Your Dyer, IN Casey’s at 1502 Sheffield Ave has the best pizza delivery and pickup featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and only the freshest pizza toppings. We’ve also got appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a variety of household essentials and groceries. When you’re stopping by, you can even fill up your gas tank with quality fuels – Whatever you need, Casey’s is here to help.
Convenience-store chain offering fuel, drinks & food, including pizza, sandwiches & baked goods. Based on 68 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery ✔️ No dine-in
Address:
1502 Sheffield Ave, Dyer, IN 46311
Phone: (219) 250-6936
Hours
| Sunday | 4 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 4 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 4 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 4 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
cuppy199
I have been ordering from here for years with no problems. Always get the taco pizza. I picked it up and noticed when I got home there was no lettuce on it. There was barely any sauce on it was told they changed the sauce. I was just calling to tell them because maybe there was a mixup. Was told I would receive a free pizza the next time. I was like they didn’t have to but ok I would take it. That’s not what upset me or getting the pizza wrong didn’t really upset me either. But then the manager calls me back and said she watched the video of them making it and they put the lettuce on pretty much saying I was lying. I offered to bring it back or send a picture. She said she seen the video. I said I would like to see the video because I know there is no lettuce on it. I know dorn well it was not on the video because there was NO lettuce on it. After being a customer since they opened and never once ever complained I won’t be ordering a pizza or getting anything from that gas station again.I’m attaching a photo of the pizza you tell me if you see lettuce on it.
… more
Fletch Keilman
I have no idea why anyone would complain about this place. This place is great and they treat you with kindness soon as you walk through the door. Sure….it gets busy ..and sometimes tempers can flare. But that happens in ANY service job. These people keep it together AND they make sure everything is run smoothly, all the while making sure you walk away a satisfied customer. And I cannot say that this is a common trait adapted by any of the many local businesses around me, either. While every location I have visited in regards to the franchise is usually running at a very respectable level, the Dyer station is the one where I feel many of the customers, most definitely including myself, feel the most welcome.
… more
Lisa Marie
There’s a girl who works there and shes always yelling across the store or on the phone. She looks sloppy in too tight pink pants and house shoes. She doesn’t say hello, give u a total, or wash up before work. If your a male, she is gushing to speak with you, and couldn’t be more polite. She has an attitude problem.
… more
dingo dingo
The manager Erica are absolutely amazing. Always brining a positive vibe and cheerful. Erica always goes above and beyond everytime i see her. Return customer for that alone.
… more
Joe Grubish
Your managers Erica and Melody are absolutely wonderful. Both bring a positive vibe and are always cheerful. Erica always goes above and beyond everytime i see her. Look forward to seeing them every day.
… more
Lisa Vargas
You have to try the generous topped pizza this place puts out! The price is phenomenal and the deals they run out beats any pizza chain in our area. Go in for a slice. They have an awesome rewards app too for purchases better than any giving you rewards you can actually redeem for what you want and quickly. Good group of people who make easy acquaintances with. Clean for covid too.
… more
Jacques Clayton
After waiting more than 2 hours for a pizza delivery, when I opened the box it looked like the pizza was just thrown all around the car. Also, the “pizza” was slightly undercooked. Never again will I order from here.
… more
frost
Amazing staff, great food, and lovely atmosphere. they make you feel like family, better than Griffith’s caseys.
… more
Mary Vaughn
Was super disappointed today. I ordered lunch for my husband and I. When I got there the oder hadn’t even been started! I couldn’t wait 15 mine or more for them to make it so just grabbed a slice of pizza.
… more
Mr86753o9
The past few times they’ve never had hot pepperoni pizza The service is a little slowThey also need a slushy machine
… more
… View more