Easygoing, strip-mall outlet featuring pizza, sandwiches, bagels & pastas alongside desserts. Based on 231 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Phone: (360) 378-8308
Hours
| Thursday | 9 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 9 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 9:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 9 AM–7 PM |
| Monday | 9 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 9 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 9 AM–8 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Laura Rosenberg
Forget about it!
… more
madison leigh
We called ahead, owner asked what we liked, and we got a masterpiece. My husband didn’t even want to add ranch (he’s a ranch on pizza kinda guy) so that tells you of Vinnie’s superior craft. God bless u, “cousin Vinnie.”
… more
Anavil Tripathi
We were in a hurry to go for whale watching and wanted a vegetarian pizza. He made sure to prepare a vegetarian pizza with all the toppings he had and the pizza was delicious. He also made a lot of efforts to get us everything on time. I would recommend the place as good vegetarian pizza place.
… more
Tony Thompson
Great, quick pizza by the slice. Closest thing to NY pizza I’ve had in a long time. Staff was super friendly. Will continue going back.
… more
Benjamin Watterson
Ordered pizza and pasta. Pizza was totally burnt and tasted bad, couldn’t eat it. Pasta was ok. Very expensive for what it was. No menu, so you just tell him what you want. Didn’t know the prices until after everything was ordered. Took 40 minutes to make.
… more
Amberlea Rose
Wonderful New York pizza and cheese steak. No dining room but a couple of tables in the area to sit and eat.
… more
Emmy MacDonald
This sad photo is all that remains of excellent pizza. Frankly this reminds me of really good pizza I had growing up in NJ. This is the real deal.
… more
jack lamb
This restaurant was a very tasty and delicious place. Vinnie was a very nice and funny guy to talk to, and you could tell he has a knack for making great pizza. It is definitely worth the price. Best place in Friday Harbor!
… more
Kaley Broome
Real NYC Pizza! My partner and I were amazed to find such an authentic pie this far west. If you are looking for that classic foldable slice, look no further. Vinnie is very friendly and had a chat with us while our slices were made. I would leave more stars if I could. It is a shame this place is so far from my place in Seattle, we would come more often if we could. If you think you only want a slice or two, trust us – get a whole pie, you won’t regret it!
… more
Eric Dalquist
Vinnie was great to talk to and the pizza was even better. Our ferry was late getting to the island and Vinnie’s was open and right there. The small hole in the wall place was a little tricky to find (it’s in the hallway of a Larger building) but it was worth getting to. A take away pizza was exactly what we wanted and everyone loved it.
… more
… View more