Coal Oil Johnny’s Eatery Menu – Pleasantville, PA

Type : American restaurant

Location : Pleasantville, PA

Based on 369 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Coal Oil Johnny's Eatery 16341

Address:
117 E State St, Pleasantville, PA 16341

Phone: (814) 589-5500

Website:

Hours

Wednesday 8 AM–2 PM
Thursday 8 AM–2 PM
Friday 6 AM–8 PM
Saturday 6 AM–2 PM
Sunday 6 AM–2 PM
Monday 8 AM–2 PM
Tuesday 8 AM–2 PM

Menu

Sandwiches / Small Plates
Sky High Reuben $5.95
Club Sandwich $4.95
Entrees
Haddock Dinner $8.95
Roast Turkey Dinner $7.45
Meat Loaf $8.45
Baked Ham $7.95
Slow Roasted Roast Beef Dinner $8.45
Desserts
Caramel Apple Nut Pie $2.95

… View more

Reviews

Jenica Myers
Sweet little eatery, a busy place because everyone wants to eat here! With good reason! Food is fantastic staff is friendly and funny even with every table full!

… more

The_Squatch_ Trek
Food was pretty great! Really enjoyed the eggs benedict. Service was fast and timely. Frequently check to see if we need to refills of coffee. I would highly recommend this place for anyone looking for a good breakfast with a home-cooked feel

… more

brandy yoho
The waitresses are amazing. Food is great. Ask for their home made sausage. Coffee cups never go empty. Great environment.

… more

Beetle Builder
We had a very large group (about 30 people). The servers were friendly but the service was rather slow. Our large group was probably the reason for the slow service. The prices for the food were reasonable and the food was very good. I was disappointed with the portion sizes though. They were too small and I left still hungry. I do have a very healthy appetite though.

… more

M Ault
Lovely, clean, well run diner. Good was tasty and fresh. Will be back.

… more

Trish Baker
We had the turkey and Salisbury Steak dinners. HOMEMADE and AMAZING.

… more

Julie Ellis
It has a Small Home Town Feel, where none is a stranger!

… more

Susan Brandt
Great breakfast!! We do not go here often, only when in town, our hunting cabin is nearby. Best meals next to our homemade. Some even better. Get the pie.

… more

Adelaide Matteson – Shears
Great food and service was good. Very homey atmosphere. Didn’t wait long for food after order. Highly recommend for breakfast!

… more

Betsy Rounds
Great service, friendly staff, homey atmosphere, EXCELLENT breakfasts.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions