Italian hub with quick slices or full dinners in a simple dining room & outdoor area with fire pit. Based on 104 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
Address:
41 Broadway, Rocky Point, NY 11778
Phone: (631) 744-1117
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rita
This is our family’s local pizzeria. The food is really good and they’re consistent. We usually order a pepperoni Sicilian. We’ve tried all the pizzerias with in the wading river and Rocky Point are and we feel, their red sauce is the best. It’s flavorful, gentle, and not salty; like home made sauce. Really good.
… more
matt engelbert
Every time I bring my girlfriend and/or her kids we have an exceptional experience. Her and I went once just before closing and they were willing to stay late and accommodate us. Instead of putting them out, we decided to take it home. Our waitress gave us each a glass of wine on the house. My beautiful girlfriend and I are definitely foodies, and this is definitely a place to go to get exceptional itialian food. Way above par and not the usual stereotypical fare. High end food, with high end service and wine to boot. Plus they put up with the demon children. All in all an amazing place and I’d recommend it to anyone.
… more
Joe Montanez
Not the best customer service, everytime I come in with my wife they take her order and walk away without asking me what I want. It has happened the past 4 to 5 times now. The staff doesn’t pay much attention either and usually messes up the order. It was definitely better a couple of years ago. Not sure what happened. I wouldn’t recommend eating here.
… more
Bonnie Haley
We are long time customers. Last night we ordered one pie at 6:00 and it got delivered at 7:30 pm and it was ICE COLD. I called to complain this morning and was told by the “ manager” that she was very sorry but they were very busy last night. She did not offer a replacement pie. As a self-employed business woman, I find this bad business and unacceptable! Time to try out a new pizza place. Fortunately, there are pizza places in every shopping center! Goodbye Carusos Pizza in Rocky Point!
… more
Christian Krepelka
Excellent large party locaton and offer a $10 price fix lunch. Staff is very nice.! They also do catering trays so place your order for the coming holiday season.! 🙂
… more
Melissa Kelly
Disappointed. I went with a group, the leader was told one thing erroneously and then day of was called and the “deal” changed to be about 5 dollars a person more with a limited selection and tea or coffee (which was never offered or served) they did not increase wait staff so service was S-L-O-W it was a 3 hour lunch without dessert, entertainment or someone opening gifts (like if i attended a shower or something) I have no idea why. If I’d have walked in off the street i’d have gotten better quicker service and a better price. Count me out for future visits and recommendations.
… more
Jessy F
Great food- kids favorite pizza! If you want a suggestion, ask for a bit of extra sauce on the pie- is so amazing! Tastes great reheated too
… more
Chris Sanford
Was there for a dinner with my wife, four daughters and their three boyfriends. If you don’t like Italian food, then you shouldn’t be dining at Caruso’s. However, if you do there are few places, if any, in our local area that provide a better dining experience for the price. Food was excellent all around.
… more
Steve Molison
Great pizza but…..
… more
MSG
Really enjoyed the pizza. Hadn’t been there in a while. Bought a pie, planned on having 3 slices and saving the rest for lunch the next day. Ate the whole pie. No regrets.
… more
… View more