Long-running pizzeria chain turning out a menu of standards, including strombolis & calzones. Based on 192 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
221 N Cedar St, Newark, OH 43055
Phone: (740) 345-0544
Hours
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 12–11 PM |
| Sunday | 3–10 PM |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Elizabeth Workman
Creno’s on Cedar Street catered our wedding last night and it was AMAZING. I cannot thank them enough. Everything made it to the venue in perfect condition. We ordered around 20 pizzas and 10 pounds of wings. It arrived right on time and was SO hot. I’m blown away by how perfect it was. I overheard many conversations about how good the pizza and wings were. A huge thank you to Bert at this location for being so helpful and making this process as smooth as possible. I 10/10 recommend Creno’s in general as it’s our favorite, but I will now be able to recommend for catering. DELICIOUS!!!!
… more
Emily Logan
I called them to order for delivery they said it would be a HR. So I said how long for pick up. They said 15 -20 min. I arrived at crenos. As I was walking in there delivery driver was walking out… I paid for the food and she couldn’t find my order. I called the house and they had delivered the food and got the money. I went back to crenos and gave her the change that she gave me and asked for my money back. she said she couldn’t make her money short. She got a hold of the driver and the driver had to turn around and go give the money back. As I was pulling into the drive way the driver was pulling out. A total un needed waist of time. And my pizza was cold but still taste good…
… more
Lori Wittman
My son ordered online and the store location switched on him from the Reynoldsburg location to this location. He called to see if he could get it switched/his money back and he was given the runaround and hung up on. So, he waited and called back and the guy still didn’t give him a straight answer. This is incredibly unprofessional. He ended up paying for something he didn’t get.
… more
Erik Frahn
Ordered delivery and customer service was great. Pizza and sub arrived hot and fresh. Delivery person was fast and polite
… more
Chris Moyers
I have been ordering delivery from this location for years and today they refused to deliver to me and were very rude to me girlfriend placing the order. They wouldn’t put a manager on phone that employee kept asking questions to. Then employee tried to pull I am the manager trick after a couple repeated can I talk to a manager pleases. Not sure if it’s new employees or management team but I will take my business elsewhere.
… more
John Robinson
Honestly the best Blt pizza I’ve had so far. I’m pretty sure they buttered the crust which made it soft and a nice brown color the only reason I’m giving 4 stars instead of five is in my opinion they went a little light with the toppings yet again that’s just my opinion. It
… more
Jeremiah Hanlon
Fantastic food and service! Crenos is definitely a solid pizza choice!
… more
Dodi Zimmerman
Order the same pizza weekly. Picked up pizza and they gave me something totally different. All I received was sorry about that….
… more
tasha Webb
So I love creno wings, it’s the only pizza place with decent ones. However, the mild wings I got tasted like pure garlic. I called and told them. The manager on duty said he made the wings and “they were right”. I was livid. He didn’t even offer to replace them. I live a distance away. I will drive across town before I spend another dollar at the cedar street location
… more
Bob
I had to edit this review because a manager promised that an $18.99 credit. I called to get the credit and somehow the manager accidentally developed amnesia and didn’t remember. Oh well that’s at least one order a week they’re missing out on. Basically the food is good but the management needs some retraining I believe. But be careful when you order delivery it may be a very very long time
… more
… View more