Based on 23 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
326 W Jericho Turnpike, Huntington, NY 11743
Phone: (631) 683-4731
Website: http://www.catch25li.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 4–11 PM |
| Saturday | 4–11 PM |
| Sunday | 1–8 PM |
| Monday | 4–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
John Kourbage
So, this is probably one of the worst dining experiences I’ve had in a few months. The price was high for the level of the food offered. The food was good, but the dishes weren’t clicking. Good ingredients, not the best combinations. The ambience was awful. The decor was bare able but the bright lighting killed any chance you had of feeling the ambience. I will be going to Branzino’s next time as that place has great food, service, ambience.
… more
Robert Lepre
We had 7pm reservations and were seated promptly. Started off with exotic cocktails. Our favorite was the sugar and spice.
… more
Heather Rosenthal
We loved it ! Food was amazing and so many options. We loved the turkey chili appetizer and crème brûlée. Everything was delicious. Ashley our server was amazing. We will be back!!
… more
Linda Tracey
We went on advice of a friend and wow what an amazing meal. Jess was our waitress, amazing service, amazing food, often Halibut is overcooked and dry this was perfect. Great cocktails, nice wine list. Crab cake and Calamari for apps, both were outstanding, nice atmosphere, tables are not bunched on top of one another. The owner Johnny came over and introduced himself, he is great host. We went early on a Friday night at 5:30 by the time we left only one table was open and I can see why.
… more
Matthew VonSalzen
Food was generally tasty, but took 1.5hrs to come out. We ordered Octopus, tuna tartar, and shrimp and lobster gnocchi. The octopus was well cooked, the tuna tartar was fresh and tasty, the gnocchi was gummy but the shrimp and lobster with it were good. Unfortunately, our apps came out an hour after we ordered them and our mains came out about 45min after that. Clearly something was going on in the kitchen because every other table around us was getting food. The manager tried to make up for it by offering dessert (all also very good) and drinks but the damage was done.
… more
Kerry Wachter
The food was outstanding! Went with a group of six. For appetizer we had eggplant rollatini, rice balls special stuffed with spinach and artichoke, and egg rolls with chicken. All delicious. For dinner I had the crab cake, it was out of the world, the sauce had a little kick to it. Desserts were spectacular, Oreo cheesecake, churros, baked Alaska and crème brûlée. There were many seafood and pasta dishes on the menu. Staff was friendly and accommodating, I will definitely be back!
… more
Donna Kirchstetter
What a great experience! Appetizers of rock shrimp, meatballs and crab cakes all excellent. The hanger steak was seasoned perfectly, stuffed shrimp and lobster was divine! Vodka chicken parm was generous and delicious. Dessert was just as good, cheesecake was creamy and delicious, Creme Brule melted in my mouth. Friendly staff and our waitress Kate went above and beyond to make our dining experience amazing. Definitely will be back.
… more
Sarah Figalora
I have gone to Catch 25 a handful of times now for family gatherings, and I cannot say enough positive things. My family originally went to Catch 25 due to its proximately to the Sunrise of Huntington, where my aunt lives (Sunrise families – I cannot recommend this enough!). We have kept coming back because of the incredible service and food – there is an elevated area in the restaurant that is PERFECT for our family gatherings of 20-30 people (with ages ranging from 2 to 99). The food has also been great — I’ll give an extra shout out to the appetizers, because those are incredible. The staff have been great and incredibly accommodating to ensure our family dinners are the best they can be. A huge thank you to Catch 25!!!
… more
Jeffrey Siegel
Stopped in for dinner to check out the restaurant. I had fresh Kumamoto oysters and baked clams to start. The oysters were disappointing and the baked clams while prepared great were lacking in seasoning. I had the tuna for my main course. It was excellent and made up for the disappointing appetizers.
… more
Med Doyle
Only have good things to say about Catch 25. From the appetizers of burrata and baked clams to my entrée of Molasses Salmon over risotto. Everything was great! Also, have to mention our waiter Chad. He was very attentive and his service was excellent. Will definitely be going back for more.
… more
… View more