Casa Vieja Menu – Brentwood, NY

Type : Colombian restaurant

Location : Brentwood, NY

Unassuming eatery with a menu of Latin American & Mexican fare, from Colombian steak to burritos. Based on 895 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout

Casa Vieja 11717

Address:
1768 Brentwood Rd, Brentwood, NY 11717

Phone: (631) 434-8255

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–11 PM
Saturday 11 AM–11 PM
Sunday 11 AM–9 PM
Monday 11 AM–10 PM

Menu

Para Antes (appetizers)
El Maduro Con Queso Y Carne
yellow plantain stuffed with cheese and meat
Las Papas Rellenas
potato balls stuffed with meat
La Arepa Con Queso
white corn griddle cake stuffed with cheese
El Aguacate Relleno
avocado stuffed with shrimp in a special sauce
El Pincho
grilled beef served on a skewer
Las Empanadas (Orden De Tres)
meat filled turnovers (order of three)
La Arepa De Chocolo
yellow corn bread griddle cake topped with cheese
Las Quesadillas Con Chorizo O Champinones
flour tortilla stuffed with cheese and choice of colombian sausage or mushrooms
Los Nachos
Con Pollo O Carne
corn tortilla topped with cheese and choice of beef or chicken
Las Papas Con Queso
potatoes topped with cheese, bacon and jalapeno peppers
El Mofongo
mashed green plantain with garlic and fried pork rinds
El Guacamole
a blend of avocado, freshly chopped vegetables and spices
Buffalo Wings
El Chicharon Con Arepa
crisp fried pork rinds served with a griddle cake
El Chorizo Con Champinones
colombian sausage served with a griddle cake or sauteed with mushrooms
El Chorizo Con Arepa
Sopas Del Dia (soup Of The Day)
Sopas Grande
large soup of the day
Sopas Pequeno
small soup of the day
Los Platos Tipicos (typical Dishes)
La Bandeja Paisa O Montanera
carne asada o carne molida, huevo frito, chicharron, maduro y arepa (grilled steak, or ground beef, fried egg, fried pork rinds, sweet plantain and griddle cake)
El Lechon Cubano
cuban style roast pork served with moros and cristianos and green plantain
La Bandeja Especial
carne, lomo, pollo asado, huevo frito, chicharron, maduro y arepa (grilled steak, pork loin and chicken breast, fried egg, fried pork rinds, sweet plantain and griddle cake)
La Bandeja “Casa Vieja”
pechuga de pollo asada, arroz, frijoles negros y maduro (marinated grilled chicken breast, rice, black beans and yellow plantain).
El Bistec A Caballo
grilled steak sauteed with onions, tomatoes and peppers topped with fried egg.
La Sobrebarriga A La Plancha O A La Criolla
colombian flank steak grilled or creole style
El Churrasco Argentino
grilled sirloin steak argentine style.
El Churrasco A La Pobre
grilled sirloin steak chilean style topped with fried onions and fried egg.
La Milanesa
breaded beef steak.
Lal Lengua En Salsa
beef tongue cooked in chef’s special sauce
El Lechon Asado
roast pork served with rice, black beans and yellow plantain
El Sandwich Cubano
roast pork, ham and cheese grilled sandwich
La Parrillada Argentina
“typical argentine platter” grilled steak, chicken, pork and sausage platter
El Tamal
corn meal stuffed with chicken, meat and vegetables wrapped in a plantain leaf
Los Tostones Con Todo – Pequeno
platanos verdes con carne pollo, guacamole, ceviche, chicharrones (green plantain with beef, chicken, guacamole. ceviche and fried pork rinds)
Los Tostones Con Todo – Grande
platanos verdes con carne pollo, guacamole, ceviche, chicharrones (green plantain with beef, chicken, guacamole. ceviche and fried pork rinds)
La Picada – Pequeno
platter of assorted meats and fried tropical vegetables.
La Picada – Grande
platter of assorted meats and fried tropical vegetables.
Las Carnes (meat Dishes)
La Chuleta De Pollo Empanizada
breaded chicken cutlet
La Carne Asada
grilled top round steak
La Carne Asada Con Arepa
grilled top round steak served with a large griddle cake
La Carne Guisada
grilled top round steak served with a large griddle cake
El Bistec A La Criolla O Encebollado
top round steak creole style or sauteed with onions
Las Chuletas De Cerdo Asadas O Al Ajillo
center cut pork chops grilled or with garlic sauce
Las Chuletas De Cerdo Empanizadas
breaded loin of pork
El Lomo De Cerdo Asado
grilled loin of pork
El Arroz Con Pollo
chicken and rice
El Pollo Al Champinon
chicken sauteed with mushrooms and hearts of artichokes
El Pollo Asado
half roasted chicken
Taco Salad
Casa Vieja Wrap
Fajitas
Chicken Or Beef Fajitas
Chicken And Beef Fajitas
Shrimp Fajitas
Meat, Chicken And Shrimp Fajitas
Los Platos Frios (cold Dishes)
La Ensalada “Casa Vieja”
house mixed salad
El Coctel De Langostions
shrimp cocktail
El Ceviche
shrimp marinated in lime juice
La Ensalada De Pulpo
octopus salad
La Ensalada De Aguacate
avocado salad
El Ajiaco
creamy chicken soup. el especial del domingo (sunday special)
Los Pescados Y Mariscos (fish And Seafood Dishes)
Los Camarones Al Ajillo
shrimp sauteed in garlic sauce
Los Camarones Empanizados
breaded fried shrimp
Camarones Encendidos (Al Chipotle)
shrimp in a special mexican sauce with yellow rice and black beans
La Picada De Mariscos – Pequeno
platter of assorted fried seafood and tropical vegetables
La Picada De Mariscos – Grande
platter of assorted fried seafood and tropical vegetables
El Pargo Rojo Frito O A La Criolla
whole red snapper fried or creole style
La Cazuela A La Casa Vieja
seafood casserole
Con Langosta
with lobster
El Filete De Pescado Empanizado
El Arroz Con Camarones
shrimp and rice
La Paella Marinera (Para Uno-For One)
seafood and rice
Para Machotes (mexican Specialties)
One Meat Taco, One Cheese Enchilada
Two Cheese Enchildas
One Cheese Burrito, One Meat Taco
Two Beef Tamales
One Bean Burrito, One Cheese Enchilada
One Guacamole Tostada, One Cheese Burrito
Two Chicken Enchiladas
Two Soft Tacos
Two Seafood Enchiladas
Any Three Items
Las Porciones (side Orders)
Arroz
rice
Frijoles Rojos
red beans
Las Papas Chorriadas
potatoes in cheese sauce
El Aguacate
avocado
Los Frijoles Negros
black beans
El Arroz Con Gandules
rice with pigeon peas
Las Papas Fritas
french fries
La Yuca Frita
fried cassava
Los Maduros O Tostones
sweet or green fried plantain

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Sandy
I went for dinner with my family, and that was the worst experience ever. I’ve seen In different reviews about the arepas. They want to charge you for them when in the menu it says that they are included in the meal. Food is horrible, steak is so hard and dry it tastes like cardboard. And on top of that when they bought my food out it was cold. On service, our server was kind of rude, he was rushing us on everything. And when he bought my check, the tip was included on my grand total.They were charging 18% of tip without asking you first or anything. I guess he was expecting more money in top of that because when he took my payment he just looked at it and gave me a look. I would not recommend this place, the service or food to anybody. Save yourself, your time and money and don’t go into this place.

… more

Aank Sandoval
I visited this restaurant with my aunt, she’s likes the beef empanadas they make, I tried the salmon and it was delicious and well cooked, everything look like an old Colombian house which is the theme of the place. I think that their customer service should improve a lot.

… more

J F
Everyone is rarely home at the same time so we decided to have a family dinner at Casa Vieja. I believe Dennis was our server and he did a good job handling our large group. I had the La Milanesa which is a breaded beef steak that comes with French fries. I washed that down with a couple of glasses of Sangria. It was an enjoyable meal and I would come again to try something else.

… more

june nachtigall
Love the enchiladas and the rice and black beans oh and the sangria. The wait staff is very attentive . I personally would like a little more lighting for my old eyes but the decor is fine.

… more

agustin alvarez
Is a nice restaurant clean an plenty of room waitters very attentive and professional food have good taste and fare portions drinks are very expensive they have their own parking lot

… more

B JS
This place is a roll of the dice, sometimes you get a great meal with wonderful service and other times you regret spending a penny there. Unfortunately for me there is one dish that keeps me coming back and that is the Picada. It is the best around. The service is never really that friendly and for some reason the food takes unsually long to get. When you call a pick up order ahead of time, if they tell you it’s going to take 45 mins you better bring a book because you are going to be there a while, its never 45 mins!

… more

M B
This place is awesome!! This is the second time I came here with my son. Great service great food. The amount of food they give you is unbelievable, a feast!!!

… more

N S
It was ok. We were in the area and decided to check it out. I think we made the mistake to sit at the bar where the deliveries were being picked up so it was a but busy. Maybe if we had gotten a table to waitress would’ve been more attentive and actually asked us how we wanted our steak cooked since it was a bit overcooked. The appetizer was very good but I wasn’t impressed with my sangria.

… more

Anderson Nyack
Food took some time to prepare, they had a lot of take out orders. Small bar, its more of a family place to eat, on Sundays anyway. Will visit in the future.

… more

William
The Milanese was cooked okay. Not too flavorful but okay. The fries were a bit stale and cold. That sometimes happens. Chef should always bite into one to see the quality before serving. My opinion. Rice and beans were very good. I would go back to see if it gets better. Nice looking place. Staff worked well together and we’re very friendly. No wait to get in.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch