Based on 185 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
116 S Broad St, Grove City, PA 16127
Phone: (724) 458-7900
Website: http://www.coffarospizza.com/index.html
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Monday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
Reviews
Steven FinGado
I was at a conference in Grove City on 8/2/23. I stopped in for lunch and ordered a large stromboli. I must say, it was probably one of (if not) the best strombolis I have ever eaten and the price was very good. The owner seemed very proud of his work and made us feel welcome. The next time I am in Grove City or passing through hungry, I am definitely stopping in for another large stromboli without ham.
… more
Kaelee Breese
Honestly the best pizza I’ve had in a LONG time. The cheesy bread sticks are absolutely amazing and the chicken bacon ranch pizza is the best I’ve had from anywhere! Customer service is ALWAYS top tier and the delivery drivers are the nicest people! The pizza is always delivered or picked up hot and fresh and perfectly cooked! And they most definitely aren’t afraid to pack the toppings on! My boyfriend and I will probably never get pizza from anywhere else in grove city again, and it’s became a weekly thing for us to order from here! Not to mention, it makes me super happy that they’re open later than all of the other pizza places around!
… more
Ernie McMann
We were passing thru the area for the first time while camping. I ordered a pizza having never been there before and didn’t know what to expect. Pleasantly surprised, professional, friendly, on time and everyone liked the pizza. What else could you ask for. When camping in the area again or just passing thru we will stop at Coffaro’s Pizza again.
… more
Rachel Hephner
This has been our go to pizza place for years; incredible food and very kind people. Highly recommend over any other establishment including the Dominos. If you’re in town for any length of time you have to try their pizza!
… more
Michael Paisley
Awesome and friendly as you can get. The calzones are huge, great sauce and fresh as it gets. The dough is fresh and easy to tell its a hometown diamond in the rough. Definitely will be a steady customer moving forward. Also they sell by the slice…perfect for a fast bite!!!
… more
Nic Chiappini
I had to reach out and give a little bit of credit because this is some of the best pizza and sides we have had in such a long time from anywhere local. We had a couple orders of their hot wings which were cooked perfectly, and the seasoning was very good, as well as an order of their jalapeño poppers and fried mushrooms, which were again fantastic and we had a few pizzas, chicken bacon ranch, a meat, lovers and a deluxe and I don’t give reviews very often but I will tell you this everything was delicious. Come to find out they are locally owned as well. Give them a shot, you will not be disappointed. We appreciate your dedication to good food and your delivery service is on point
… more
Maureen Salmen
I have ordered lunch on 2 different dates and the delivery has been late each time. I do not recommend. When I tried to contact them, I was put on hold and not able to speak to a live person.
… more
NSS54 (NSS54)
Pizza not worth 1 star. Picked up a pizza on my way home Friday night, when I ordered it I was told 30-35 minutes before it would be ready. In 25 minutes I picked up a COLD, OVERDONE pizza. Crust was harder than the box it came in, when I asked how early I should have been there to avoid it being placed on top of the oven, I was told just depended on how busy they were, no time frame was given. If this was 1st time I would make an exception but it has happened at least 3 times, needless to say we will go elsewhere for our pie.
… more
Nick
When you ask for extra sauce and cheese you get lite cheese and sauce slopped on top of the cheese
… more
Kimberly Smock
In town for weekend & plan to eat pizza most of the time… pizza from somewhere else. Called & asked if they had pizza specials ” we have a lg 3 topping for $13.99″ so I asked if we could have just cheese, she said sure. WOW! there’s hardly any cheese. If this is 3 toppings, I’d hate to see just a single topping. Idk where pizza is coming from tomorrow but definitely NOT HERE!
… more
… View more