Your Benton, IL Casey’s at 710 E Main St has the best pizza delivery and pickup featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and only the freshest pizza toppings. We’ve also got appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a variety of household essentials and groceries. When you’re stopping by, you can even fill up your gas tank with quality fuels – Whatever you need, Casey’s is here to help.
Convenience-store chain offering fuel, drinks & food, including pizza, sandwiches & baked goods. Based on 94 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery ✔️ No dine-in

Address:
710 E Main St, Benton, IL 62812
Phone: (618) 439-9188
Website:
Hours
| Sunday |
Open 24 hours |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Open 24 hours
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
Open 24 hours |
| Wednesday |
Open 24 hours |
| Thursday |
Open 24 hours |
| Friday |
Open 24 hours |
| Saturday |
Open 24 hours |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
I am me
Who do you have to know to order a sub hear? Done with this place and their employees “whatever” attitude. Been there twice today and have been ignored both times. Second time I was only customer in store. Two people standing behind register, two in kitchen, and one walking around. Didn’t even get a be right with you from anyone. Very common problem with this store as well as one in west City IL. Pretty poor customer service.. Heading to Subway as this time. Take my fuel buisness to Match as well. May even stop and get a real pizza at a Hunt Brothers station.
… more
Joe Woolsey
ordered pizza online said they’d be ready at 3:56 waited over an hour horrible service
… more
Jemi Miller
About a year ago I would have rated this place with one star. I had an unpleasant experience with Caseys pizza. Pretty much I called in a pickup order for a pizza, and they told me it would be ready in 30minutes. I just got out of my college course, and arrived at Caseys about 35-40 minutes after placing my order. I told the girl at the register that I had an order under my name. She laughed, and told me that they didn’t have my sons pizza even cooking yet. Considering I had 20 minutes to get to work I told her to forget it and left. I was not happy. That was my sons dinner, and there was absolutely no reason for her to laugh about it. It almost caused me to never order from them again. I am glad I decided to give them another chance! I love there pizza, and so does my son. They also have much nicer employees then what they did last year. I do recommend, and will proceed to return for that incredible cheesy pizza!!!
… more
Caleb Bundy
I just ordered a taco pizza from caseys on east main in benton.im not sure if they changed the recipe but normally it has crunched up nachos big chunks of tomatoes and lettuce ect. The pizza I got had none of the above and was cold and the taco sauce packets that they always throw in the box werent even in there and they had to go back and get them..i paid over $19 plus a $5 tip for a pizza I cant eat because of how bad it taste . gotta say im sadly disappointed
… more
Penni Dunford
Ordered a medium pizza and got home and was only 6 pieces which I feel was a small size. Called to complain and only excuse I got was that she cut it wrong! Won’t be ordering any more from there! Not worth 12.00 for 6 slices!
… more
Mark Hall
Every time you get gas there they are too cheap to put paper in the machine for a receipt. Came back a week later no change and this time half the pumps have bags on the handles and don’t even work they need upgrade their stuff and actually put some paper in the machines or too lazy or too cheap.
… more
Fluffy Mouse
Clean restrooms, Friendly staff, Cashier informed us they had fresh pizza available. Store was well stocked. I’m impressed with Casey’s store chain they take care of their locations inside and out.
… more
angie behringer
It’s Pretty Sad Most any given time you go to this Casey’s it’s never Stocked Sodas milk What on Earth are u all getting paid to do???? The manger needs to take a different position Because had I been working there Those Coolers Would Be Stocked Get Off your butts and Do what your paid to do Sorry Not Sorry But Way Way To Many People Are Complaining
… more
Joelle B.
Their Taco Pizza is delicious! I have had some slight bad service with them, but they more than made up for it! They really do care if they got your order wrong and if on the off chance that they do, they will fix it as soon as they can. The service has always been friendly and the place has always been clean!
… more
krystyna taft
We order pokemon pizza for my little boys birthday. They were delicious and turned out great as far as looking like a poke ball. The manager made a sugar cookie cake with icing that looked like a poke ball!
… more
… View more