Laid-back pizza chain serving classic & creative NYC-style pies, plus chicken wings & breadsticks. Based on 384 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
4658 Kenny Rd, Columbus, OH 43220
Phone: (614) 459-4400
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4 PM–3 AM |
| Thursday | 4 PM–3 AM |
| Friday | 4 PM–3 AM |
| Saturday | 4 PM–4 AM |
| Sunday | 4 PM–4 AM |
| Monday | 4 PM–3 AM |
| Tuesday | 4 PM–3 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Caitlyn Kinnaman
Favorite takeout pizza in Columbus. The hand tossed AND thin crust are fantastic. Cheese is quality, vegetables are fresh and flavorful, crust has a satisfying chewiness and texture. The veggie sub doesn’t rely on slimy mushrooms for flavor (making it a standout from every other pizza place around town). Even cold the next day, this pizza is superb. Great deals on combos, AND they’re open later than anyone else? Try this pizza.
… more
Mike Harris
Great Pizza! Quick Service. Actually cooked to their timing, the sauce is dried up. I ask for mine to be cooked lighter, then there is the right amount of sauce, for those who like a pizza that doesn’t have too much sauce. I would recommend they cook all their pizzas lighter to speed up service, which isn’t a problem & to conserve on resources.
… more
Abdi Ali
Truly one of the worst experiences I’ve had with a restaurant in my entire lifetime.If you have the power from stopping your loved ones or friends from going here please do that ASAP!!!! I ordered a small pizza a “5pc wings” and the sweet bread I never received but instead got regular garlic bread the pizza straight up tasted like it got pulled out from a microwave so freaking nasty I guess it was like that cuz it was small dont make that mistake and please don’t do delivery if I could give that money I just wasted to a homeless I would the wings felt like I was eating small chicken nuggets but they was very good not gonna lie that’s the only good thing small tiny wings please do better cousin Vinny
… more
Michael Irzyxel
I have only walked in, ordered and waited. The staff was helpful and my food was ready quickly. Visited twice.
… more
J W
One of the best privately owned shops in Columbus, OH. Top shelf ingredients generously used.
… more
Greg Freeman
The website works as it should. Lacking a confirmation page is not up to the time and date.
… more
Josh Low SPS
The pizza is good, but they make too many mistakes that are frustrating to deal with. Today has been the last time that I order from them without being there in person to correct it or try the sodas before leaving. It’s frustrating and was offered no help or even sympathy when calling the store. If the orders were complete and correct it would be worth their prices, but dealing with them is no longer worth it. Good riddance Cousin Vinny!
… more
Heather Spurrill
I’d give no stars if I could. We ordered late night but more than an hour before close and we got a 50 min estimate on delivery specifically from them not through another service. No one showed up. Called the store repeatedly no answering device just hangs up after many rings. Went to the store prior to closing time and it was empty lights out locked. Emailed store about issue haven’t heard back yet. Called store yesterday no answer, today answered was put on hold for 5 mins and hung up on. Unreliable and no communication. There aren’t a ton of food options open late but if I cannot rely on communication about the order before everything is closing at the very least then there’s really no point trying to do business with them. Sharing because I don’t want others to run into the issue without warning.
… more
Logan Cochran
Online says open til 3AM. I called one night a couple weeks ago close to 2AM, no answer. Called again this time it got picked up. I asked, “I was wondering if you guys were still open?” And all I got was “No.” and the phone hung up on me.
… more
A P
The customer service here was amazing! The employee on the phone with me was very patient and answered all my questions. Then, when I went to pick up my order, another employee helped me put some of the items in my car, which I appreciate a lot! The pizza and breadsticks are so yummy too. Will be ordering again
… more
… View more