Based on 6 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price $$
Address:
56 N Main St, Florida, NY 10921
Phone: (845) 651-3663
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Lee Whitty
I’ve been to recommended BBQ restaurants in Texas and North Carolina. Texas was good, but I was still hungry when I left. North Carolina had dry meat. Chumley’s was better than both. I had the pulled pork sandwich, and I could barely finish it was so large. This was my first visit here, and I was pleasantly surprised. I will be back. The server was friendly as well.
… more
Chris Biddle
I have been drooling over coming to this BBQ joint but sorry that I did. Today, I had the unfortunate experience to eat at Chumleys BBQ in Florida, NY. After reading most of the reviews I just don’t see where all the good reviews come from. Truthfully, I am basing my review on my one experience but it is this experience that will cause me to never return and never recommend this to any of my friends and family. Too start, the service is ridiculously slow from both the waitress to the kitchen. I waited over thirty minutes for my tailgate steak sandwich that should have taken 10-12 minutes at the most. Once I received my sandwich, it was not as described. The steak was overcooked and an incredibly small portion, the onions not caramelized but raw, the bun was burnt and not garlic toasted as described. The fries (paid extra) showed up 5 minutes after I received the sandwich. All this excitement (please note the sarcasm) for $15.14 plus tip ($11.00 & $3.00 fries and drink). A ridiculous amount of money for what I received in food, service, and quality of dining.
… more
Peter Lyons Hall
You gotta love this place because they’ve got the basics down pat: great ribs, great, homemade sauces, and great sides. They also have some unique sandwiches, and they just introduced roasted chicken – the really moist, tasty kind with succulent juices and crispy skin. . . well, you get the idea. Never a problem here. They chefs are from Culinary Institute of America, so they were trained well and know how to prepare food.
… more
James Grill
Great atmosphere, wonderful service, and the food is exceptional. The root beer bbq sauce is one of a kind and packs a ton of great flavor. The ribs, brisket, and pulled pork left me wanting more. Can’t wait to go back!
… more
Robert DiSalvo
Been like 6 months since I been there
… more
Steven Williamson
The food is really good but the service is a bit slow. Don’t go when they’re about to close because they’ll give you an attitude
… more
… View more