Critics Choice Menu – Alexandria, LA

Type : Sandwich shop

Location : Alexandria, LA

Based on 123 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Critics Choice 71301

Address:
415 Murray St, Alexandria, LA 71301

Phone: (318) 442-3333

Website:

Hours

Sunday Closed
Monday

(Labor Day)
 10:30 AM–7 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 10:30 AM–7 PM
Wednesday 10:30 AM–7 PM
Thursday 10:30 AM–7 PM
Friday 10:30 AM–7 PM
Saturday 10:30 AM–2 PM

Menu

Side Orders
Broccoli Cheese Balls
Broccoli engulfed by cheddar cheese with a delightful light potato breading. Fried in peanut oil to perfection.		 $9.00
Zesty String Beans With Ranch
Zesty string beans dredged in seasoned flour and quick fried in the nutty taste of peanut oil. Served with ranch dressing.		 $7.50
Beer Battered Mushrooms With Ranch
Battered mushrooms fried to perfection in peanut oil and served with ranch dressing.		 $7.50
Beer Battered Onion Rings
Fall in love with our beer battered onion-rings, we’ve added the nutty flavor by frying them in peanut oil.		 $7.50
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks With Marinara
Battered mozzarella cheese stick’s served with mom’s home-made marinara sauce.		 $7.50
Freedom Fries
French fries cooked in premium peanut oil. For the tastiest fries!		 $4.80
Cheese Fries
Our tasty french fries covered in mild cheddar cheese sauce. A delicious addition to an old tradition.		 $6.00
Waffle
Cross-cut potatoes perfectly seasoned and fried in peanut oil.		 $4.80
Cheese Waffle Fries
Criss-cut potatoes seasoned and topped with a generous portion of mild cheddar cheese sauce.		 $6.00
Tangy Coleslaw
No sweet slaw here! Ours has a bite! 		$2.40
Mild Banana Peppers
Mild banana peppers to add to anything and everything.		 $0.60
Pickle Spear
Four kosher dill pickle spears, crisp and tangy		 $1.20
Italian Sauce
Mom’s home-made marinara sauce is a great with our Stromboli.		 $3.60
Potato Chips $1.20
Dressing Choices
House Italian
Oil & vinegar with our special mix of Italian seasonings.		 $0.60
Ranch
Buttermilk ranch with a little twang.		 $0.60
1000 Island
Tangy and a little sweet at the same time.		 $0.60
Blue Cheese $1.20
Salads
Tuna $15.60
Turkey
With bacon for an additional charge.		 $15.60
Char-Broiled Chicken $15.60
Deep-Fried Chicken $15.60
Deep Fried Shrimp $15.60
Child’s Menu
Grilled Cheese $4.80
Grilled Ham & Cheese
Yummy baked ham & white American Cheese toasted to perfection on the grill.
 $6.00
Personal Pizza $4.80
Chicken & Fries
Not parts and pieces, just breaded chicken tenderloin fried in wholesome peanut oil. Sliced by hand and placed on a bead of fresh french fries.
 $9.60
Philadelphia Steak Sandwich
Cheese Steak
Thinly sliced beef cooked to perfection. Served on an Italian roll with sautéed onions, mushrooms, and mild banana peppers.		 $15.00
Veggie (Meatless)
Served on an Italian roll with sautéed onions, mushrooms, lettuce, tomato, and mild banana peppers		 $12.60
Hoagies & Oven Grinders
Chicken $14.34
Italian $14.34
Ham $14.34
Tuna $14.34
Cheese $14.34
Turkey
With bacon for an additional charge.		 $14.34
Parmigiana’s
Chicken, Eggplant Or Meatball Parmigiana
Tender Italian meatballs , breaded and fried chicken or eggplant baked with mom’s Italian tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese on an Italian roll.		 $15.00
Sandwiches
Salads
Tuna, turkey, char-broiled chicken, deep-fried chicken, or fried shrimp – each served on a bed of lettuce, tomatoes, onions, crackers, salad dressing, and sweet or hot peppers.		 $15.60
Hamburger
1/2 lb. of choice beef served on a NY kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, onions. Served with kosher dill spears. Add bacon and mushrooms for an additional charge.		 $15.00
Italian Sausage Sandwich
Hot Italian sausage in spaghetti sauce on our 8-inch Italian roll. Add grilled onions and peppers for an additional charge.		 $12.60
BLT
Center-cut bacon with lettuce, tomato, and mayo, built on 3 slices of white, wheat, or rye toast.		 $12.60
Ham Club Sandwich
Triple layer of toast of your choice stacked high with lettuce, tomato and mayo.		 $12.60
Tuna Club Sandwich
Triple layer of toast of your choice stacked high with lettuce, tomato and mayo.		 $12.60
Turkey Club Sandwich
Triple layer of toast of your choice stacked high with lettuce, tomato and mayo.		 $12.60
Critics Club Sandwich, Turkey, Ham, Bacon & Cheese
Triple layer of toast of your choice stacked high with lettuce, tomato and mayo.		 $15.54
Hot Beef Sandwich
Hot roast beef simmered in a rich brown grave and served on a NY kaiser roll.		 $12.60
Corned Beef Sandwich
Thinly sliced new York corned beef with a tangy coleslaw and Russian dressing on rye bread. Served with kosher dill spears.		 $12.60
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Fried tenderloin chicken breast served on a kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, mayo or ranch dressing.		 $12.60
Stromboli
Italian luncheon meats, cheeses, and pepperoni – all baked in a specially seasoned dough for a delicious hot meal.		 $9.60
Sloppy Joe
Choice ground chuck simmered with spices.		 $12.60
Shrimp Sandwich
5 large breaded shrimp fried in peanut oil and placed in our 8” Italian roll with lettuce, tomato and your choice of mayo or tarter sauce.		 $15.60
Char Broiled Chicken Sandwhich
Char-broiled chicken breast served on a kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, mayo or ranch dressing.		 $12.60
Dinners
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Pasta dinners come with moms very own home made from scratch marinara sauce. Garlic bread, Side salad with choice of dressing on the side		 $18.00
Chicken Parmigiana & Spaghetti
Pasta dinners come with moms very own home made from scratch marinara sauce. Garlic bread, Side salad with choice of dressing on the side		 $18.00
Italian Sausage & Spaghetti
Pasta dinners come with moms very own home made from scratch marinara sauce. Garlic bread, Side salad with choice of dressing on the side		 $18.00
Lasagna
Pasta dinners come with moms very own home made from scratch marinara sauce. Garlic bread, Side salad with choice of dressing on the side		 $18.00
Eggplant Parmigiana & Spaghetti
Pasta dinners come with moms very own home made from scratch marinara sauce. Garlic bread, Side salad with choice of dressing on the side		 $18.00
Shrimp Basket
5 large shrimp breaded and fried in peanut oil in a bed of french fries.
Comes with tarter sauce and ketchup.		 $13.20
Chopped Steak Dinner $18.00
Open Faced Hot Beef Dinner
Open faced roast beef sandwich in our savory gravy served with french fries.
Plenty toy enjoy here.		 $18.00
Desserts
Italian Cannoli $5.40
New York Cheesecake $5.40
Chocolate Layer Cake $6.60
Beverages
Coke $2.46
Diet Coke $2.46
Sprite $2.46
Dr Pepper $2.46
Root Beer (Barq’s) $2.46
Hot Tea $2.46
Iced Tea (Unsweetened)
Our tea is brewed fresh every morning and is Unsweetened 		$2.46
Coffee $2.46

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Kelli Welch
I would give this place 10 stars if I could. My family and I were nearby at the hospital and decided to order a party tray with a mix of sandwiches. They prepared them fast, and they were kind and friendly. And the sandwiches are AMAZING. Turkey, chicken (think chicken parmesan without the marinara), Italian, and Philly steak. Plus a big bag of chips. It was perfect for what we needed, and absolutely delicious. Highly recommend!

… more

matthew lanclos
Good service, owner greeted us when we walked in. The food was fresh and delicious.

… more

CrowCat Review
Critics Choice is a staple and mainstay in Alexandria. They have some of the best club sandwiches and Philly cheesesteak you may possibly ever have. They have been in business for a long time and really know what they are doing.

… more

Chris Nolen
I had a really good Philly Cheese steak, one of the best I have had. The owner and wife are great people who visited.

… more

chrissy bergeron
I have been going to Critics Choice for the past 20 years. Not only is the food phenomenal, but the family makes you feel at home. I have gained some true friends over the past 20 years and I’m so thankful they have stayed open to allow the public to enjoy such great food.

… more

Jasamine Waller
Great treasure trove, it’s different but tasty. The owners are awesome and friendly. Its family owned, get time here! Definitely need to stop by if anyone passes threw Alexandria,LA. I had the poppers, it was simply sinful to eat. The philly steak was awesome with a twist. Literally a great delight, I will have to stop by again soon.

… more

Braden Martin
Born and raised in Alexandria. This place has always had great food BUT literally the rudest owner and staff ever. I’m not a regular reviewer of anything on the web but I can’t help but share this one!

… more

Joost Morsink
American diner with sandwiches and burgers. Decent food, but nothing special, except for the clown dolls that decorate the place. And they serve freedom fries.

… more

Gugu Sal
First time going there and being from jersey, there food makes me feel at home! Their mozzarella sticks are great and sandwiches taste even better!

… more

Ellen Gray
Best sandwich shop in town!! Many great choices if you want more than a sandwich.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch