
Just love the Buckhorn! Great food and friendly service. Excellent old fashions and delicious ice cream drinks. Cassie and Bobbi make you feel like old friends and take great care in making dinner a great experience.
… more
Mark Wimberly
This was our first time here. It is a traditional supper club. The food was good the service was great day the ice cream drinks were good. You get alot of food for a fair price. In Milwaukee you would pay 75.00 or more for the prime rib that was 36.00 here.
… more
Gordon Duer
Had the Big Ben prime rib with baked potatoes and onions block appetizer. Was seated right away and then server took my drink order. She was very pleasant and professional. The food was very tasty. I also received a bread stick basket with cheese spread and a roll. The roll wasl the only thing that did not stand out. Also had the clam chowder.
… more
Ronna Blackley
My husband and I LOVE Supperclubs..We both had the steak sandwiches with fries..mine medium, his well done they were perfect. I paired mine with mushrooms & onions and he had the soup, potato ham and bacon..Everybody was Friendly..great visit..
… more
Steve
The food was good but two out of three in the party are sick the next day with stomach cramping and diarrhea. We all had the prime rib. The only difference between the the ones who got sick was the salad dressing and cucumber. We had ranch dressing and cucumbers and the other person didn’t.
… more
… View more