Casey's Menu - Hamilton, IL

Your Hamilton, IL Casey’s at 1825 Keokuk St has the best pizza delivery and pickup featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and only the freshest pizza toppings. We’ve also got appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a variety of household essentials and groceries. When you’re stopping by, you can even fill up your gas tank with quality fuels – Whatever you need, Casey’s is here to help.

Convenience-store chain offering fuel, drinks & food, including pizza, sandwiches & baked goods. Based on 54 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $

✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery ✔️ No dine-in

Casey's 62341

Address:
1825 Keokuk St, Hamilton, IL 62341

Phone: (217) 847-3654

Website:

Hours

Sunday	5 AM–11 PM
Monday (Labor Day)	5 AM–11 PM Hours might differ
Tuesday	5 AM–11 PM
Wednesday	5 AM–11 PM
Thursday	5 AM–11 PM
Friday	5 AM–11 PM
Saturday	5 AM–11 PM

Single Topping Pizza
Create Your Own Pizza Our Create Your Own Pizza lets you make your own pizza just the way you like it! Start with marinara, add your favorite toppings and top with mozzarella cheese. Order the best pizza for delivery or pickup!
Pepperoni Pizza Our Pepperoni Pizza starts with classic marinara sauce and is topped with pepperoni and real whole milk mozzarella cheese. Order pizza for delivery or pickup!
Cheese Pizza Our Cheese Pizza starts with classic marinara sauce and is topped with real whole milk mozzarella cheese. Order pizza for delivery or pickup!
Sausage Pizza Our Sausage Pizza starts with classic marinara sauce and is topped with our signature mild or hot sausage and real whole milk mozzarella cheese. Order pizza for delivery or pickup!
Beef Pizza Casey’s Beef Pizza starts with our classic marinara and is topped with plenty of delicious beef. Order your Beef Pizza for delivery or pickup!
Canadian Bacon Pizza Casey’s Canadian Bacon Pizza starts with our classic marinara and is topped with plenty of delicious Canadian bacon. Order your Canadian Bacon Pizza for delivery or pickup!
Specialty Pizza
Taco Pizza Our Taco Pizza starts with refried beans and salsa, beef or chicken, mozzarella cheese, and is finished with lettuce, tomatoes, taco chips and cheddar cheese. Order pizza for delivery or pickup!
BBQ Chicken Pizza Our BBQ Chicken pizza starts with our BBQ sauce and is topped with grilled chicken, smoked bacon, onion and our real whole milk mozzarella cheese. Chef’s Tip – Add banana peppers for the ultimate BBQ experience!
Ultimate Hawaiian Pizza Our Ultimate Hawaiian Pizza starts with our classic marinara sauce and is topped with loads of ham, Canadian bacon, juicy pineapple and real whole milk mozzarella cheese.
Supreme Pizza Our Supreme Pizza starts with classic marinara and is piled with pepperoni, mild sausage, beef, green peppers, onions, mushrooms and black olives. Order pizza for delivery or pickup!
Meat Galore Pizza Our Meat Galore Pizza is topped with pepperoni, beef, ham and your choice of mild or hot sausage. It’s the pizza of every meat lover’s dream! Order pizza for delivery or pickup!
Chicken, Bacon & Ranch Pizza Our Chicken, Bacon & Ranch Pizza starts with ranch dressing and is topped with grilled chicken, smoked bacon crumbles, and mozzarella cheese. Order pizza for delivery or pickup!
Veggie Pizza Our Veggie Pizza starts with classic marinara and is topped with green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, and real whole milk mozzarella cheese. Order pizza for delivery or pickup!
NEW BBQ Brisket Pizza Our new BBQ Brisket Pizza starts with our made from scratch dough and topped with BBQ sauce, smoked chopped brisket, jalapenos, red onions, real mozzarella and cheddar cheeses, and finished with a ranch drizzle. This pizza is available for a limit…
Breakfast Pizza
Bacon Breakfast Pizza Our Bacon Breakfast Pizza starts with cheese sauce or sausage gravy and topped with scrambled eggs, crispy bacon, and mozzarella and cheddar cheese. Order breakfast pizza for delivery or pickup!
Sausage Breakfast Pizza Our Sausage Breakfast Pizza starts with cheese sauce or sausage gravy and topped with scrambled eggs, breakfast sausage, and mozzarella and cheddar cheese. Order breakfast pizza for delivery or pickup!
Veggie Breakfast Pizza Our Veggie Breakfast Pizza starts with cheese sauce or sausage gravy and topped with scrambled eggs, green peppers, onions, and mozzarella and cheddar cheese. Order breakfast pizza for delivery or pickup!
Coffee & Cappuccino
Casey’s Classic Coffee A well rounded mellow coffee with light body and a crisp nutty finish
Casey’s Medium Roast Coffee A bright and balanced aromatic full bodied coffee with a hint of caramel
Casey’s Dark Roast Coffee Intensely bold and rich with sweet overtones and a smoky finish
Hazelnut Coffee A sophisticated aromatic brew that offers the elegant flavor of freshly roasted hazelnuts and a smooth aftertaste to match
Casey’s Classic Decaf Coffee Almost entirely caffeine-free, this mild roast is smooth in taste, rich in flavor and well balanced
French Vanilla Cappuccino
Fat Free French Vanilla Cappuccino
Hot Chocolate
Mocha Max Cappuccino
White Chocolate Caramel Cappuccino
Mocha Iced Coffee
Vanilla Iced Coffee
Casey’s Vanilla Iced Coffee 13.7oz
Casey’s Mocha Iced Coffee 13.7oz
Casey’s Caramel Iced Coffee 13.7oz
Casey’s Vanilla Coffee Energy 15oz
Casey’s Mocha Coffee Energy 15oz
Casey’s Coffee Energy 15oz
Starbucks Doubleshot Energy Mocha 15oz
Starbucks Doubleshot Energy Vanilla 15oz
Bakery Donuts
White Cake Donut
Chocolate Cake Donut
Glazed Donut
Long John
Jelly Filled Donut
Apple Fritter
Blueberry Fritter
Cherry Fritter
French Toast Fritter
French Toast Twist
Fried Cinnamon Bun
Raspberry Flip Pastry
Maple Pecan Danish
Fudge Brownie
Casey’s Chocolate Donut Holes
Casey’s Glazed Donut Holes
Casey’s Powdered Donut Holes
Casey’s Frosted Mini Donuts Bag
Casey’s Powdered Mini Donuts Bag
Casey’s Frosted Mini Donuts 6ct
Casey’s Powdered Mini Donuts 6ct
Casey’s Cinnamon Mini Donuts 6ct
Fountain Soda & Beverages
Iced Tea
Sweet Tea
Diet Coke
Coca-Cola
Coca-Cola Zero Sugar
Sprite
Powerade Mountain Blast
Vitamin Water XXX
Diet Dr Pepper
Dr Pepper
Sunkist
Canada Dry Ginger Ale
Mtn Dew
Diet Mtn Dew
Mtn Dew Code Red
Mug Root Beer
Pepsi
Wild Cherry Pepsi
Tropicana Lemonade
Breakfast
Sausage, Egg And Cheese Biscuit A hearty sausage patty with scrambled eggs and topped with gooey cheddar cheese, all on a warm, delicious biscuit.
Bacon, Egg And Cheese Croissant A classic for a reason: Crispy bacon and scrambled eggs topped with gooey cheddar cheese, all on a warm, delicious croissant
Sausage, Egg And Cheese Croissant A hearty sausage patty with scrambled eggs and topped with gooey cheddar cheese, all on a warm, delicious croissant.
Loaded Breakfast Burrito Our new, hearty, flavorful burrito loaded with fluffy scrambled eggs, shredded potatoes, savory bacon and sausage crumbles, then topped with gooey, melty cheese and rolled up into a soft tortilla.
Loaded Breakfast Bowl Everything you love about our Loaded Burrito – fluffy scrambled eggs, savory bacon and sausage crumbles, plus gooey, melty cheese – but in a bowl!
Biscuits And Gravy Try out Casey’s classic biscuits and gravy to start your day. Delicious sausage gravy paired with warm, flaky, homemade-style biscuits makes for the best biscuits and gravy. Order breakfast at a Casey’s near you!
Bacon, Egg & Cheese Biscuit Crispy bacon with scrambled eggs and topped with gooey cheddar cheese, all on a warm, delicious biscuit.
Hashbrowns Our hashbrowns are lightly seasoned and crispy on the outside, while fluffy on the inside, making for an irresistible breakfast item. Pair with your breakfast sandwich, or perfect as a grab-and-go breakfast on its own. Order our hashbrowns at a Ca…
Sandwiches & Burgers
1/4 Lb Cheeseburger Our 1/4 lb Cheeseburger starts with a 100% beef patty and is topped with American cheese on a warm bun. Order your burger for delivery or pickup customized with your favorite toppings!
1/4 Lb Bacon Cheeseburger Our 1/4 lb Bacon Cheeseburger starts with a 100% beef patty and is topped with American cheese and crispy bacon on a warm bun. Order your burger for delivery or pickup customized with your favorite toppings!
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Breaded Pork Our Breaded Pork Sandwich starts with a delicious pork fritter and is served on a warm bun. Order your Breaded Pork Sandwich for delivery or pickup customized with your favorite toppings!
Sides
Cheesy Breadsticks Try Casey’s Cheesy Breadsticks! Each 8-stick order starts with made-from-scratch dough, real whole milk mozzarella cheese, and a delicious garlic sauce then are baked to perfection. Your choice or marinara or cheese dipping sauce.
Potato Cheese Bites Finely chopped potato with cheese breaded in a crispy, golden brown coating.
Chicken Tenders Crispy, white meat chicken tenders ready for dipping in creamy ranch, BBQ or honey mustard.
Popcorn Chicken Casey’s crispy and delicious Popcorn Chicken is the perfect companion to your favorite Casey’s Pizza, or a great snack when you’re on the go. Order your Popcorn Chicken for delivery or carryout!
Desserts
Peanut Butter Crispy Bites Bars made with creamy peanut butter, blended with crisped rice and topped with mouthwatering chocolate icing, cut into bite-sized pieces.
Brownie Bites Bite-sized chocolate brownies coated in a rich chocolate icing. This treat pairs perfectly with a slice of pizza.
Casey’s Chow Crunchy corn cereal covered in chocolate, peanut butter and powdered sugar makes for a delicious snack anytime.
Shareable Party Brookie 4pk Golden chocolate chip cookie on the bottom with traditional fudge brownie on top. Finished with rainbow sprinkles and made with real M&M’S®. Four Brookies per pack makes this perfect for sharing! 220 calories per serving, 2 servings per piece, 4 p…
Chips
Lay’s Classic 9oz
Ruffles Cheddar & Sour Cream 8.5oz
Pringles Original 5.57oz
Doritos Nacho Cheese 9.75oz
Cheetos Crunchy 8.5oz
Cheetos Flamin’ Hot 8.5oz
Doritos Cool Ranch 3.125oz
Casey’s Original Chips 6oz
Casey’s BBQ Chips 6oz
Casey’s Cheddar & Sour Cream Chips 2.5oz
Casey’s Dill Pickle Chips 2.5oz
Casey’s Jalapeno Kettle Chips 2.25oz
Ice Cream
Happyness By The Pint Peanut Butter Me Up Ice Cream, 16oz New at Casey’s! Happyness by the Pint Peanut Butter Me Up features chocolate ice cream with a caramel swirl, peanut butter bits and chocolate chip cookie dough pieces. Available for delivery or pick up!
Happyness By The Pint Dough For It Ice Cream, 16oz New at Casey’s! Happyness by the Pint Dough for It! features vanilla ice cream with a chocolate swirl, brownie and chocolate chip cookie dough pieces. Available for delivery or pick up!
Happyness By The Pint Pretty Please With M&M’s On Top Ice Cream, 16oz New at Casey’s! Happyness by the Pint Pretty Please with M&M’s on Top features vanilla ice cream with chocolate chip cookie dough pieces and M&M’s. Available for delivery or pick up!
Happyness By The Pint Smile And Say Cheesecake! Ice Cream, 16oz New at Casey’s! Happyness by the Pint Smile and Say, “Cheesecake!” features cheesecake flavored ice cream with a strawberry swirl, cheesecake pieces and graham cracker pieces. Available for delivery or pick up!
Ben & Jerry’s Half Baked 16oz Ben & Jerry’s is proud to partner with fellow B Corps Greyston & Rhino Bakeries to bring you half baked. The incredible stories behind both the fudge brownies & cookie dough make this a flavor that not only tastes good, but does good.
Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough 16oz We knew we were onto something big when we made the world’s first batch of Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough ice cream in 1984. Today the flavor still reigns among our all-time most popular concoctions.
Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Fudge Brownie 16oz The fabulously fudgy brownies in the flavor come from New York’s Greyston Bakery, where producing great baked goods is part of their greater-good mission to provide jobs & training to low-income city residents.
Ben & Jerry’s Americone Dream 16oz Founded in fudge-covered waffle cones, this caramel-swirled concoction is the only flavor that gets a s’cream of approval from The Late Show host, Stephen Colbert. What’s sweeter is this flavor supports charitable causes through The Stephen Colber…
Ben & Jerry’s The Tonight Dough 16oz Inspired by the show & host we love staying up late for, here’s a flavor you’ll love spooning into—dedicated to SeriousFun Children’s Network of global camps for children with serious illnesses.
Twix Ice Cream Bar
Snickers Ice Cream Bar
M&M’s Vanilla Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich
Haagen Dazs Vanilla Milk Chocolate Ice Cream Bar
Nestle Tollhouse Vanilla Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich
Energy Drinks
Monster Energy Drink 16oz
Monster Zero Ultra 16oz
Monster Pipeline Punch 16oz
Monster Mango Loco 16oz
Monster Energy Drink 24oz
Monster Ultra Watermelon 16oz
Red Bull Energy Drink 8.4oz
Red Bull Energy Drink 16oz
Red Bull Watermelon 12oz
A Shoc Watermelon 16oz
A Shoc Fruit Punch 16oz
Bang Cotton Candy 16oz
Bang Blue Razz 16oz
Reign Razzle Berry 16oz
Reign Orange Dreamsicle 16oz
Candy
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup King Size 2.8oz
Twix Share Size 3.02oz
Kit Kat King Size 3oz
Snickers Share Size 3.29oz
M&M’s Peanut Pouch 5.5oz
M&M’s Peanut Butter Pouch 5oz
Skittles Wild Berry Share Size 4oz
Milky Way Share Size 3.63oz
Skittles Original Share Size 4oz
Snickers Almond Share Size 3.29oz
Sports Drinks
Gatorade Fierce Grape 28oz
Gatorade Glacier Freeze 28oz
Gatorade Cool Blue 28oz
Gatorade Fruit Punch 28oz
BODYARMOR Strawberry Banana 28oz
BODYARMOR Orange Mango 28oz
BODYARMOR Fruit Punch 28oz
BODYARMOR Blackout Berry 28oz
Wings
Boneless Wings 16pc Try Casey’s new, crispy boneless wings! Each 16 count order includes 2 complimentary choices from our dipping sauces. With 7 to choose from, you can’t go wrong! Each additional sauce costs $0.69.
Traditional Bone-In Wings 16pc Try Casey’s new, crispy bone-in wings! Each 16 count order includes 2 complimentary choices from our dipping sauces. With 7 to choose from, you can’t go wrong! Each additional sauce costs $0.69.
Boneless Wings 8pc Try Casey’s new, crispy boneless wings! Each 8 count order includes 1 complimentary choice from our dipping sauces. With 7 to choose from, you can’t go wrong! Each additional sauce costs $0.69.
Traditional Bone-In Wings 8pc Try Casey’s new, crispy bone-in wings! Each 8 count order includes 1 complimentary choice from our dipping sauces. With 7 to choose from, you can’t go wrong! Each additional sauce costs $0.69.
Fresh Sandwiches
Ham & Swiss 6 Inch Sub Treat yourself to the mouth-watering taste of Casey’s 6″ Ham and Swiss Sub Sandwich. Made with succulent slices of ham and smooth Swiss cheese, served on a freshly baked bun. Perfectly balanced and hearty for the ultimate lunchtime or on the go me…
Turkey & Cheddar 6 Inch Sub Indulge in our delicious 6 ” Turkey & Cheddar sub, made with freshly baked bread and filled with delicious slices of savory turkey and the balanced mild flavor of yellow cheddar. Perfect for a quick lunch or as a satisfying snack, this sandwich is…
Italian Provolone 6 Inch Sub Savor the taste of Italy with Casey’s 6″ Italian & Provolone Sub. Made with a delicious combination of salami, pepperoni, ham, lettuce, tomato, and melted provolone cheese all on a freshly baked sub roll. This sub is perfect for lunch or dinner, i…
Harvest Grain Ham Sandwich Are you looking for a delicious and satisfying sandwich to enjoy for lunch? Look no further than Casey’s Harvest Grain Ham Sandwich! This sandwich is packed with amazing flavor and is sure to leave you feeling satisfied. The savory ham is paired w…
Harvest Grain Turkey Sandwich Looking for a delicious and satisfying sandwich to enjoy for lunch? Look no further than Casey’s Harvest Grain Turkey Sandwich! This sandwich is packed with amazing flavor and is sure to leave you feeling full and satisfied. The succulent turkey i…
Chicken Salad Croissant Satisfy your cravings with the creamy and flaky goodness of Casey’s Chicken Salad Croissant. Indulge in the delicate layers of croissant pastry filled with a generous amount of homemade chicken salad, fresh greens, and mixed vegetables. The perfec…
Hot Sandwiches
Breaded Pork Tenderloin Our Breaded Pork Sandwich starts with a delicious pork fritter and is served on a warm bun. Order your Breaded Pork Sandwich for delivery or pickup customized with your favorite toppings!
Crispy Chicken Sandwich Our Crispy Chicken Sandwich starts with a perfectly seasoned, breaded chicken breast on a warm bun. Order your Crispy Chicken Sandwich for delivery or pickup customized with your favorite toppings!
Fresh Wraps
Grilled Chicken Wrap Fuel your day with Casey’s Grilled Chicken Wrap, featuring a tender and juicy grilled chicken breast paired with a medley of crisp veggies and tangy sauce all nestled in a soft and warm tortilla. The perfect grab-and-go meal that is both satisfyin…
Turkey Ranch Club Wrap Experience the delicious combination of flavors and textures in Casey’s Turkey Ranch Club Wrap. Made with succulent slices of turkey, crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, and creamy ranch dressing all wrapped in a soft and warm tortilla. A perfect blend…
Italian Wrap Enjoy a fresh deli wrap filled with ham, hard salami, pepperoni, lettuce, black olives, provolone cheese and mayonnaise.
BBQ Ranch Chicken Bacon Wrap Indulge in the bold and mouth-watering flavors of Casey’s BBQ Ranch Chicken Bacon Wrap. This wrap combines succulent grilled chicken, crispy bacon, tangy BBQ sauce and creamy ranch dressing all wrapped in a warm tortilla. Perfectly balanced and lo…
Burgers
1/4 Lb Bacon Cheeseburger Our 1/4 lb Bacon Cheeseburger starts with a 100% beef patty and is topped with Cheddar cheese and crispy bacon on a warm bun. Order your burger for delivery or pickup customized with your favorite toppings!
1/4 Lb Cheeseburger Our 1/4 lb Cheeseburger starts with a 100% beef patty and is topped with Cheddar cheese on a warm bun. Order your burger for delivery or pickup customized with your favorite toppings!
Dipping Sauces
BOOMerang Don’t miss out on this delicious sauce! A little bit spicy, garlic mayo-based chili sauce, delivers a ‘boom’ of sweet and tangy flavor. Perfect for dipping your Casey’s garlic crust in, or even the traditional and boneless wings.
Marinara Sauce Our classic marinara sauce is a flavorful blend of tomatoes, onion, garlic, and spices. Try with an order of cheesy breadsticks or your favorite Casey’s pizza. Two marinara dipping cups are provided with each cheesy breadsticks order.
Ranch Add this classic creamy buttermilk ranch dipping sauce to your order today. Casey’s ranch is seasoned with a special blend of herbs and spices to make this a fan favorite. Try with the cheesy breadsticks, traditional and boneless wings, or your fa…
Garlic Parmesan Savory blend of real parmesan cheese and roasted garlic finished with crushed black pepper.
BBQ Order a side of BBQ sauce to complete any meal. Smoky and rich, with a blend of spices, creating a sweet kick that’s a major hit. Can’t go wrong with a classic dipping sauce! Try with the traditional and boneless wings, your favorite pizza, or add…
Buffalo Another classic sauce, made with a blend of cayenne pepper and other spices. Try with the traditional and boneless wings, your favorite pizza, or add to your Crispy Casey’s Chicken Sandwich. Add to your order now for same-day delivery, curbside pi…
Honey Mustard Tasty blend of Dijon mustard and a touch of honey, makes this sauce a delicious addition to any meal. Perfect pairing for the boneless and traditional wings, your favorite Casey’s pizza, or any of our on-the-go sandwiches. Add to your order now fo…
Bleu Cheese Get ready for this amazing sauce, made from artisan bleu cheese crumbles, for a tangy creamy sauce. Add it to your ready-made salad, or pair with the Buffalo sauce for an ultimate dip combo. Dip your Casey’s boneless and traditional wings, or your…

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Mary Russell

Pizza is nice and hot, they actually use a fair amount of toppings.

… more

Dawn Harr (Minniemee)

They were very helpful in a bad situation with Keokuk being with out power they were awsome and worked really hard

… more

Renee Marlin

Quick hot pizza or sandwich grabs for lunch breaks makes on the run easy! They have a sub sandwich bar too. Casey’s is the best! Their donuts are my favorite… Soooo good! And, I love Hamilton Casey’s coffee bar!

… more

Charles King

Sufficient but definitely not overly spectacular

… more

Liz McLean

I have to commend Casey’s here in Hamilton, IL. Hamilton is a small town so there is not many food places. As far as I know Casey’s is the only one in Hamilton. They have great croissant sandwiches, every time I’ve gotten one the filling over flows the croissant. Their pizza is terrific, We always order a large pizza with extra cheese and extra mushrooms. Between my son and myself we have leftovers. It’s better than some pizza joints I’ve been to. Casey’s people are friendly. Their pizzas are like homemade. No complaints. Keep up the great work.

… more

Katonna Johnson

They ignored me and they only make to order after 6 they said

… more

Jonathan Sandidge

Of all the area locations, This one seems to have the best pizza! Have ordered pizza from here numerous times and they always have it ready when I want it and the employee’s are always friendly. They also maintain a clean store which is very important! Needless to say, Will be returning!

… more

Pamela Eward

Ordered pizza for delivery on a Saturday at 5:30 and was told when ordered that it would take about 25 min. It ended up coming after 45 minutes. The driver parked at the end of the driveway and brought the pizza to the porch. It wasn’t in a thermal bag and the temp that night was 21°. Perhaps it was in the bag in her vehicle, but it should have come to the porch warm. The pizza was not done well. The bottom crust was doughy in the center and barely crusty on the outer edges. This was the first time in years that we had their pizza. Very disappointed.

… more

Jack Wilson

Just got a large meat lovers pizza, unfortunately it was more of a meat hunters, what has happened to Casey’s pizza’s? they have really been skimpy on toppings, Casey’s used to be the best pizza.

… more

Richard Schipper

The customer service was great the pizza crew is on point and the rewards are awesome.

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Casey’s Menu – Hamilton, IL

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions