Cicerelli’s Park East Steakhouse Menu – Pueblo, CO

Type : Steak house

Location : Pueblo, CO

Based on 456 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $$$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Cicerelli's Park East Steakhouse 81005

Address:
720 Goodnight Ave, Pueblo, CO 81005

Phone: (719) 565-6655

Website: http://www.parkeaststeakhouse.com/

Social Profile:

Photo Gallery

Reviews

H18M24
One of pueblos nicer older restaurants. Food was flavorful and portions were good size, and presentation was beautiful on all plates. The staff were friendly and helpful and service was prompt and efficient. As for the margaritas….they were super! Cheers! It’s more on the expensive side but for a romantic night out….it’s worth it.

… more

Laura Allen
My parents attempted to have dinner here last night for their 49th wedding anniversary. The hours listed online are 4:30pm to 8pm Tuesday through Saturday. My mom is handicapped and wheelchair-bound. My parents got to the restaurant at 4:30, got my mom out of the car and into her wheelchair (which is a time-consuming and very tedious process), only to find the doors of the restaurant were locked. My mom called their phone number and a staff member was sent to the door, telling them they “only open at 4:30 for large parties”. My dad and wheelchair-bound mom were turned away at the door. This is disgusting to me. We have been visiting this restaurant since the early 80’s, through all its changes of ownership and have never had anything like this happen. Current ownership should be absolutely ashamed. If they don’t open at 4:30 for everyone, that should be clearly stated online. If I could leave a ZERO star review, I would. Horrible service with no regard whatsoever for the disabled.

… more

Heather Manganello
One of pueblos nicer older restaurants. Food was flavorful and portions were good size, and presentation was beautiful on all plates. The staff were friendly and helpful and service was prompt and efficient. As for the margaritas….they were super! Cheers! It’s more on the expensive side but for a romantic night out….it’s worth it.

… more

tom nelson
Only open to private events, no public seating/service? Large family event, food was below subpar, prime rib had to be sent back and still not good, tough, raw, tasteless, aujus mainly wistershire sauce. Had good meals here years ago, not so good currently. Cannot recommend.

… more

Carol Gerler
Have a nice private space for small gathering. Waiter was patient with the children and checked on our needs frequently. Really large portions. Limited menu.

… more

Sarah Alarid
We paid for 45$ steak meal and they used fake mashed potatoes. They smelled really bad and were gross too. You can’t skimp on things like this when charging so much for a meal.

… more

Kathleen Means
The food, drinks, and service are great. I have never had a bad or mediocre meal there. I do miss the live music though.

… more

Charice Carrasco
I was a bit apprehensive to come here because of the mixed reviews. But , wow!! The waiter informed us that there was a large group in front of us so it may take a bit longer for our food to come out. But I’ve waited for much longer at restaurants without large groups in front of me. He was very attentive. The manager also made it around to greet diners. This is always big plus in my book. The food was soooo so good! I had one of their specials. Pan seared sea bass. It was cooked perfectly with crispy skin, and was piping hot. I was seriously impressed with this restaurant and will be visiting as often as I can.

… more

Catherine P
We were very excited to take my father to this restaurant for his 80th birthday (and even though we told the server that it was his birthday, no acknowledgement was made). It was recommended to us by a friend. We made reservations online which was very easy. Once we got to the restaurant, we were seated in the back of the building near the brick wall that was radiating the cold from outside. I ordered a Pinot Noir…waiter came back, they were out. Ordered a malbec, they were out. Settled for a different red, not one I really wanted. The food, other than their halibut special was terrible. 2 of us ordered the tuna and it was drenched in very salty goop. My father ordered a steak. It came scored at least 1/2″ y through. Even with a steak knife the steak was almost impossible to cut and even harder to chew. We had to ask the waiter twice to take it off the bill as it had 2 bites eaten off of it. Why didn’t we get a replacement dish? The waiter came back once to the table to clear the empty plates. The table next to us had a server there several times. I would not recommend.

… more

Aaron Martinez
Came in last weekend for our anniversary. Going in we can see they were short staffed and very busy. Our server jaron was very kind and very respectful. He got us in and out as quick as he could and did a wonderful job me and my wife loved him. The food was excellent and our drinks were perfect. Overall a great night for us and 10/10 will come back!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions