Carroll House Restaurant Menu – Sister Bay, WI

Type : Family restaurant

Location : Sister Bay, WI

Based on 582 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Carroll House Restaurant 54234

Address:
2445 S Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234

Phone: (920) 854-7997

Website:

Hours

Thursday 7 AM–2 PM
Friday 7 AM–2 PM
Saturday 7 AM–2 PM
Sunday 7 AM–2 PM
Monday 7 AM–2 PM
Tuesday 7 AM–2 PM
Wednesday 7 AM–2 PM

Menu

Breakfast
Wake Up Special
7am-8am, 2 eggs, hash browns, toast		 $4.25
Quiche Of The Day
Served with fresh fruit and toast		 $9.50
Famous Carroll House Waffles
One Egg – Any Style $3.50
Two Eggs – Any Style $4.50
Three Eggs – Any Style $5.50
Pork Chop
Served with two eggs any style, hashbrowns & toast		 $9.75
Chicken & Waffle $9.95
Country Fried Steak
Served with two eggs any style, hashbrowns & toast		 $9.95
Eggs Benedict
Served with hashbrowns		 $9.95
Steak & Eggs
Served with two eggs any style & hashbrowns & toast		 $13.50
One Slice $3.50
Two Slices $4.75
Three Slices $5.95
One Pancake $3.25
Two Pancakes $4.50
Lunch
Soups/Chili
Homemade soups that warm the soul		 $3.75
Bacon Cheese Burger $8.95
Mushroom And Swiss Burger
1/3 lb. prime beef served on toasted bun		 $7.95
Pattymelt
1/3 lb. prime beef on toasted dark rye with fried onions, melted swiss and cheddar cheese		 $7.95
Grilled Cheese $6.95
Tuna Melt
Our fresh made tuna salad with melted cheddar cheese on grilled rye		 $7.50
Tuna Salad Sandwich
On toasted bread of choice		 $7.50
Carroll House Grilled Roast Beef
Prime roast beef with sautéed mushrooms, onions, green peppers topped with melted swiss cheese on grilled whole wheat and horseradish sauce on the side		 $8.95
Bacon, Lettuce And Tomato
Served with choice of bread toasted with mayo		 $8.25
Carroll House Club
Smoked turkey and bacon with lettuce, tomato and mayo		 $8.95
Reuben
Shaved corned beef with sauerkraut and swiss cheese on rye, grilled to perfection		 $8.95
Rachel
Shaved turkey with sauerkraut and swiss cheese on rye,grilled to perfection		 $8.95
Italian Beef
Grilled green peppers and onions with mozzarella cheese on a hoagie bun		 $8.95
Ham And Swiss
Served on toasted rye		 $8.25
Veggie Melt
Cucumber, tomato, spinach, red onions, sautéed mushrooms, green peppers with swiss on grilled whole wheat		 $8.25
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
Served on a toasted bun with tomato, lettuce and mayo		 $8.50
Crispy Chicken Breast Sandwich
Served on a toasted bun with tomato, lettuce and mayo		 $8.50
Turkey Melt
Shaved turkey and bacon with swiss on grilled rye		 $8.25
Chicken Tenders Basket
With french fries		 $8.50
Turkey Wrap
Lettuce, tomato, onions, shredded mozzarella cheese and ranch dressing		 $8.50
Chicken Club Wrap
Bacon, tomato, lettuce, onions and mayo		 $8.75
Ceasar Wrap
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, croutons and shredded parmesan cheese		 $8.75
Veggie Wrap
Spinach, tomato, sautéed mushrooms, onions, cheese, carrots and guacamole		 $8.75
At The Door
Crispy lettuce, dried cherries, walnuts, mandarin oranges, sunflower seeds, sliced hard boiled egg, feta cheese crumbles, choice of dressing		 $7.95
Crispy Chicken And Cashews
Crispy lettuce, cashews, tomato, red onions, green pepper, cucumber, choice of dressing		 $8.95
Chef Special
Crisp lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onions, carrots, swiss and cheddar cheese topped with ham, turkey, bacon and choice of dressing		 $8.75
Taco Salad
Crisp lettuce, tomato, ground beef, sour cream, guacamole, cheese and spanish salsa		 $9.25
Chili Lime Shrimp
Sweet chili shrimp, tomato, red onions, cucumber, red and green peppers with a honey lime dressing		 $8.95
French Fries $3.50
American Fries $3.50
Onion Rings $4.25
Cheese Curds $5.95
Hashbrowns $3.50
Side Salad $4.95
Additions
Root Beer Floats $3.50
Beverages
Coffee $2.10
Hot Tea $2.00
Hot Chocolate $2.75
Milk
Soda
W/refill coca-cola products		 $2.10
Lemonade
W/refill		 $2.10
Fresh Brewed Iced Tea $2.10

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Mark Renfro
A good place for a hardy breakfast with larger selection. They were very busy when we visited but we received great service. Our order was taken quickly and the meals arrive quick, fresh, and correct.

… more

Asalia Diaz Ortega
Best waffle in door county!!! Such fast service & the atmosphere is great!! The worker is darling, I’ve never met Carroll but I feel like I have thru this food. Come early the parking is tight.

… more

Christopher Frey
Nice homey diner with a good selection of breakfast and lunch. The food was solid but nothing in particular went above and beyond. The service was efficient yet pleasant and staff were all very nice.

… more

Chas Erickson
We had a good experience here. Arrived on a rainy Monday morning when apparently everyone wanted to have breakfast. The place is small so we had a wait but we were routinely kept up to date on getting a table (unsolicited) and once we got seated, service was prompt and attentive.

… more

Barak Reese
Al’s had a long wait and we were on a time-line. The dining room was full, but they got us in outside on the patio. The food was delicious and came out quick and correct. Staff is friendly.

… more

Kyle Herman
Nice little place with great prices. I had the Bacon/Chicken Wrap and it was delicious. I would come back for sure and try more of the delicious menu items…

… more

Jarek Strugacz
We had eggs benedict,veggie omelet and cherry stuffed waffles. Everything was fresh and delicious. Service was excellent. Definitely recommend this place!

… more

Ezra Rodriguez
We walked in with 7 people about 80 minutes before they closed at 2pm. The staff were incredibly accommodating and friendly. We were out within 40 minutes and stuffed with delicious food. I ordered a ham and cheese omelette that came with 2 pieces of toast. I also ordered a side of hashbrowns and their house waffle topped with strawberries and whipped cream. Their food was incredible but their WAFFLES are to DIE FOR. Overall amazing interaction and I left feeling great. Definitely recommend.

… more

Pat Corbley
Great little breakfast place. Limited seating and parking so during the peak season be prepared to wait for a table. But the wait will be worth it. The food was prepared perfectly. Waffle was done completely but not hard or crispy. Sausage was very good and just a little spicy. Eggs were done exactly as I like them. Portions were ample and the cost was reasonable. Definitely will be going back next time in Door County.

… more

Ashleigh N
Very cute on the inside. We didn’t have to wait for a table at all, even on a Sunday. The food was very good and came out fast.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch