Based on 22 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
100 Marketside Avenue Suite 305, Ponte Vedra Beach, FL 32081
Phone: (904) 373-0504
Website: https://www.facebook.com/catullositalian
Hours
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed
Holiday hours
|
| Tuesday | 5–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 5–9 PM |
| Thursday | 5–9 PM |
| Friday | 5–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jill Wiltfong
We lived in NY for 10 years and I can still remember the restaurants there we loved.
… more
Pamela Hoffman
The burrata appetizer and the scallop entree are excellent! The canolli’s are delicious too. Location is on smaller side so if you arrive around prime dinner time there is often a wait. If you go around 8pm, it’s much easier to get a table.
… more
Kelly Biastre (KellyBee)
The food is fantastic. The brushetta appetizer was a burst of flavor with an almost a smokie tomato taste mixed kalamatta olives and with fresh herbs. I have to say, probably the Best brushetta ever! The shrimp fra diavolo with the homemade pasta was outstanding, the spice was perfect, the sauce was creamy and delicious and it was served with fresh bread. Perfect selection! All at very reasonable prices! Add your wine from their generous wine list. Overall, fantastic food, and excellent service! Personally, I don’t care for the close proximity of the tables and being able to listen to everyone’s conversations. Will that stop me from coming, no, because the delicious food far outweighs the crowded space.
… more
Savannah Zuber
We got there about 10 min before opening to grab seats at the bar when doors opened. The service was incredible and the bartenders gave us amazing recommendations on food and wine. I ended up ordering and extra meal to go for lunch the next day – it’s THAT good! The intimate setting catered to really getting to learn about their roots and where their menu came from. The staff is very attentive and pays attention to customer needs. No reservations are taken – but it’s well worth the wait!
… more
Gail Bril
The food was very good, but from the moment we sat down we were rushed to order. We walked right in as there were just a couple people waiting, so don’t know why our waitress would ask us what we wanted when we hadn’t even opened our menus. Tables are very close together, so not a date nite place. When I pay $130 for a dinner for two, I don’t want to be pushed along to order, eat and get out. That is how we felt and there were 4 of us. We live in Nocatee so will return and hopefully will have a better experience!
… more
Peter Stacy
Unbelievable experience from start to finish. Our server Justin made the perfect recommendations for the entire meal. My daughter and I had appetizers thru dessert. The highlight of the night were the sea scallops. Without question the most amazing scallops I’ve ever had. If you live in the Nocatee area you must visit this restaurant.
… more
Timothy Nolan
Arancini was fantastic
… more
Francis Shoemaker
Went on a Saturday night. I will be succinct. Great staff. Great food. This is not your standard baked pasta, house Caesar, and frozen garlic knots kinda place.
… more
Sloane Ward
We absolutely love Catullas! The food and the service are 12/10. The staff makes every moment truly enjoyable and memorable. Every time we go into Catullas they make it so special even if we aren’t there to celebrate. I cannot recommend them enough. Our server this evening, Justin, made my husbands birthday night!
… more
Kim Harrod
Everything was delicious!! Justin was awesome and took great care of us. My oldest son had the shrimp fra diavolo, which he loved but it is quite tangy. That’s the best I can describe the red sauce. He loved it so it was probably just me. He asked for it spicy, so that’s probably why. I ordered the pear fiocchi and added 4 large sea scallops. It is absolutely amazing and probably one of my favorite dishes they have! It was just over $40 because I added scallops. – that’s ok because they are worth it. The gnocchi dish was so good and my husband also added the scallops. They have the best and most perfectly cooked scallops ever. My 11yr old ordered the Sea Scallop Risotto and he loved this too. This was a splurge for an 11yr old, but that’s ok. They do have a kids menu but he is getting a little old for that. I wish I took pictures of all the food. We got a couple of cannolis and I have to say, I’d go to get a to go order just for their cannoli- so good. This will be one of our regular date night spots. You won’t be disappointed! It’s rare to go out and have such an amazing meal and great service these days. We had a stressful day and this is just what we needed.
… more
… View more