Based on 246 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
36 James St, Middletown, NY 10940
Phone: (845) 342-1222
Website: https://www.caputospizzany.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8:30 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Yanira Quinones
Honestly by far the greatest pizza place I’ve gone to in Middletown! I always order from here whether it’s pasta, ice cream, Stromboli, wings everything is delicious. Mind you this is a size small Stromboli. I had leftovers for lunch the next day. And the wings had surprisingly a lot meat on them. I’m so happy this place is right around the corner from my house. 10/10 would recommend coming to eat here.
… more
Gavinhates People
The food here is always fresh and delicious, the customer service is amazing. The workers are very nice, friendly, and helpful. They even support the local skatepark next door.
… more
Heather Mann
The best pizza in all of Middletown! affordable prices, fast reliable service. All around a great place to frequent.
… more
Donna Niell
I’ve been eating at Caputo’s for years , since they were located up North St in Middletown. They relocated to a beautiful new location Downtown (and they brought the fish tank with them) The food is still great especially the veal parm hero. The pizza is just right not too doughy and not too thin. The reason for this review is not only to mention the food but what a great staff that works there. My best friend had a medical emergency at ORMC so they called another pizza place to deliver for the family that was stuck at the hospital waiting. After waiting for 2 1/2 hrs and no delivery my friend called me in a panic. I called Caputo’s and they had two pies ready in 10 minutes. when I showed to pick them up(they do deliver but that was not an optional this time) I explained the situation and Brittany allowed me to use one of the pizza holder warmers to deliver them to the hospital. they went out of their way service wise. If you have to travel downtown Middletown, To the DMV, Library, City Hall, Court or the Police station stop here and have a slice or great sandwich or dinner. Highly recommended.
… more
Good Egg Of Wisdom
Great spot to take the family to. We had a blast of great food, not only pizza but multiple varieties of things to choose from, even desert and Icecream.
… more
nyomee rodriguez (fluffy)
The pizza is ok if you like dough and cheese. They barely put any sauce. That’s what makes the pizza. Tried 3 times same thing.. hardly no sauce in the pie. Garlic knots are excellent and salads. This place is through word of mouth for sure… speaking only about their pies. Bite into a slice and it’s dry. Brother brunos has good pizza… good pizza with sauce… yummy. Sauce it up Caputo’s.. and maybe
… more
Adrienne Dawkins
We’ve been ordering from Caputo’s for years but this was our last order. We called in advance and told them the last 5 pies have been lacking sauce. We also asked if they were going to send a fresh pie. They assured us the pie would be fresh with the right amount of sauce. That wasn’t the case. Instead they sent us another DRY pizza with barely any sauce. What a waste of money and not the Caputo pizza we have grown to love. I don’t know what has changed over there but the pizza has fallen off big time
… more
William Bougart
noticed this place gave free pizza to the skateboarders at the park what a nice gesture. check out the new boba tea place down main st called Mon Tea
… more
Jherry DI DANCA
Before I finish this scrumptious pizza I had to write this review. WOW now that’s PIZZA. The rich cheese and the SAUCE IS PERFECT. The garlic knots I can eat a dozen of. I found my new favorite pizzeria in Middletown. Oh and the customer service when I walked in till the time I sat down.
… more
Rvf K
Best pizza in Middletown
… more
… View more