Casa Mia Menu – Hurleyville, NY

Type : Italian restaurant

Location : Hurleyville, NY

Based on 355 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Casa Mia 12747

Address:
205 Main St, Hurleyville, NY 12747

Phone: (845) 434-8051

Website:

Hours

Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday 11 AM–10 PM
Sunday 11 AM–9 PM
Monday 11 AM–9 PM

Menu

Main Menu
Meatballs $5.95
Meatball Parmigiana $6.50
Sausage $5.95
Sausage Parmigiana $6.50
Sausage & Peppers $6.50
Sausage & Peppers Parmigiana $6.95
Veal Cutlet With Sauce $6.75
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana $7.95
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana
with peppers		 $8.25
Eggplant Parmigiana $6.75
Chicken Parmigiana $6.95
Shrimp Parmigiana $10.75
Chicken & Broccoli Rabe $9.25
Sausage & Broccoli Rabe $9.25
French Fries Potatoes (Homemade) $3.25
Large Pizza $12.50
Pizza With Meatballs $14.50
Pizza With Peppers $14.50
Pizza With Mushrooms $14.50
Pizza With Sausage $14.50
Pizza With Pepperoni $14.50
Pizza With Anchovies $14.50
Pizza With Onions $14.50
Pizza With Garlic $14.50
Pizza With Extra Cheese $14.50
Pizza With Broccoli $14.50
Pizza With Eggplant $14.50
Pizza With Black Olives $14.50
Pizza With Bacon $14.50
Pizza With Pineapple $14.50
Pizza With Cherry Peppers $14.50
Pizza With Garbage Pie $18.50
Pizza With Chicken $18.50
Pizza With White Pie $15.50
Pizza With Veggie Pie $18.50
Pizza With Boneless Buffalo Wing $19.50
Lunch Menu
Chicken Wings
10 pieces hot or mild		 $6.95
Fresh Mozzarella & Tomatoes $7.95
Fried Mozzarella Sticks $6.95
House Salad $3.00
Cold Antipasto $6.95
Chef Salad $6.50
Fried Calamari $9.95
Baked Clams $6.95
Homemade French Fries $3.25
Grilled Chicken Salad $7.50
Grilled Shrimp Salad $9.95
Pasta Fagioli Or Soup Of The Day $2.95
Tomato Sauce $7.95
Marinara Sauce $7.95
Meatballs $8.25
Sausages $8.25
Meat Sauce $8.95
Mushroom Sauce $8.95
Garlic & Oil $7.95
Bolognese $9.75
Vodka Cream Sauce $9.75
White Or Red Clam Sauce $9.75
Baked Ziti $7.25
Baked Lasagna $8.25
Manicotti $7.00
Cheese Ravioli $7.50
Pasta With Shrimp $8.95
Pasta With Calamari $8.50
Tortellini Alfredo $8.95
Pasta Combo
stuffed shells, manicotti & lasagna		 $8.95
Parmigiana $10.50
Francesea $10.50
Marsala Mushrooms $10.50
Piccata $10.50
Chicken Scarpariello $9.50
Chicken & Broccoli $8.75
Chicken Breast Milanese $9.50
Chicken Valdestano $10.95
Parmigiana $12.50
Francesea $12.50
Marsala Mushrooms $12.50
Piccata $12.50
Veal Cutlet Milanese $11.50
Eggplant Parmigiana $8.50
Eggplant Rolatini $8.95
Meatball Parmigiana $7.95
Sausage & Peppers $7.75
Parmigiana Combo $12.50
Pizza Slice $2.00
Large Pizza $12.50
Pizza With Meatballs $14.50
Pizza With Peppers $14.50
Pizza With Mushrooms $14.50
Pizza With Sausage $14.50
Pizza With Pepperoni $14.50
Pizza With Anchovies $14.50
Pizza With Onions $14.50
Pizza With Garlic $14.50
Pizza With Extra Cheese $14.50
Pizza With Broccoli $14.50
Pizza With Eggplant $14.50
Pizza With Black Olives $14.50
Pizza With Bacon $14.50
Pizza With Pineapple $14.50
Pizza With Cherry Peppers $14.50
Pizza With Garbage Pie $18.50
Pizza With Chicken $18.50
Pizza With White Pie $15.50
Pizza With Veggie Pie $18.50
Pizza With Boneless Buffalo Wing $19.50
Meatballs $5.95
Meatball Parmigiana $6.50
Sausage $5.95
Sausage Parmigiana $6.50
Sausage & Peppers $6.50
Sausage & Peppers Parmigiana $6.95
Veal Cutlet With Sauce $6.75
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana $7.95
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana
with peppers		 $8.25
Eggplant Parmigiana $6.75
Chicken Parmigiana $6.95
Shrimp Parmigiana $10.75
Chicken & Broccoli Rabe $9.25
Sausage & Broccoli Rabe $9.25
Grilled Chicken $6.95
Buffalo Chicken $6.95
Eggplant, Fresh Mozzarella, Roast Pepper & Basil $8.50
Dinner Menu
Cold Antipasto $6.50
Hot Antipasto $11.00
Baked Clams $6.95
Shrimp Cocktail $8.00
Chef Salad $6.00
Buffalo Chicken Wings
10 ct.-mild or hot		 $6.95
Mussels Marinara $9.95
Fried Mozzarella Sticks $6.95
Fried Calamari $9.95
Fresh Mozzarella & Tomatoes $7.95
House Salad $3.00
Grilled Chicken Salad $7.50
Pasta Fagioli $4.00
Soup Of The Day (Seasonal)
priced accordingly
Veal Chops (2) $28.95
Porterhouse Steak $28.95
Broiled Pork Chops $19.95
Pizzaiola Sauce $4.00
Onions $4.00
Peppers $4.00
Mushrooms $5.00
Vinegar Peppers $5.00
Pizzaiola, Mushrooms & Peppers $5.00
Hot Cherry Peppers & Potatoes $5.00
Supreme
sausage, potatoes, onions & peppers		 $7.00
Giambotta Di Casa
broccoli rabe, sausage & potatoes		 $8.00
Broiled Twin Lobster Tails $26.95
F&J’s Lobster Tail Fra Diavolo $34.95
Lobster Tail Scampi With Shrimp $33.95
Broiled Lobster Tail With Shrimp Oreganato $33.95
Shrimp $21.95
Seafood Combo
broiled shrimp, scallops & filet		 $20.95
Scungili Fra Diavolo Or Marinara $18.95
Scungili & Calamari
fra diavolo or marinara		 $18.95
Stuffed Filet Of Sole $19.95
Stuffed Filet Of Sole With Shrimp $21.95
Broiled Filet Of Sole $18.95
Broiled Halibut $18.95
Broiled Salmon $18.95
Calamari Fra Diavolo Or Marinara $17.95
Fried Calamari $17.95
Fried Fish Combo
scallops, shrimp & calamari		 $22.95
Scallops:
broiled, oreganato, marinara or fra diavolo		 $21.95
Linguine, Spaghetti, Penne Or Rigatoni With Tomato Sauce $10.95
Linguine, Spaghetti, Penne Or Rigatoni With Marinara Sauce $10.95
Linguine, Spaghetti, Penne Or Rigatoni With Meat Sauce $13.95
Linguine, Spaghetti, Penne Or Rigatoni With Mushroom Sauce $13.95
Linguine, Spaghetti, Penne Or Rigatoni With Meatballs $12.95
Linguine, Spaghetti, Penne Or Rigatoni With Sausages $12.95
Linguine, Spaghetti, Penne Or Rigatoni With Garlic & Oil $12.95
Linguine, Spaghetti, Penne Or Rigatoni With White Or Red Clam Sauce $14.50
Linguine, Spaghetti, Penne Or Rigatoni With Bolognese
meat with touch of cream		 $14.50
Linguine, Spaghetti, Penne Or Rigatoni With Filetto Di Pomodoro $14.50
Linguine, Spaghetti, Penne Or Rigatoni With Vodka Cream Sauce $14.50
Baked Ziti $12.50
Baked Ziti Siciliana $13.95
Baked Ziti With Ricotta $13.95
Baked Lasagna $14.95
Baked Lasagna Siciliana $15.50
Homemade Manicotti $12.95
Homemade Stuffed Shells $12.95
Homemade Cheese Ravioli $11.95
Linguine Or Spaghetti With Shrimp $16.50
Linguine Or Spaghetti With Calamari $16.50
Fettuccine Alfredo $14.50
Tortellini Alfredo $14.95
Pasta Combo
stuffed shells, manicotti & lasagna		 $14.95
Chicken Breast Parmigiana $17.95
Broiled Half Chicken $14.95
Chicken Scarpariello
sautéed with sausage & potatoes in tangy herb sauce		 $17.95
Chicken & Broccoli
sautéed & simmered in lemon wine sauce		 $17.95
Chicken Breast Milanese $16.95
Chicken Valdestano
baked with prosciutto, mozzarella, mushroom tomato marsala sauce		 $18.95
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana $19.95
Veal Valdestano $20.95
Veal Parmigiana Siciliano $20.95
Veal Cutlet Milanese $18.95
Eggplant Pamigiana $15.95
Eggplant Rollatini $16.95
Sausage & Peppers $15.95
Meatball Parmigiana Dinner $14.95
Cacciatore $17.95
Francese $17.95
Marsala With Mushrooms $17.95
Piccata $17.95
Pizzaiola, Mushrooms & Peppers $19.95
Francese $19.95
Marsala With Mushrooms $19.95
Pizzaiola Parmigiana $19.95
Piccata $19.95
Fettuccine, Escarole & Sausage With Garlic & Oil $16.95
Pasta & Broccoli With Garlic & Oil $13.95
Pasta & Broccoli With Marinara $13.95
Pasta, Chicken & Broccoli $16.95
Penne With Broccoli Rabe & Sausage $17.95
Parmigiana Combo $19.95
Surf & Turf $36.95
Mussels Marinara Over Linguine $16.95
Shrimp & Scallops $22.95
Sautéed Mushrooms $5.00
Sautéed Potatoes, Onions & Peppers $5.50
Meatballs Or Sausages $3.50
Broccoli Rabe (Seasonal)
French Fries $3.00
Escarole & Beans $7.95
Escarole With Garlic & Oil $6.95
Broccoli With Butter & Garlic $3.75
Giambotta Di Casa
broccoli raba, sausage & po		 $8.50
Tartufo $5.25
New York Style Cheesecake $5.25
Tiramasu $5.25
Chocolate Mousse Cake $5.25
Take Out Menu
Cold Antipasto $6.95
Hot Antipasto $11.50
Shrimp Cocktail $8.00
Chef Salad $6.50
Buffalo Chicken Wings
10 ct.-mild or hot		 $6.95
Mussels Marinara $9.95
Fried Mozzarella Sticks $6.95
Fried Calamari $9.95
Fresh Mozzarella & Tomatoes $7.95
House Salad $3.00
Grilled Chicken Salad $7.50
Pasta Fagioli $4.00
Soup Of The Day (Seasonal)
Baked Ziti $12.95
Baked Ziti Siciliana $13.95
Baked Ziti With Ricotta $13.95
Baked Lasagna (Homemade) $14.95
Baked Lasagna Siciliana $15.50
Homemade Manicotti $12.95
Homemade Stuffed Shells $12.95
Homemade Cheese Ravioli $11.95
Linguine Or Spaghetti With Shrimp $16.50
Linguine Or Spaghetti With Calamari $16.50
Fettuccine Alfredo $14.95
Tortellini Alfredo $14.95
Pasta Combo
stuffed shells, manicotti & lasagna		 $14.95
Baked Ziti $12.50
Baked Lasagna $14.95
Fettuccine Alfredo $14.50
Pasta Combo $14.95
Chicken Breast Parmigiana $17.95
Broiled Half Chicken $14.50
Chicken Scarpariello
sautéed with sausage & potatoes in tangy herb sauce		 $17.95
Chicken & Broccoli
sautéed & simmered in lemon wine sauce		 $17.95
Chicken Breast Milanese $16.95
Chicken Valdestano
baked with prosciutto, mozzarella, mushroom & tomato marsala sauce		 $18.95
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana $19.95
Veal Valdestano $20.95
Veal Parmigiana Siciliano $20.95
Veal Cutlet Milanese $18.95
Eggplant Parmigiana $15.95
Eggplant Rollatini $16.95
Sausage & Peppers $15.50
Meatball Parmigiana Dinner $14.50
Cacciatore $17.95
Francese $17.95
Marsala With Mushrooms $17.95
Piccata $17.95
Pizzaiola, Mushrooms & Peppers $19.95
Francese $19.95
Marsala With Mushrooms $19.95
Pizzaiola Parmigiana $19.95
Piccata $19.95
Fettuccine, Escarole & Sausage
with garlic & oil		 $16.95
Pasta & Broccoli With Garlic & Oil $13.95
Pasta & Broccoli With Marinara $13.95
Pasta, Chicken & Broccoli
with marinara or garlic & oil		 $16.95
Penne
with broccoli rabe & sausage		 $17.95
Parmigiana Combo
chicken, veal & shrimp		 $19.95
Surf & Turf $36.95
Mussels Marinara Over Linguine $16.95
Shrimp & Scallops
in vodka cream sauce over fettuccine		 $22.95
Sautéed Mushrooms $5.00
Sautéed Potatoes, Onions & Peppers $5.50
Meatballs Or Sausages $3.50
Broccoli Rabe (Seasonal)
Escarole & Beans $7.95
Escarole With Garlic & Oil $6.95
Broccoli With Butter & Garlic $3.75
Giambotta Di Casa
broccoli raba, sausage & potates		 $8.50
Children’s Dinner Menu
Tomato Sauce $6.50
Marinara $6.50
Meatsauce $7.00
Meatballs $7.00
Sausage $7.00
Garlic & Oil $7.00
Baked Ziti $7.00
Baked Lasagna $8.00
Manicotti $7.50
Cheese Ravioli $7.50
Stuffed Shells
Veal Parmigiana $9.00
Chicken Parmigiana $8.50
Eggplant Parmigiana $7.50
Shrimp Parmigiana $10.95
Chicken Fingers $8.50

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: snaptown-online.com

Reviews

Kerry Sullivan
Casa Mia Hurleyville hosted my graduation party and it was amazing! They let us arrive early to decorate.The food was delicious, the staff was wonderful and so helpful, and everything that went into the planning was easy. The cost was surprisingly reasonable. I will definitely consider them again

… more

rina valentine
Ordered a shrimp cocktail which was $9 dollars. And this is what I got for $9. Like damn, I might as well go buy a shrimp cocktail at ShopRite, they’d give me more than 5 shrimps.

… more

Tialisa Whipple
I have to say the best thing about this place is the staff. The food was good the atmosphere fine but the waitstaff was exceptional. Very attentive, funny without being obnoxious and friendly. Our waitress made us feel like family. I love that! This restaurant is literally a stones throw from my house so it’s a go to whenever I don’t want to cook. There are other restaurants just as close, but I choose Casa Mia. You can tell they are all working hard at building a successful business and the staff reflects it. My favorite dish here is the broilded pork chops with a side of fresh green beans.

… more

Melissa Coca
We had a nice meal. Our original server was still there from the Frankie and Johnny days we love her… we were so sad though not to see our Bartender Donald! They need to bring him back.

… more

Charles Boltas
We are visiting family in upstate New York from Texas. Our family here recommended this place, so we ordered for pickup. We ordered a caprese salad, a pasta trio, chicken Parmigiana, Sicilian pizza, and an eggplant rotini.

… more

Mike Panekowski
We decided on Italian foods for dinner and although there are several choices in the Monticello area we all chose Momma Mia resturant,

… more

Rita VanFluke
Casa Mia ( formerly Frankie and Johnny’s) is a wonderful little Italian restaurant in Hurleyville.

… more

Kevin Garrett
It’s a good local place but the food seems to be going downhill. I recently ordered a pizza and the sausage on it was tasteless and not at all as good as other pizzas in the area.

… more

Lois Munoz
Service sucked! Was served dinner and nobody ever returned to check on us once. We sat there for about 30 minutes after we finished eating and nobody even looked in our direction. It was my daughter’s birthday and we couldn’t even order dessert or get grated cheese for her food. Thank goodness for the nice bus girl. We were able to get boxes to wrap our food and had to get up to pay without even having a check. Working in the restaurant industry it is infuriating to me to receive this type of service. Food was mediocre. Don’t understand why this place has good reviews. Do not even consider it!

… more

Karen Northrup
Service was great! The food was delicious and nice portions.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch