Quaint outpost with indoor-outdoor seats offering seafood & American classics with full bar. Based on 399 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
Address:
6004 Miller Ave, Gary, IN 46403
Phone: (219) 488-4506
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tiara
The atmosphere is awesome, the staff are incredible! It definitely has that small town vibe but we were instantly made to feel like family! And then the food was amazing!! Shrimp and grits, chicken and waffles and the seafood eggs benny were all delish!! Not to mention the beignets!!!!
… more
Raymond Miller
The food was average but the service and cleanliness definitely needs improvement. My wife and I came here for lunch. She has a small, quiet, service dog for seizure alerts. An eight pound Yorkie-Maltese. I’m not sure who she is, but the woman in a white t-shirt told us we would need the approval of the other diners in the room, and if any objected that we wouldn’t be allowed to eat there. I’m guessing she is unfamiliar with the ADA and the severity of the fines for violating it.
… more
Mark Langworthy
Joined friends here for breakfast and really enjoyed it tremendously. Service was awesome, food great, and the atmosphere cozy for sure. I had the Seafood Benedict (made with lots of lobster meat) that was delicious with a side of Bacon Ranch Grits that were a bit dry, but very tasty. All four of us really enjoyed the food and the warm (and somewhat tight) surroundings. I understand this place is quite popular, so plan on a wait in the busy times. Worth it, though!
… more
Stacey Wachowski
Do not be fooled by the shim sham looking outside of the restaurant; you are about to be in for a treat. We just left after having a phenomenal lunch! They have about 20 different varieties of lobster rolls, so the toughest part of lunch is making a decision. I went with the Boston Terrier roll, but my brother and sister got the Italian and some german sounding variety. Each one was delicious. I got my son the chicken tenders from the kids menu, and it was a delightful surprise. These are not your average chicken tenders!
… more
Jackie La Fave
Captain’s House is a local gem!!! Atmosphere is calm and inviting. The service is always on point; keen to your needs but not bothersome. Most important of all, the dishes…oh the food at Captain’s House is beyond words!!!! No matter if you dine for breakfast, lunch, or dinner your tasebuds are sure to be delighted. Can’t say enough about this place!
… more
Elizabeth N
So this is a new concept. They purchase old homes and keep it like grandmas house. There’s no AC but you don’t need it when the staff is so incredibly friend and passionate about their chef and location.
… more
Claire Abel
Amazing food and the chef worked with our GF food issues! If there was more than a 5 star rating I would give it
… more
Katherine Stirling, Realtor
I stumbled upon Captain’s House by chance and it is now my designated place for weekend breakfast, brunch, and lunch. Since my first time going here, I have brought every single one of my close friends and family to try Captain’s and they are all equally amazed with the food, atmosphere, and service. No matter what you order on the menu, you are in for a handcrafted meal like no other. The baked goods and desserts are decadent and fairly priced. I have never been to a restaurant that has quite the unique, quaint charm that Captain’s House has with its cozy atmosphere and eclectic decorations. The wait staff and the main cook, Chef Angela, are the icing on the cake. My personal recommendations for those that like seafood are the Seafood Egg’s Benedict for breakfast and the Lobster Roll for lunch. A breakfast or brunch here is a great start to your day before heading over to the Gary Aquatorium at Marquette Beach on the National Lakeshore Dunes just a few minutes away.
… more
Quid Yen
The kind of food popping up in Miler Beach at the Captain’s House is an astonishing array of culinary brilliance. A patchwork of colors and flavors dipped in perfection.
… more
Doug Fidler
What a surprise! We loved the look of this quirky little restaurant, but we didn’t expect such amazing food! A hidden gem. Make sure you visit if you’re in the area.
… more
… View more