The Tastes You Crave, The Quality You Trust Since 1985!
Have you ever wondered why Cristy’s Pizza tastes so good?
It’s simple, if you’re going to have the best pizza, you’ve gotta start with the best ingredients, like…
Bold Sweet Sauce from Fresh, Vine-Ripened Tomatoes
Signature Dough Recipe
All-Natural Premium Cheese
Fresh Vegetables
Old World Pepperoni
And of course, a team of Pizza Pros to make the best pizza every single time.
Based on 315 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1001 S Main St #12, Baltimore, OH 43105
Phone: (740) 862-6611
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kelly Brison
Best pizza in town. Love it every time we get it. Never not perfect!! The cheese and the sauce is my favorite.
… more
Rick Draudt
Cristy’s pizza and subs are amazing. We make a special trip to this particular location and the staff is awesome. Keep it up guys!
… more
KJ H
Employees are always nice but twice at this location and twice just not like Cristys in Chillicothe or Lancaster. Last night we picked our so much brown lettuce in our salad and multiple lettuce cores and there was more meat and cheese in our salad than lettuce but when our sub come out it was a mess and more salad than meat. There was a thin slice of Ham and slice of salami or pepperoni don’t know what was used on each half. The rest was bread and salad. There was only one clean booth we could find away from the AC in a place that wasn’t busy. We was excited to know Cristys as in Baltimore but not anymore. Just missing the mark a lot for a $30 meal
… more
Mary Jo Cline
Ordered Pepperoni Nibblers they were so greasy , No pepperoni only a few pieces in the whole order, Crust was old! Normally they are really good, not sure why they were super greasy and no pepperoni tonight, I did order late so maybe beware not to order at closing!
… more
Ashley Stephens
This location is less than 5 miles from my house. For 14 years Christie’s has been the only delivery service in Baltimore to bring our family dinner on those nights you just don’t feel like cooking or you just want a really good Pizza. Sure they are a bit more expensive than going to Domino’s or another place like that but we enjoy the food. However since last year after 14 years of loyal service, they are now refusing to deliver to our address. We have always tipped well and we’re always polite to the drivers. This makes me sad . Maybe they’re under New Management?
… more
BJ Meen
The pizza is AMAZING as always. Fresh, hot, cheesy, quality toppings! My absolute favorite and I highly recommend. I wish there was a location close to me in Columbus as i drive approximately 40 min but its well worth the drive.
… more
David Wilson
Went there in a snow storm. Got all the way back home and some of our order was missing. Called them back to let them know. They were incredibly rude. They actually hung up on us. All we wanted was our money refunded. Wouldn’t take our calls. Didn’t get our money back. I’ve been a customer for 7 years. I’ll never do business with them again.
… more
Whit
I recently moved to the area. We’ve been loyal Cristy’s customers thus far. Checked over purchases on our bank account and combined with the move in, in-laws pizza nights and parties, well over $1000 spent over the last 90 days. Placed a prepaid order online last night and utilized a “1/2 off one pizza” coupon code that was mailed to us. Upon arrival to the Baltimore, OH location, we were informed we would not be receiving our pre-paid order unless we presented the physical coupon. So, we ordered Creno’s. I stopped in to Christy’s after picking up our Creno’s to request a refund receipt and give the manager the coupon back. After waiting more than 10 minutes to speak with him, was advised they couldn’t provide a receipt for a voided order. As of today, I still have the $37 charge on my account. Pizza at Cristy’s was our fav, but we won’t be returning. Good luck with their service.
… more
Ricky Bobby
Very good pizza, subs, and appetizers. My favorite appetizer is the cheesy breadsticks which I was skeptical the first time I saw it upon ordering but it is phenomenal. I haven’t had a single item that I have been disappointed in. The subs are meaty and worth every penny.
… more
Tara Vacca
I have dined in many times and have had a good experience. However this time the red head kid working the counter was exceptional. He was polite, got our order in right away, and was diligent in making sure our food was correct . I will be dining here again!
… more
… View more