Based on 57 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
2600 Middletown Cir, White Hall, WV 26554
Phone: (304) 816-3536
Website: http://casadamiciwv.com/
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Reviews
Kimi V
A lot of options!!! I got the deal for 2 slices and a fountain drink for $7. They had about 8-10 different pizzas to choose a slice from (including specialty pizzas) and the man at the counter was very helpful in explaining what each one was! The slices were very big and fresh! They cook your slice in the oven, so the bottom is crispy and fresh! Traditional New York style thin slices. Mine were finished in about 3 minutes and they brought it over to me! You can add parmesan cheese and red pepper flakes. I got the pepperoni and a buffalo chicken slice. The pepperoni was definitely my favorite, but both were so good! I’ll definitely be back 🙂
… more
Dan Rowcroft
Some of the best pizza I’ve had here. Growing up in the Philly area it’s difficult to find pizza like the pizza of my childhood. Especially since Vito’s closed. Vito’s was the best pizza in WV. This place is a different pizza than Vito’s but closer to the Philly style I grew up with give it a try it’s really good. The meatballs are great as well. Not sure where the 1 star review came from. I’m guessing they were here a day or two after they opened? I had no problem the place was clean, staff were happy and I received the correct order with a smile. I will be back everything was great.
… more
Doss Arts Danielle Doss
I can’t say how awesome they were!! I got there kind of late (8 they close at 9). I ordered. There was a miscommunication from me to the cashier, and there was one item that was wrong. It was my fault for not catching it when she repeated the order. At this point, it is close to 8:30, and I am certain they want to start getting ready to break down for closing, but unfortunately, I was having guests, and I had to have the pizza. I was completely prepared to pay for the pizza because the girl repeated it back, and I confirmed it. Not only did they apologize for the inconvenience. (That really I caused them, sorry y’all) They remade the completely free. I love their pizza anyway, and by accident, I have tried now their subs. * chef kiss* As good as everything you know and love there!! But the service there is even better than the food. Thanks y’all!
… more
Eron S
We love their 20″ pizza and garlic knots.
… more
MICHELLE ANDERSON
As soon as I walked in the restaurant I was greeted by a very friendly staff member. She told me the specials and asked if I had any questions. I proceeded to order and I got my food to go. This was hands down the best pizza I’ve had in Fairmont EVER!!!!! I never eat the crust of pizza but this place changed my mind!!!!!! Looking forward to trying other things on menu but I am highly impressed!!!!!
… more
Wittlee Retton
Great customer service and amazing food! We felt like we were back in Italy. Kid friendly and family oriented. Heard great things and had to try for ourselves. We will be back! 100 stars if it was possible!
… more
chatto hill
Great local place to get food. It’s more expensive than I like, but the food is really good and it’s a local business (so I’ll pay more). I wish there was more outdoor seating.
… more
Jeff Raymond
As a New Yorker, I was disappointed with the pizza. It’s NY style, but not NY flavor. The sauce isn’t very good, and the cheese doesn’t taste like fresh Mozzarella. Even bad pizza in NY tases better. Service was great and the place feels like a NY pizzeria. Unfortunately, I was disappointed. I just can’t get good pizza or bagels here.
… more
Amy Fitch
Great pizza. We order from here occasionally and have had good food so far.
… more
Bugsy Cline
Excellent pizza for this area. Best when buying by the slice. They have a 2 slice one drink special that is awesome. The slices are monstrously sized. They have several types to choose from. While they offer many of the usual pizza joint offerings, for me its the Pizza by the Slice that shows where they excel. I was a fan of their Morgantown High Street location for several years. It’s a new york style which is thin and crispy and light. Its hard to get a NY style pizza in Morgantown, most of them are too thick and too floppy heavy with grease and too much cheese (typical of midwestern style pie) so Casa is a welcome alternative to the norm. When you get it by the slice it’s super crispy. I recommend it over the whole pie. But the whole pie heats up nice if you use a hot cast iron pan and your broiler to reheat.
… more
… View more