Carmelina’s is the newest pizzeria and takeout spot in Center Moriches! The Giordano family has owned and operated restaurants and pizzeria’s across long island for the last 60 years and we could not be more excited to serve the Center Moriches community. We make delicious pizza’s and dinners fresh to order, and we also have a massive selection of fresh made slices and sandwiches every single day.
Based on 44 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
794 Montauk Hwy, Center Moriches, NY 11934
Phone: (631) 878-4755
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lyn Najdek
1st time eating from here since new owners and name change. Was disappointed. Ordered a Sicilian Pie with meatballs and sausage. The bottom was burned, dough was way over worked and not a lot of toppings. Veal parmigiana was way dry, hardly any sauce and the bread was hard.The cinnamon sugar zeppoli’s are hard, and so oily. Don’t think we’ll even give it a second try. If we weren’t so hungry and it was earlier, I would’ve run out to grab something else to eat.
… more
Nick Antonaccio
So I just want to say, this is my favorite pizza place. Their pizza, and all their hot items are amazing. However their Italian sub I was extremely disappointed in. At almost $17 there’s about a slice of each meat along the entire sub….I’ll keep coming for the pizza as they’re the best pizza in the area.
… more
Miguel Fernandez
You can always tell when something is made with love, that’s what my grandma used to say. When you walk into this place, the pizza counter has all sorts of special slices, one looks better than the next! The owner’s super creative and expands the imagination of what pizza can be.
… more
Linda Edwards
This past weekend I was working in the area and I decided to get something to eat afterwards. There was a few places to choose from a BBQ place and a few other places so I decided to go into Carmelina’s. As I entered inside I automatically was taken back by the cleanliness and fresh display of food which was very enticing. There was an array of different choices to choose from. The moment I made my decision the gentleman behind the counter was welcoming and
… more
Frank Douglas
Eh….gave it a try 3 times since they were new. Definitely better pizza around. Hands down the worse garlic knots I have ever eaten in my life! Had a bite and threw half dozen away.
… more
S MC
First time going to carmelinas tonight, thanks to my sister’s recommendation… and I have to say, hands down best pizzeria I’ve ever been too! The food was delicious! The staff, owner & cook were so polite& the restaurant was clean! I will definitely be coming back to Carmelinas!
… more
Mike “Bar.snobs” DeMarino
This place is great. Delicious pizza, lots of variety. The staff and owners are so nice. Try the Detroit!
… more
melinda zavesky
First time trying out Carmelina’s. My slice was great and had a nice crispy bottom. Im not a fan pizza that falls down when holding it so I appreciated the nice bottom and crust. Their mozzarella sticks were really good too! They are a lot longer than typical, so you definitely get your moneys worth. I would recommend!
… more
Becky Marshall
Our favorite pizza spot!
… more
J Rabbits
There is alot of inconsistenty with the basic cheese pie. Some days it so good, cheesy and nice size. Other times it’s a flat bread with cheese on it. In addition, burnt on the bottom side. The “pizza” makers are not consistent and therefore you get a different pie every time.
… more
… View more