Counter-serve chain dishing out traditional pizzas, plus pasta, subs & calzones. Based on 138 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
430 W Main St, New Lebanon, OH 45345
Phone: (888) 294-5464
Website: https://www.cassanos.com/location/west-main-street/
Hours
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–11 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–11 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–11 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lisa Muncy
Best pizza around, grew up eating this pizza then moved to Florida where they have nothing that compares to it! It’s still amazingly great after all these years and I’ve got my 18 y/o son hooked on it since he was 6, every time we go to visit family this is the first thing he wants when we get there. Get the deluxe, it’s great. The service was great as always, the young man working the counter was friendly and polite. Dining room was clean.
… more
Gary Douglas
As good as it ever was. It’s been years since I had a pizza and sub from here. The crust still has that old fire oven taste. The classic sauce just can’t be matched anywhere public. The new digs are better and have a lot more space and atmosphere, in comparison to the old outlet location. Take out or eat right there and chat for a while – no disappointments either way.
… more
Elizabeth Perry
When you pay so much on an order you expect it to be correct.
… more
Angela Dalton
Clean dining room got new Manger seems to be getting better
… more
L “Market Review”
One of the worse.. pore customer service, was given the wrong order, and it had a food allergy issue on top of that. Laugh at when I brought it back. The so called shift lead said they could remake it but would take 45 mins. Ridiculous it takes 3-5 days to refund payment when they can take it in seconds. Was sent to the manger of the store and they didn’t even pick up the phone. Will never go here again and I will definitely be telling all my friends, family and people I know to stay away.
… more
Mandy Wallace
We ordered from here and it was made within 15 mins. I had a 20 minute drive home and the food was still hot. This was the best pizza and subs we have had in a long time. Everything about our dinner was perfect! Great job and will definitely be back!
… more
Josh Mitchell
I ordered pizza over the phone they said it would be $33 I looked in my account they charged me $38 they get here with the pizza I said that I owed the $33 and I told them I paid for over the phone the driver said that he had to go back to the office to figure it out so I had to pay $72 today just for a large pizza and medium Pizza and breadsticks now I have to wait a couple days and hope I get my $38 back
… more
C. R. Johnson
We were never asked if we were dining in or carrying out, when we placed our order. When our subs were ready, we were told to leave(not asked) because the dining room was closed and time was needed to clean it. Every table was clean except the one we had been sitting at for 20 minutes, waiting on our food. When we got home and sat down to eat, every single one of the four subs ordered was wrong. Even the plain ham and cheese sub was wrong. We were given a plain steak hoagie instead.
… more
amber murphy
We called and ordered delivery and immediately upon hanging up realized all we had was a hundred dollar bill. So we called back to change the order to pick up. Okay, no problem. We went to pick the food up and were told the order had been canceled and we would have to place it again and wait “15ish” minutes. We wait and finally get home with our food only to find it wasn’t correct. By this time they had already closed. So we were told to keep it and take it back the next day to be replaced or we could have 25% off the next order. Really? After all that you’re going to comp us 3 dollars. Nope, wont be back. We had just moved here 2 months ago and this had been our go to dinner out. But as time went by we have gotten more and more burnt bland food.
… more
William Blanton
Ordered pizza and a sub last night 12/24/2020 from New Lebanon ohio location. Food arrived cold. Called to ask for a refund of my 31 dollar order and they give me a 8 dollar credit towards next order. What a joke will never order there again
… more
… View more