Chill restaurant & bar offering food such as pizza, wings, burgers & cheesesteaks, plus lots of TVs. Based on 215 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $
Address:
1270 E Philadelphia St, York, PA 17403
Phone: (717) 846-7499
Website: http://www.crazytomatopa.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Kait Dalton
We always come up for the cheese steak pretzel bolis. Absolutely top notch! We travel about 40 minutes just for them. The staff is always super personable and our food is always ready in a timely fashion. Great place!
… more
Heather Wartburg
Ordered on a Thursday night and we live around the corner. Took over an hour for a food to arrive, they called to say they had no mushrooms for my Stromboli. Ordered Fresh Cut Fries and they were shoestring fries, half burnt and cold. Hadn’t ordered for awhile from them and was completely disappointed. Got a cheese pizza too and the cheese was “well done” on top. Very very disappointed especially for the price we paid.
… more
Damiam Smith
Great place to eat! Staff is great and friendly. I can’t eat dairy and every time I order I never have to worry that they put dairy on my pizza, boli, or sub, they listen. Awesome place!
… more
Ami Champlain
We moved here from New York and we’ve been struggling to find real pizza, and this place is it! Great tasting sauce with a slight sweetness, great seasoning so it smells like Italian food should! The 2 for $22 deal is awesome! You pay a couple of dollars more for the pretzel boli but it’s so worth it!!! Great flavor, we’ve found our new pizza place home! Now if we could just find a real bakery with some layered cakes, fresh bread and bagels with flavored cream cheese, and some lobster tails and cannoli!
… more
Evan Eavanson
Pretzel Stromboli is absolutely delicious and staff was super friendly for a pickup from store. If you want really good food, get a pretzel boli! It is very delicious
… more
Jim Martin
The best Hawaiian pizza I have ever eaten.. There was a live turkey in the parking lot.. Lol
… more
Lori Leiphart
Pizza extra cheese was well done. Naked wings they were out of stock yet again. they do have breaded cauliflower which is so good. Practicing social distancing a mask is not required but I usually order and wait in my car and they bring it out no problem but you have to go in and pay first when you place your order. The staff is so friendly. I only give it a three star due to not being able to get items on the menu it’s not their fault I understand that but being prepared for customers needs to be looked at a little bit better and when ordering supplies. Otherwise their food’s pretty good not sure about delivery times I’m sure that they can get backed up just like everywhere else I would say at least an hour.
… more
Chandra Illarza
Cheese on pizza was black. I looked past that tried it and cheese tasted burnt. Crust was perfect. I won’t order again.
… more
kat Santiago
Cheese pizzas were ok. Nothing special about it.
… more
Mr. Eaton
Made a good size order, first time with this place. Maybe should have read some reviews on them first. I order a large pep pizza, a cheese burger sub, a Crazy steak sub and a chicken finger basket. First with the pizza the sauce seamed spoiled had a weird taste and the sauce seamed water down. I want the two subs buns toasted and they were not with the cheese burger sub I had bacon added and it looked like they use the bacon pcs that they put on the pizza and there wasn’t much of it and the cheese and bacon was cold. The burger tasted like it was sitting in water. With they carzy steak it seamed they used very cheap cheese, the chicken basket the fries were tiny and burnt and it only came with 3 small chicken strip that was also over cooked. I will never go back.
… more
… View more