Eatery with covered patio seating offers dine-in or take-out pies & other Italian fare. Based on 286 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
6645 Midnight Pass Rd, Siesta Key, FL 34242
Phone: (941) 349-4490
Website: https://www.citypizzasrq.com/?utm_source=GMB&utm_medium=GMB%20Visitors&utm_campaign=Organic%20GMB
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 3–11 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Matthew Hall
I live in a city that has 12 pizza options in a 10 mile radius. With a world of choice I have high expectations for anything so simple and available. Saying all that … I was trulely disappointed with this place. Very curious how it is still in business. Carry out wait time was 1 hr 10 mins. Strangly arranged to pick up right when they close. When I picked it up… The place was empty and for an island known for it’s bar hopping I thought that was strange. The pizza it’s self ($16 for a large pepperoni) was terrible . The dough was old (did not rise) pepperoni wasn’t cooked like it had gone through a pizza oven. Was this this an attempt at New York style pizza? Fail! If you have taken the time to read all this and still want pizza do yourself a favor and go to Pi on the Northside of the island.
… more
scott bird
Underwhelming. Too bad. Toppings were very sparse. Asked for extra cheese – didn’t get it – or hope that’s not what they consider to be extra cheese. Tomato sauce needs to go to the edges. Pizzas expensive these days – you’d like to feel like you got your moneys worth. By the way – We appreciate the friendly service from the staff – but that’s not enough for us to come back.
… more
Tim Lynn
Now named Pizza and Brew. They have both indoor and outdoor seating. They specialize in the beer, but also have a full bar and wine. Prices and the food were satisfactory.
… more
Stacey Rose
This was the worst pizza! Wasn’t ready when i got there, extra cheese as you can see was barely any and some didn’t have it all, it was soggy and cold even though, i had to wait for it to come out.
… more
John Ratzke
So glad we found this place. The table was clean and service was quick. The dinner salad had nice toppings, like cheese and olives. The fountain coke was delightful, but the star of the show was the pizza. We got a cheese pizza and being from the suburbs of Philly, I have certain expectations. The pizza was superb. The right amount of sauce and cheese. The crust was perfection. Spoke to the owner and found out she was from New York. No wonder the pizza is delicious. Thanks for a great dinner.
… more
Carrie Guy
I ordered a margarita pizza and there was no basil or pesto on it. The cheese pizza with tomato that I received was very bland. The crust was good. I would recommend adding flavorful toppings as the sauce does not flavor the pizza at all. They should consider adding some Italian seasoning and/or parmigiana cheese for flavor. The staff was very nice.
… more
Peter McGhee
Such a disappointment. I ordered several pizzas a year ago while visiting and they charged me $680 instead of $68.00. I figured it was an innocent error and had them correct it. Now, a year later, I order again for delivery and they never showed up despite assurances they would. Bottom line, I tried to support independent businesses but in the end, my kids never enjoyed the pizza they expected. Never again.
… more
S S
Good pizza but that’s about it.
… more
Debbie Livorsi
At first I was very nervous about the poor reviews that this place had. Usually low stars means bad food, but that was far from it! The pizza is AWESOME! My husband and I are pizza critics as well. We’ve gotten complacent with “Florida” pizza, having grown up NJ and NY (respectively), so to have this place close to the house we were staying in, we were just ecstatic! We will definitely order pizza from here again.
… more
Rosemary Garner
It’s now called Pizza n’ Brew.
… more
… View more