Based on 455 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
N9581 US-12, Merrillan, WI 54754
Phone: (715) 333-5901
Website: http://castlehillsupperclub.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 5–8 PM |
| Friday | 4:30–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 4:30–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 5–8 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Zuege Doug
Good food. The chicken soup was good . I had the garlic sirloin, ok. The price was good and the Old Fashioned was tasty.
… more
Amy Grutzik
We had the worst service I’ve experienced in a long time. Steak ordered medium and came out well done and chewy. Samantha our waitress shrugged her shoulders when we politely told her. She never cleared a plate or glass the entire dinner and came over and asked for the signed check before we were finished. Eaten here before and never had such a rude server or an over cooked steak
… more
Wolfe Ridge MFG
Prime was fantastic. The cold rolls in plastic bags on table and the white onion on the salad could definitely use an upgrade. Service was good, pricing was good as well. 4 stars overall.
… more
Mark R. Greenwood
We went for the All-You-Can-Eat Friday night Seafood Buffet. It was okay. Decent variety of baked, fried, and boiled seafood options (fish [haddock & catfish], clams, and shrimp), but not anything special like Wisconsin lakes fish like walleye, perch, bluegill, or anything like that. Usual sides like fries, mashed potatoes, and pasta salads. Salad and dessert bars were good. Service was okay but not very personable or friendly. Efficient (removing used dishes, etc.). Fairly reasonable prices. Felt a bit like a cafeteria, I guess, though. No atmosphere in the big seating hall. It got crowded pretty quickly after opening but there is a huge amount of seating, so we didn’t see anybody having to wait too long to get a table. The cook was always checking the status of the buffet so there was adequate food coming out. Not sure we’ll be back though because the buffet was like a lot of other chain buffet places and didn’t offer anything unique and the service wasn’t especially friendly. Noted that the place is for sale. That may have something to do with those issues. Maybe new owners/management can make some needed changes.
… more
Shauna Valdez
Phenomenal seafood buffet on Friday night. I haven’t had good American buffet food since Old Country Buffet went out of business. Everything was delicious! Reasonably priced at $17 per person.
… more
Anthony Nespoli
Best food in town for sure! The steak was there, and the buffet was full of food.
… more
Chad Gibbons
This is a Wisconsin Supper Club – if you are city folk who don’t know what these are, then keep in mind they are not like big city dining establishments.
… more
Paris Lafuente
Been here several times and I’ve never had such horrible service. The waitress was rude and did not clear any plates or glasses the entire dinner yet still managed to come over and ask for the signed check with an absolute attitude. After taking the signed check, she came to take the dirty glasses and plates and when I made a comment she snickered at me. Do not order medium steak, it will come well done. Prime rib was great. For the rude wait staff, not worth the money.
… more
Isaiah Humphrey
There is none better. This is the prime rib you’ve been dreaming of
… more
H Stanton
We were a party of 7 that have patronized CastleHill in the past and loved it. This time was quite different. Our main waitress Was Hailey and she was quite brash with us! We had one joker in the bunch and she was not impressed with him and it showed in her demeanor! Actually she was quite rude! I ordered three shrimp with my Prime rib and she completely forgot about them. I didn’t get an apology or some sort of comp on our bill. They came out after everyone was done eating, so I actually only ate one shrimp. One of the people with us ordered his Prime med rare and it came out very Medium and several of us that ordered the Prime all stated it was barely warm. So needless to say it was not one of our best experiences, unfortunately!
… more
… View more