The Tastes Your Crave, The Quality You Trust Since 1985!
Have you ever wondered why Cristy’s Pizza tastes so good?
It’s simple, if you’re going to have the best pizza, you’ve gotta start with the best ingredients, like…
Bold Sweet Sauce from Fresh, Vine-Ripened Tomatoes
Signature Dough Recipe
All-Natural Premium Cheese
Fresh Vegetables
Old World Pepperoni
And of course, a team of Pizza Pros to make the best pizza every single time.
Based on 428 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Drive-through ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
45 E Water St, Chillicothe, OH 45601
Phone: (740) 773-1114
Hours
| Wednesday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
terena Borland
I love good pizza, so I can be a little picky. Cristy’s pizza is one of my favorites. I’m not sure what has changed because we tried them a few years back and was not impressed, but someone said they had changed and we gave them another try. Loved it! So far we have gone back 4 times and every time the pizza is great. My # 1 pet peeve with pizza places is consistency, you never get the same taste. Either it’s burnt, or cold, or not enough sauce, but it is hardly ever the same. Not here. It’s been the same every time. We love the sweet sauce.
… more
Eric Cockrell
Delivery driver left order on the porch. No knock, no call, no text. The food is good when it’s the correct order. But there is almost always an issue getting what you ordered
… more
Bradley Frank
The pizza is very good. We carried it out and when we got it back to where we needed it to be, it was hot and fresh.
… more
Rebekah Wrightsel
Paul is an awesome manager and will treat you like royalty when he is there. ! I love the new york style pepperoni it is so good!
… more
Tiffiney Adams
I used to love Cristy’s pizza but after two bad experiences in one day, I am not sure I will be back. They must have some new cooks because the quality of the food should not have passed quality review.
… more
Andrea Holmes
I placed an online delivery order for the wrong day. When I realized my error, I had 45 minutes until I needed it. I called Cristy’s and Shannon was so helpful and worked to make sure I got my order on time!!!!! She was great!!
… more
Cindy “Cyn” Diehl
They are fast and courteous. Their pizza’s are outstanding. Be careful, when pizza is hot, all toppings may hit you under your chin. That hurts. I love their Phillysteakand cheese pizza. It is so easy to bite into, toppings are generous. They have so much more.!!!
… more
Roibin Jones
Always a great pizza….second only to Pizza Crossing in Logan.
… more
Daniel Mathuews
I think the owners need to look at expanding the size of this business to accommodate the amount of demand they have. Placed an order and after 45 minutes went to pick it up. They said it would be another hour and a 1/2 because there just was not the capacity to complete the orders that they had on time.
… more
Cory Gilpen
The pizza was amazing and was glad they were open during the fireworks .
… more
… View more