Based on 175 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
61 53rd St, Marathon, FL 33050
Phone: (305) 414-8626
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Mike Giacometti
This place is a gem, a must go for lovers. My wife and I were planning to go to a fancy dinner, but found Coast to Coast Pizza on the way and called an audible. Boy are we glad we did. The team at C2CP were a delight, the pizza… incredible, and the TMNT arcade game make this local business special.
… more
Julia B
The pizza is good but honestly, the calzone was the shining star. The bread is very good and if you get NY pizza you just don’t get to experience the amazing bread.
… more
MaryLynn Harrington
We saw this restaurant reviewed on TikTok and had to check out if it lived up to the hype. We we’re definitely pleased. I got a slice to try first and then took a pie to go. My sister got a white pizza. I’ll definitely check that out next! Definitely the best pizza in the keys! This is no my go to pizza place!
… more
Deb Clif
We are from north Jersey and this place ranks pretty high on our families pizza list for being away from our hometown. Owners/staffers were very friendly. Everything teas very fresh. Fries, pizza, and sandwich were all very good with a homey taste!
… more
Tyler Jones
Pizza was great as were the mozzarella knots. Everyone we spoke to was kind and helpful
… more
James Wilson
Pizza was delicious! It’s definitely worth a visit if on Marathon. Had the “Amazing 7.7,” which is named after the score the Barstool Sports founder gave this slice, which I would agree was a tasty slice of cheese. Also did a Detroit style pie too, which reminded me of many of the pies we have in the Midwest. Added a key lime pie slice for dessert, which was a little pricey but very tasty! The women working the counter were friendly but the one lady was a bit slow getting the order in, which delayed our pizza being ready sooner. Overall, I would recommend, esp. for kids!
… more
Kara Dempsey
I’ve been to a lot of pizza places and this has to be one of my favorite pizza’s I’ve ever had. Not only is the pizza delicious (recommend a Detroit style Grandma) but the co-owner is fantastic as well. I wasn’t able to get her name but she was so kind and hospitable!
… more
Aaron B
Between 4 and 5 but they are very fast even for a from scratch calzone. I was exceptionally happy with how fast they had everything ready. Steak calzone is pretty good. The part that looks like it doesn’t have anything in it actually has cheese baked into the bread and is quite tasty. Can’t go wrong with the ready made NY cheese either. We had three of those.
… more
Beth Hayes
I LOVE PIZZA! I could eat it every day. And if I did, and if I lived in Florida, I would ONLY eat it from Coast to Coast Pizza! The crust is soooo good. Both the thin and thick crust has a great texture. My family agreed it was the best white pizza we ever had. The pepperoni with the hot honey drizzle … mind blowing good!!! I could eat the pesto by itself.
… more
Ben Bortner
Got the NY 7.7 and it was true to it’s word, as good as a New York pizza. Even my snobby NYC fiance was impressed.
… more
… View more