When you want food in Irving, NY, come to Colony Seafood And Steakhouse! We offer Italian food, gourmet dining, catering, and much more. We pride ourselves on the excellent service we provide to our customers and our affordable rates. Our food is prepared with the freshest ingredients and our staff is friendly. For great service in Irving, NY, call on Colony Seafood And Steakhouse.
Based on 497 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
876 Main Rd, Irving, NY 14081
Phone: (716) 934-4826
Website: https://www.colonyseafoodandsteakhouse.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: colonyseafoodandsteakhouse.com
Reviews
Mountain Guide
We had a great meal at Colony Seafood and Steakhouse. Each of us ordered a different menu item and we all enjoyed our meals. The portion sizes were plentiful and if it wasn’t so good, it may have been enough to serve two people. The staff was attentive and friendly.
… more
Bonnielee Mikula
A great place to eat great food, relax and have a drink. We had the Haddock fish fry, a lot of food, too much to eat at one sitting. We should have shared. Service, Cheryl, was wonderful and attentive. Well decorated and music was low so we could chat. Clean and neat throughout the restaurant. Fish fry was $19.00, with an apperterizer a coke and a beer with tip for 2 was $79.00. Well worth everything! Stop in, you will be more than pleased and full.
… more
Deb Hanks
Wonderful service. Food was wonderful. You get enough for the $. I had the surf & turf mini, hubby blacken swordfish. The he had creme brule . Absolutely no complaints. Cheryl was our server and she was wonderful. Highly recommend.
… more
Ken Bush
Third time there. Great food. I’ve had Italian and steak before. Last night was crab stuffed Lake Erie walleye. Very good. Love the bread, salad was the right size. Meal complimented with baked mash potato served on the skin, mixed veggies and a small sampling of corn on the cob. Server was very good despite the dining room being packed. Restrooms small and not real handicap accessible. I like Coke and it’s a Pepsi establishment. Celebrated a birthday last night. Dessert fabulous.
… more
Christina H
Got take out from here (first time ordering/eating any of their food) I placed an order for takeout. The woman didn’t ask me if I wanted mac or potato salad so I guess it defaulted to potato salad unfortunately. Still not bad, but then there was a bone in the fish (haddock fish fry). I’ve been reviewing for 4 years now and have never had a fish bone (choking hazard) in any of my food. I understand it’s an honest mistake, but if you’re charging high prices the food needs to be up to par for the cost. Fries were soggy (understandable, even though it’s a 5 minute drive from this restaurant to our house) but very VERY bland. No salt, pepper, garlic, NADA. Maybe this is the best place out here, but if that’s the case then it’s a VERY low bar for good food out here.
… more
Dan Titus
Great family steakhouse. Great prices. Not many steakhouses have soup or salad along with potato and vegetables included in the price. 42.00 for huge porterhouse steak cup of French onion soup twice baked potato and vegetables
… more
Donna Luh
My husband had scallops. Delicious. Surf and turf was not. Steak was not edible. I sent the entire piece back. No credit to bill. Lobster piece would fit in a tablespoon. I would go back but would never order surf and turf there again.
… more
Michelle Rudy
Went there for my Dad’s anniversary! Great staff, food, and great time! Shrimp is so big and yummy! Duck is amazing! Jambalaya, nice kick! Surf n turf amazing!
… more
Adam Wilmot
Awesome food, awesome bar. I’ve had the garlic rubbed T-bone, the veal colony, Alaskan crab legs, crab cakes, clams casino, and the red sauce is amazing. The make an excellent Mule and Old Fashioned. Definitely recommend
… more
Dave Hart
We went tonite for our 26th wedding anniversary. We ordered filet steaks. The wait staff ( our wait person was named Shirley) Excellent service, she was very quick in taking care of us. Also, the young man taking dishes out of the way, was very polite. The whole experience was great. Our steaks cooked the way WE wanted. Thanks Colony
… more
… View more