Your Geneva, IN Casey’s at 725 N Main St has the best pizza featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and only the freshest pizza toppings. We’ve also got appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a variety of household essentials and groceries. When you’re stopping by, you can even fill up your gas tank with quality fuels – Whatever you need, Casey’s is here to help.
Convenience-store chain offering fuel, drinks & food, including pizza, sandwiches & baked goods. Based on 53 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No dine-in ✔️ No delivery
Address:
725 N Main St, Geneva, IN 46740
Phone: (260) 204-1716
Hours
| Sunday | 5 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
5 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 5 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 5 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 5 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 5 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 5 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Beth Lawrence
So I went there to get dinner for the family, and the guy behind the checkout shook his head as we walked in and so I asked my spouse if we just want to go to the marathon. We decided to order a pizza and the other guy working behind the food counter said they are out of pizza dough, but they had slices of pizza in the warmer so I think he was just too lazy to make a pizza. So we went to the other gas station and had a nice dinner and friendly service. Done with Casey’s!!
… more
Kermit Buckingham
Went in for a job interview. The manager completely forgot about the interview and made me wait a half hour for her to get back to the store. She was completely unprepared for the interview and basically just hired me on the spot. Told me I’d be working full time at 12 dollars an hour.
… more
Harry Shroyer
I use to go here everyday after work, and buy breakfast and lottery. Well, I don’t think ill be back for a while… I purchased my lottery here, but the cashier won’t let me cash anything in, $100 or more. The tickets that you purchase say otherwise. I don’t want to buy stuff here, and then have to drive somewhere else, to cash in the winnings. I only had $110 to cash in, but they told me to go to the other gas station. Disappointed in Caseys, in Geneva Indiana. The other Caseys locations don’t operate like this. This cashier also gets an attitude, everytime i want to buy lottery, because he doesn’t like messing with the machine. He works mornings… highly lacks professionalism!
… more
Michael Mann
Always have good pizza but I just ordered and the lady who took my order was not pleasant to speak too. She actually sighed when I told her I have a coupon to use. Maybe next time I’ll go elsewhere
… more
mike smith
This place was amazing! I entered the store with a thirst, fatigue, and money. After wandering the store aimlessly for a minute I found a long line of coolers. Those coolers contained every sugary caffeinated beverage my heart could desire. They even stocked MOUNTAIN DEW!! well the nice lady at the counter let me exchange my money for her soda pop.
… more
Darin Line
When I first heard that Casey’s General Store was opening a store in Geneva,I was excited. I’ve been to Casey’s General Store in other cities and really liked them. As of tonight,I’m officially done with Casey’s General Store. I won’t be spending another penny at your store , not on gas , not on snacks , not on pizza , notta. For the second time , I ordered a pizza and arrived only to be told they hadn’t even started the pizza.UNBELIEVABLE ! This time the excuse was they were out of a key ingredient for the pizza. 1) Why wasn’t I told when I ordered the pizza. 2) They had my phone number,why didn’t someone call me BEFORE I arrived for the pizza. I’ve heard Casey’s has very good pizza , too bad they can’t actually make one !!!! I’ll never set foot inside your store again !!!!!
… more
Jeff Keller
A nice, almost brand new gas station and store. They make fresh donuts, subs, wraps and pizza. Their lunch counter can be a little slow, it’s not big city fast. They don’t sell beer either, but that is kind of normal in Indiana. Lots of Amish stop in and people in golf carts.
… more
True Freedom
Great breakfast pizza, employees have always been prompt as far as service, very friendly, tidy. Good place to stop. Oh, and free Air. Love free air, 1.50 seems crazy
… more
Sean Kroeber
This caseys nvr has food ready to eat there system is always down so you cant even buy stuff gas pumps never have recipt paper sad its one of the o ly places in town to grab something quick and there shelves of ready food are always empty
… more
Chef Cary Mcclure
3 associated and me no other customers. I tell the girl behind the kitchen counter that your out of coke. (She may be training), she tells the other woman, who says go tell the girl behind counter (cashier). So literally 3 people who could’ve dropped what they were doing to help the customer. Stood there and waited, no one moved. Finally I just poured Pepsi instead. Then the cashier comes over now that I’m done. I said I just used pepsi, but now she “HAS” to change it. So I get to stand at the counter till she is done..this pour treatment for customers is why I stopped using the only other place in town..guess what there bnb is a BP down the road guess where I will be taking my business from now on..not a first for this store!
… more
… View more