Based on 191 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1852 US-40, Clayton, IN 46118
Phone: (317) 839-4900
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Leonard Caponegro
This was our first and definitely not our last visit. We ordered the Cheese Bread and it did not disappoint. It was full of stretchy cheese on top of a puffy dough with a crispy crust with a nice chew. I could have had that as my main dish it was that delicious. For the main course we ordered the Addy’s Favorite XL Pizza, and that was equally delicious. Again, lots of stretchy cheese with a puffy dough, and once again a crispy crust with a good chew that is reminiscent of a NY Style Pizza. I also like the nice selection of beers to choose from. The staff was friendly, helpful and attentive.
… more
Eric Turner
We visited CJs pizza in Clayton and is was so unique. The tap room is so ingenious, you have a pour card and sample self serve style, any one of the current guest beers. We went for the beer, but we were pleasantly surprised with the quality and selection of food.
… more
Dan Piotrowski (drpiotro)
An unexpected treat and surprise. Visited after going to our favorite greenhouse. Staff were friendly and helpful. Interior was clean. Salad bar was stocked and fresh. Our kids loved the “very cheesy pizza” , we had calzones and those are nearly 2 meals a piece. Great value great place. Will come back for sure.
… more
Jennifer Drzakowski
The service/delivery at this location has declined incredibly over the last several months. We used to absolutely love it and told so many people about this place, but we just can’t bring ourselves to refer anyone any more. We have been patient and just let it go when we had to wait hours for food, received cold food or the wrong food, but the customer service continues to decline. We have gone into the restaurant and there was no lettuce when we paid for the salad bar. We have waited for over an hour for food when we ordered in. Tonight, our delivery was 45+ minutes late and they wanted to credit us 20% of our full order. I want to love this place because we are fully behind supporting local and we have really enjoyed several of the servers, but they can’t seem to keep good workers long enough to maintain decent service.
… more
Steven H
Man, wish I had discovered this place years ago!
… more
Jason Perry
Fresh salad bar and fresh pizza buffet(went on a Sunday). Great selection of Indiana beers. Place was very clean and the kitchen was putting out a good variety of fresh pizzas for the buffet. Pepperoni rolls are delicious and also on the buffet!!
… more
Jake Stiles
Our vehicle broke down so we walked over to this place. Pleasantly surprised, we had wings and pizza and they were both amazing! If you are out this way, give this place a shot, you won’t be disappointed.
… more
James Gordy
Everything was great!! The self-pour beer taps were easy to use with a great number of choices. The pizza comes out a little more doughy, would prefer it cooked just a tad longer.
… more
Holly Brunes
Love their all u can eat buffet! I have a unique allergy, they remember me AND the allergy and start my special pizza when we walk in. Without even asking!! A+ and kudos to the entire staff. Feels like family when you walk in!
… more
Steven
Really like the place, good pizza, salad bar. The idea of the tap room and how you pay for the beer. Great selection.
… more
… View more