Long-running pizzeria chain turning out a menu of standards, including strombolis & calzones. Based on 225 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
13 E Main St, New Concord, OH 43762
Phone: (740) 826-0077
Website: http://crenospizzaco.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
hhmuskie
I’ve been going to this Creno’s Pizza shop since I was a student at Muskingum University back in 2009. I feel like the pizza shop (here in New Concord specifically) is on the decline. It used to be a fun place to hang out, but now the shop inside is always empty, even when classes are in session. It looks and feels dirty now. Tables have crumbs on them, and surfaces feel sticky. Staff is young, and is often goofing around when customers are there, including dancing and singing to music, which sometimes causes them to not hear or see that there is a customer standing at the register. They aren’t the only pizza shop in town, which a lot of people prefer over Wally’s, so I do feel like they need to work harder at keeping a good reputation in town to ensure they have a shop here in the coming future. I think Creno’s leaves a lot to desire, and I wish they’d put a little more pride into their New Concord establishment in the best interest of their community.
… more
Cory “Oak” Andrews
Excellent pizza and other foods. The owners in Zanesville sold a franchise to a friend of ours who lived in Cambridge. Then did a surprise inspection and chewed the girl behind the counter out so aggressively that when my friend got back she was crying and ran away. My friend told them they could their pizza shop and get bent! And that if he ever caught any person berating an employee of his they will regret that day. Two days later he met the corporate people in an office. My friend said he’d stay and continue his contract IF and only IF… The manager apologized to Connie. She wouldn’t. My friend signed the default waiver and walked away from the building. Case closed.
… more
Lori Baker
Ordered chicken sub no lettuce xmayo!! Got lettuce n didn’t get any xmayo!!
… more
S Lentz
I’ve had very few good experiences with this Creno’s location. The area locations have gone down hill in value, quality, and service the past few years. Tonight I ordered an XL deluxe ($21.49) well done. Not done, pepperoni still raw. There was no crust in a few places as well, and what was there was so slippery and raw the sauce stuck to the cheese. I’ve come to the conclusion they use the same amount of dough for a small as the XL. How many every day people have to work more than one hour for that pizza? Highly disappointed that we didn’t eat very much for dinner, and what was consumed was not good. It’s irritating to waste the money for food and gas, the time to pick it up, and still be hungry.
… more
Noel Foraker
We love crenos and ordered in Cambridge regularly when we lived there. When moving to new concord we were excited to have it again. Everything tastes great whenever we order from there but I once forgot to add a tip over the phone when ordering a delivery and thought we could add it when they arrived but we couldn’t …ever since then they deny delivering to my house. they even ask carry out Or delivery and when I ask for delivery they check my name then say they can’t. Most recently I came to pick it up since they told me they couldn’t deliver . I thought they were really busy bc on the phone they were rushing me but when I arrived I saw 3 workers standing around talking and sharing something on their phones laughing . When someone finally came to bring my 4 pizzas to me I never received an offer to help. I had one child in my arms and another trying to hold my hand. Another customer volunteered to help open doors for me. It’s not easy carrying 4 pizzas with two babies .. that’s why I always attempt delivery .
… more
Chris
Not bad at all. The calzone was good. The bathroom was not in good shape. The staff was very friendly.
… more
Charlie Carley
First time having their pizza. The crust is insanely thin, it could stand to be a bit thicker. Other than the crust, the pizza had a good taste.
… more
Chris Davis
This is our go-to some nights for pizza. Their pizza is always made the same which is a good thing. You know what you’re going to get. The staff is friendly. Delivery is quick as well.
… more
Larrissa Freeland
They were understaffed but handled the restaurant like bosses they were incredibly amazing and kind I will be returning
… more
Heath Alton
Best pizza I have ever had from a creno’s
… more
… View more