Cozy, relaxed dining room serving Italian standards from pasta to seafood plates plus wine & beer. Based on 384 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
477 Old Country Rd, Westbury, NY 11590
Phone: (516) 385-3700
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: casadifratelliwestbury.comopentable.com
Reviews
Rhonda Singh
I have visited this establishment 3 times & every time I go the food & service is always superb! My niece originally took me here for a valentines dinner during restaurant week in 2022 which featured their $35 3 course prixe-fixe dinner menu which had great choices. Since then I’ve been back 2X for dinner whether it was birthdays or just a week night out & the food, ambience & service is always great! I definitely recommend this restaurant & will be back! I think I may even inquire about hosting a dinner party & see what options are available! Love it!
… more
Vonny E
This place is a hidden gem. Staff is amazing. Food is delicious. I can’t wait to go back.
… more
Phil Carbo
A hidden gem on Westbury. My friend recommended it as an impromptu choice for some out-of-town guests craving Italian and even though I’ve driven past it dozens of times, I never even noticed it. Portions are generous and the prices are very fair for this area of town. $40 for a NY strip with two full sides, $30 for a half duck and $28 for a very large pork chop. We had fried zucchini flowers and calamari for an appetizer. The calamari was a bit dry but passable. The zucchini flowers were very tasty. The duck entrée (pictured) was seasoned with orange and cranberries. The steak, cooked medium rare was a requested and even without being finished with butter ( at the diner’s request), was tender and juicy. They were out of several deserts such was a disappointment but my friends said the tiramisu was delicious. Overall, we had a good meal and didn’t break the bank.
… more
Mango
I’ve come here so many times. Family run old school Italian, beautiful ambiance, great cocktails, reasonable and delicious. I can’t stop coming here. This is the ideal place for large parties or small, beautiful at Christmas time as well! It does not have that commercial feel. I will always be coming here
… more
Melissa Leibowitz
The best night ever!! My hubby and I went out for our 20th year anniversary and had a perfect evening! Our waiter Frank was just wonderful and I also met Giovanni who was also very sweet. The food melted in our mouths and was worth every penny! See you very very soon!!!
… more
Ryan Tammaro
I stopped into Casa Di Fratelli on a Wednesday night to catch up with a friend. The restaurant was quiet that evening, which was great, since we were able to have an enjoyable conversation and received attentive service.
… more
barry bernstein
This was a big disappointment! My wife and I have gone here many times before Covid so, although it’s a ride, we made a reservation for a Saturday afternoon since we were meeting friends who live nearby. I asked for a specific table since they are not usually busy at that hour. Not only was the table not available but it was in the two thirds of the restaurant where a children’s birthday party was in progress. To say it was noisy would be a complete understatement. The restaurant certainly had an obligation to let us know this in advance but I guess the extra few bucks was more important than being honest with a long standing client. We certainly would have left if it was only the two of us.
… more
shanna comacho
I am sad to say that I will never return to this restaurant again along with my family and friends. My friends and I would go there every other week, I have had my birthdays and my friends birthdays here. On Friday 5/19/23, we were treated so disrespectfully I am still in shock. We were told we did not leave a tip on our last outing and we did. We always leave a tip and I explained that to the waitress and I was told very nasty that we only leave 20%. I couldn’t believe her attitude and since when is 20% not a good tip. It was the owners daughter and she does not know the first thing about customer service or human decency. I will never go to Casa di Fratelli and neither will my family and friends. When I talked to the owner he didn’t even apologize for her ATTROCUOUS BEHAVIOR. I suggest she learns how to treat the people that keep the lights on and be respectful!
… more
Justin Bayoneto
Truly a hidden gem that I can’t believe I haven’t been to sooner. As soon as you enter there’s a bit of a regal atmosphere, such a clean and welcoming dining room. The staff are extremely professional and cordial, excellent service all around. As for the food, simply outstanding! Portions are huge and the quality is fresh. Relatively cheap price point for a great meal. I’m surprised they’re not as packed as they deserve to be, certainly a must visit place that’ll I’ll personally be coming back to.
… more
Cin Torres Espinal
We were at Casa di fratelli this past weekend for a graduation dinner and service and food was amazing! Karina and Eric did an amazing job with the party, everyone was happy and there was never an empty glass. Sangria was delicious and so was the chicken parm and penne a la vodka. Will be back
… more
… View more