Long-running pizzeria chain turning out a menu of standards, including strombolis & calzones. Based on 40 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
22 S Main St, Mechanicsburg, OH 43044
Phone: (937) 834-5144
Website: https://crenospizzaco.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Christopher Baker
The pizza had minimal sauce, minimal cheese. There was a 1 1/2 inch ring of just dough around the outside. The dough tasted like it had been frozen and freezer burnt. The pieces were cut into too large of pieces. They gave a 45 minute time frame for a pickup order. I love trying new foods and am happy to see new businesses in the burg, however I would order from Frostys or Ronados before getting this pizza again.
… more
Heath Miller
Really happy there is finally a foodservice business that delivers in Mechanicsburg.
… more
mac man
Nothing really special about this place. The menu has no prices on it on the wall. A basic ham and cheese sub sandwich is $10.. lack of choices in town allows them to charge a higher price for their food.
… more
Rachel Simpson
Called in to order a pizza and a few subs for my family and I . The guy that answered the phone was rude . My husband goes to pick up the food walks in and a male behind the counter put his hand up his shirt and was touching his belly and back and then was touching food with no gloves on. And didn’t even wash his hands afterwards. So disgusting. My husband left without the order and called me . I called the store and the same guy that answered the first time answered again. I asked to speak to a manager he said I am a manager but when he answered the phone all he said was hello? He finally got a real manager on the phone a guy named Mike . I told him to cancel my order and told him what happened and all he said was ok. Didn’t even apologize for the other guy . Sounds like someone should be calling the health department on this place . Will never eat or order from them again. Very disappointed!!!
… more
Buffy Packard
We ordered for the first time and were happy with it. Sauce is our favorite part, it was perfect! Toppings were plentiful and the calzone was huge! Not a big fan of the long strip cutting of the pizza, but I’m sure if we ask they would cut into squares. We will order again. Oh and they deliver!! Which is a plus plus for us!
… more
todd
So the negative: slow delivery. Whatever they quote, double it. It’s a bit pricey in comparison to normal chains. No real way around it. Plus gratuitous junk mail for kind of slow service. They request that you tip the driver BEFORE they get to your home. Are tips not merit based anymore and just expected that we pay their wages regardless of work?
… more
Angela Cummings
First time trying Creno’s. So delicious. Large pepperoni pizza with light sauce, made perfectly to order. Old world style pepperoni, all great quality ingredients. Loved everything about it. Highly recommend.
… more
Linda Sloan
Ordered a pepperoni pizza with extra cheese, good thing I ordered extra cheese if I hadn’t there wouldn’t have been any cheese on it at all! Or maybe they forgot! Hardly any sauce either. Pizza had hardly any taste at all but seemed loaded with salt. The dogs enjoyed it but I won’t be going back. Pricey also. Certainly not worth the money.
… more
Clyde Jones
It’s was my son’s 5th birthday and they wrote happy birthday on the inside of his pizza box like a little surprise message. Ever since they have opened we have ordered from them and stopped ordering at the other pizza places in town. We always get Delivery and the food is always fantastic when it arrives. Thanks Crenos keep up the amazing work!
… more
Phil Blair
Excellent Blt sub. They did mess up my order, but they made it right. The food was absolutely great. I am a pretty critical person when it comes to reviews (and you can look too), but when I think something is great, should be rewarded for doing so.
… more
… View more