Cincinnati Good Fellows Menu – Cincinnati, OH

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Cincinnati, OH

Easygoing, enduring hangout with pizza & other typical bar fare, plus a full bar & outdoor seats. Based on 549 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Cincinnati Good Fellows 45255

Address:
7466 Beechmont Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45255

Phone: (513) 407-6818

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Sunday 11 AM–12 AM
Monday

(Labor Day)
 Closed
Tuesday 4 PM–12 AM
Wednesday 4 PM–12 AM
Thursday 4 PM–12 AM
Friday 3 PM–2:30 AM
Saturday 11 AM–2:30 AM

Menu

Bites
Blake’s Pepp Balls
Pepperoni wrapped in pizza dough with fresh garlic, butter, Parmesan, GF spices, side of marinara.		 $8.05
Italian Sticks
Fresh pizza dough, cheese and GF spices, side of marinara.		 $8.05
Italian Capicola Sticks
Fresh pizza dough, cheese and GF spices, covered with capicola, side of marinara.		 $11.00
Ruby’s Garlic Bread
Garlic butter, Parmesan, GF spices, side of marinara sauce.		 $7.00
Connor’s Veggie Skins
Potato skins (5) filled with banana pepper, goat cheese, black olive, Cheddar cheese, drizzle of spicy garlic ranch, side of sour cream.		 $11.50
Tre’s Bacon Skins
Potato skins (5) filled with bacon, Cheddar cheese, side of sour cream.		 $10.00
Tim & Shirley’s Antipasto
Capicola, pepperoni, ham, Provolone, Cheddar, carrot, pickle, celery, green olive, tomato, basil, drizzle of olive oil, GF spice, side of Italian dressing.		 $14.00
T.J.’S Meatballs & Toast
Meatballs topped with Parmesan, GF spices, side of garlic toast.		 $9.25
Bobby’s Meatball Chili
House made beef & pork chili, garlic, onion, Parmesan, house blend cheese, Italian croutons, basil.		 $7.00
Diane’s Nachos
Corn tortilla chips, lettuce, chili, Cheddar cheese, tomato, onion, jalapeno.		 $12.65
Sheila’s Soft Baked Pretzel
Choice of side: nacho cheese, honey mustard, dijon mustard, dijonnaise, pizza sauce.		 $8.15
Jonny’s Pepperoni Chips
Crispy chips seasoned with GF spice and Parmesan, side of ranch.		 $7.00
Diamond’s Deathbed Coleslaw
There’s only one way anyone will get the recipe!		 $5.00
Bacon Cheese Waffle Fries
Baked Waffle Fries, Cheddar Cheese, bacon .		 $9.20
Jumbo Pretzel
Extra Large Pretzel sprinkled with salt, served with two dips of your choice.		 $20.70
Waffle Fries $5.00
Baked Wings
Baked Wings (5)
Cajun baked wings with sauce on the side and choice of celery or baby carrots.		 $9.00
Baked Wings (10)
Cajun baked wings with sauce on the side and choice of celery or baby carrots.		 $17.25
Salads
House Salad
Mixed greens, onion, tomato, cheese, croutons and choice of dressing on the side.		 $6.00
Godfather Salad
Mixed greens, cheese blend, capicola, pepperoni,
ham, tomato, onion, green pepper, banana pepper,
black olive, green olive, jalapenos, swirl of mustard,
GF spices, croutons, Italian dressing.		 $9.25
Grandma Vera’s Salad
Mixed greens, ham, turkey, capicola, tomato, onion,
egg, Cheddar, croutons, balsamic dressing.		 $8.00
Mama Mac Salad
Mixed greens, pulled pork, onion, Feta cheese,
croutons, hot bacon dressing.		 $8.00
Stormy’s Turkey Salad
Mixed greens, smoked turkey, bacon, onion, tomato, egg, Cheddar cheese, croutons, honey mustard dressing.		 $8.00
Wedge Salad
Lettuce wedge topped with ranch, tomato,
green pepper, bacon.		 $8.00
Jaime B’s Salad
Mixed greens, basil, egg, tomato, black olive, chopped black bean burger, Blue cheese crumbles, ranch dressing.		 $9.25
Sandwiches & Subs
Classic Burger
All beef patty, tomato, onion, pickle, lettuce, mustard, mayo. Served with your choice of side.		 $10.35
Rett’s BLT
Applewood bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Served with your choice of side.		 $9.00
Kati Q’s Pulled Pork Burger
All beef patty, pulled pork, Cheddar, Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ. Served with your choice of side.		 $12.65
Cody’s Club
Ham, turkey, capicola, bacon, Cheddar, Pepper Jack, lettuce, tomato and mayo. Served with your choice of side.		 $11.50
Daniello Sub
Capicola, pepperoni, ham, onion, green pepper, banana pepper, house blend cheese, Good Fellows spice and Italian dressing on the side. Served with your choice of side.		 $11.50
Kevin’s Porkopolis
Pulled pork, bacon, pickle, onion, Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ. Served with your choice of side.		 $11.50
Jax’s Meatball Sub
Meatballs, marinara, Provolone and Good Fellows spice. Served with your choice of side.		 $12.65
Erica’s Sausage Sub
Italian sausage, onion, green pepper, marinara, Provolone. Served with your choice of side.		 $11.50
Lindsey’s Black Bean Burger
Baked black bean patty, Pepper Jack, tomato, onion, pickle, lettuce, creamy pesto. Served with your choice of side.		 $10.35
Bentley’s Italian Beef
Sliced Roast Beef and provolone cheese on a sub bun served with au jus, and your option of side.		 $13.80
Tacos
Mr. Anderson
Pulled pork, onion, Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ, BBQ
Grippo’s.		 $9.25
Kelly Belly
Meatballs, house cheese blend, Parmesan, fresh basil.		 $9.25
Kari’s Black Bean
Chopped black bean burger, house cheese blend,
onion, tomato, lettuce, creamy pesto.		 $9.25
Jones
Pulled pork, Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ, Cheddar cheese.		 $9.25
King Caleb
Chicken, house cheese blend, onion, tomato, Hot Garlic Parmesan, creamy pesto, mixed greens.		 $9.25
Calzones
Schriber Zone
Pepperoni, capicola, onion, goat cheese. Choice of large dipping sauce and filled with our house blend cheese. Topped with garlic butter, Parmesan, and GF spice.		 $13.80
Kloe’s Five Cheese
Parmesan, Mozzarella, Provolone, Feta, goat cheese. Choice of large dipping sauce and filled with our house blend cheese. Topped with garlic butter, Parmesan, and GF spice.		 $11.50
Phenix’s Pesto
Banana pepper, onion, mushroom,
tomato, pesto. Choice of large dipping sauce and filled with our house blend cheese. Topped with garlic butter, Parmesan, and GF spice.		 $13.80
Nicki’s Basil Tomato
Garlic, olive oil, fresh basil, tomato. Choice of large dipping sauce and filled with our house blend cheese. Topped with garlic butter, Parmesan, and GF spice.		 $11.50
Kendall’s Spicy Pork
Pulled pork, onion, jalapeno, spicy garlic ranch. Choice of large dipping sauce and filled with our house blend cheese. Topped with garlic butter, Parmesan, and GF spice.		 $13.80
Build Your Own Calzone
Choice of large dipping sauce and filled with our house blend cheese. Topped with garlic butter, Parmesan, and GF spice.		 $9.00
Signature Pizzas 9″
Debbie’s Veggie
Pesto, onion, tomato, green pepper, mushroom,
banana pepper, black olive, green olive.		 $15.00
Bella Maria
Olive oil, garlic, tomato, basil, Feta.		 $13.80
Good Fellow
Pizza sauce, capicola, sausage, onion, green pepper, tomato, mushroom, banana pepper, green & black olive, pineapple, bacon, pepperoni.		 $20.00
Hot Garlic Parmesan
HGP sauce, chicken, onion, banana pepper,
topped with swirl of ranch dressing.		 $13.80
Red Tony
Red sauce on top of sliced Provolone and Parmesan.		 $12.65
Pat’s Meatball
Marinara, sliced meatballs, onion, basil and cheese.		 $15.00
Louie’s Love
Olive oil, garlic, artichoke hearts, banana pepper,
black olive, goat cheese.		 $15.00
Alex’s BBQ Grippo
Sweet Baby Ray’s® BBQ, chicken, bacon, onion, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo’s chips.		 $15.00
Ace
Pesto, Italian sausage, onion, green pepper and cheese.		 $13.80
Malia’s Hawaiian
Pizza sauce, capicola, green pepper, pineapple.		 $13.80
Leta Fajita
Spicy garlic ranch, chicken, tomato, onion, jalapenos, Cheddar, topped with swirl of sour cream.		 $13.80
Lucky Luke
Red sauce, bacon, sausage, onion, pickles and Cheddar, topped with a swirl of mustard.		 $15.00
Jacob’s Inferno
Pizza sauce, onion, green pepper, jalapeno, habanero.		 $13.80
Kristina’s Kindness
Olive oil, garlic, capicola, tomato, mushroom, Blue cheese crumbles.		 $15.00
Simpson’s Way
Sweet Baby Ray’s® BBQ sauce, pulled pork, bacon, pineapple, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo’s chips.		 $15.00
“Brent The Bull” Meat
Bacon, Capicola, sausage, and pepperoni		 $13.80
Signature Pizzas 12″
“Brent The Bull” Meat
Pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, capicola, bacon.		 $20.75
Bella Maria
Olive oil, garlic, tomato, basil, Feta.		 $20.75
Good Fellow
Pizza sauce, capicola, sausage, onion, green pepper, tomato, mushroom, banana pepper, green & black olive, pineapple, bacon, pepperoni.		 $25.30
Hot Garlic Parmesan
HGP sauce, chicken, onion, banana pepper,
topped with swirl of ranch dressing.		 $20.75
Red Tony
Red sauce on top of sliced Provolone and Parmesan.		 $20.00
Pat’s Meatball
Marinara, sliced meatballs, onion, basil and cheese.		 $23.00
Louie’s Love
Olive oil, garlic, artichoke hearts, banana pepper,
black olive, goat cheese.		 $23.00
Alex’s BBQ Grippo
Sweet Baby Ray’s® BBQ, chicken, bacon, onion, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo’s chips.		 $23.00
Ace
Pesto, Italian sausage, onion, green pepper and cheese.		 $20.75
Malia’s Hawaiian
Pizza sauce, capicola, green pepper, pineapple.		 $20.75
Leta Fajita
Spicy garlic ranch, chicken, tomato, onion, jalapenos, Cheddar, topped with swirl of sour cream.		 $20.75
Lucky Luke
Red sauce, bacon, sausage, onion, pickles and Cheddar, topped with a swirl of mustard.		 $23.00
Jacob’s Inferno
Pizza sauce, onion, green pepper, jalapeno, habanero.		 $20.75
Debbie’s Veggie
Pesto, onion, tomato, green pepper, mushroom,
banana pepper, black olive, green olive.		 $23.00
Kristina’s Kindness
Olive oil, garlic, capicola, tomato, mushroom, Blue cheese crumbles.		 $23.00
Simpson’s Way
Sweet Baby Ray’s® BBQ sauce, pulled pork, bacon, pineapple, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo’s chips.		 $23.00
Signature Pizzas 16″
“Brent The Bull” Meat
Pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, capicola, bacon.		 $27.50
Debbie’s Veggie
Pesto, onion, tomato, green pepper, mushroom,
banana pepper, black olive, green olive.		 $30.00
Simpson’s Way
Sweet Baby Ray’s® BBQ sauce, pulled pork, bacon, pineapple, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo’s chips.		 $30.00
Bella Maria
Olive oil, garlic, tomato, basil, Feta.		 $27.50
Good Fellow
Pizza sauce, capicola, sausage, onion, green pepper, tomato, mushroom, banana pepper, green & black olive, pineapple, bacon, pepperoni.		 $32.25
Hot Garlic Parmesan
HGP sauce, chicken, onion, banana pepper,
topped with swirl of ranch dressing.		 $27.50
Red Tony
Red sauce on top of sliced Provolone and Parmesan.		 $24.15
Pat’s Meatball
Marinara, sliced meatballs, onion, basil and cheese.		 $30.00
Louie’s Love
Olive oil, garlic, artichoke hearts, banana pepper,
black olive, goat cheese.		 $30.00
Alex’s BBQ Grippo
Sweet Baby Ray’s® BBQ, chicken, bacon, onion, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo’s chips.		 $30.00
Ace
Pesto, Italian sausage, onion, green pepper and cheese.		 $27.50
Malia’s Hawaiian
Pizza sauce, capicola, green pepper, pineapple.		 $27.50
Leta Fajita
Spicy garlic ranch, chicken, tomato, onion, jalapenos, Cheddar, topped with swirl of sour cream.		 $27.50
Lucky Luke
Red sauce, bacon, sausage, onion, pickles and Cheddar, topped with a swirl of mustard.		 $30.00
Kristina’s Kindness
Olive oil, garlic, capicola, tomato, mushroom, Blue cheese crumbles.		 $30.00
Jacob’s Inferno
Pizza sauce, onion, green pepper, jalapeno, habanero.		 $27.50
Create Your Own Pizza
Build Your Own 9″ Cheese Pizza
Our pizza is hand tossed, with crushed red tomato sauce, 50/50 blend Mozz & Prov, topped with 9 blend GF spice.		 $9.75
Build Your Own 12″ Cheese Pizza
Our pizzas come with traditional tomato-based red sauce and are seasoned with GoodFellows signature 9 blend spice “GF spice”.		 $15.00
Build Your Own 16″ Cheese Pizza
Our pizzas come with traditional tomato-based red sauce and are seasoned with GoodFellows signature 9 blend spice “GF spice”.		 $18.50
Pasta
Scott’s Spaghetti
Goodfellow’s signature marinara, Parmesan, GF spice.		 $8.00
Kid’s Menu
Cheese Pizza (8″) $8.00
Chicken Quesadilla
Includes drink and side.		 $8.00
Kid’s Burger
Beef patty with American cheese, with side and drink.		 $8.00
Meatballs
2 meatballs with garlic toast and drink.		 $8.00
Dipping Sauce
Dipping Sauce $1.00
Desserts
Maggie’s Cinnamon Sticks
Made with fresh pizza dough, butter, cinnamon, sugar, side of warmed cannoli filling.		 $9.20
Steveo’s S’mores Pizza
Fresh pizza dough, Nutella, marshmallows, crumbled graham crackers, chocolate syrup.		 $11.50
Piper’s Cannoli
4 mini Italian pastries filled with our own special sweet Ricotta with chocolate chips, whipped cream, chocolate, caramel syrup.		 $9.20
Beverages
Soft Drinks
Add a drink to your order		 $4.60
Red Bull
8.4 oz Redbull Can		 $5.85
Juice $4.60
Sugar Free Redbull
8.4 oz Sugar Free Redbull can		 $5.85

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Long Legged One
Nestled in Cincinatti it looks on a few town lines, this place is a classic gem. I got the classic cheese pizza 16 in for $16. The pizza is done Omaha style as it resembled that as well as east coast style pizza and have not had flat Chicago style all that often as id just get deep dish if i was getting that. Id say the way it’s cut up is Omaha style. This pizza is on the level of the best pizza cities. If there’s any pizza better, people pay expensive transportation to go there and eat them and wait a long time so all things considered, it’s worth it just to come to a place like this if they’re around you. Servers are great in there, you can tell they take pride in their business. Bathrooms on opposite sides however..

… more

Elizabeth
Came in a few minutes after opening midweek. Waitress was prompt. Started out with garlic bread and deviled eggs, both came within minutes. Bread was excellent, eggs were fine but had a mustard based filling (I prefer mayonnaise.) Next we ordered The Goodfellow and Louie’s Love with no banana peppers (pictured below!) Both were super tasty.

… more

Kyle H
Pizza was very good! We got a pepperoni and a good fellow pizza and both were delicious. We had the pepp balls and cheese bread to start and I can recommend the cheese bread. My picky eater kids had the spaghetti and a meatball sub which they both finished and were very happy with. Our server did a great job and was very attentive and friendly, and was quick to help when we had an issue. We will definitely be stopping in for more pizza the next time we’re in Cincinnati.

… more

Adam Schweitzer
I went here with my two year old daughter trying to get a slice of pizza and a drink at 6:45 on a Saturday and I was treated not welcomed because I had a child. The younger guy at the front acted like he needed to ask management if I was even allowed inside. Go to tap house instead they allowed to sit have food and drinks without the hassle.

… more

Cruisin 4 Jesus
We went here for my wife’s Birthday we had such a Great time…Owner is Kyle very very nice man. The food is Fresh and is Amazing… I look forward to going back again.

… more

Corey Wright
Fantastic Pizza. Sauce was good. They dont hold back on the toppings. Recommended by a client and he was 100% correct. If in the Anderson area, eat here before you go to movies.

… more

Miranda Knight
We went in today for lunch and didn’t have the greatest experience. We ordered two pizzas, salad and the deviled eggs for our appetizer.

… more

david kuhn
First time ordering from here and kept it simple. Cheese pizza, spaghetti, and the bbq pulled pork tacos. Everything was really good and still only spent about 35 or 40 bucks. Will definitely order again!

… more

Darin Bowman
One of my favorite places. Friendly staff and good food. I have only had once or twice that my pizza was overcooked or not good from sitting out too long, but they are always happy to make things right if something is wrong. This is out of many years and many many visits. They seemed to have stepped up their game since Covid.

… more

Brian Ashley
Pizza is barely even edible. Horrible. I think it’s bad garlic causing the issue.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch